AQA AS Level Physics Paper 1, June 2018: Question 4
12 marks · Hard difficulty · Extended Answer
Analyze the equilibrium of a uniform beam supported by two light cables attached to a steel cable, determining conditions for equilibrium, centre of mass, tension in the cables, and extension of the steel cable using the Young modulus.
Practise this questionQuestion
Question text
04 Figure 4 shows a uniform beam supported by two light cables, AB and AC, which are
attached to a single steel cable from a crane. The beam is stationary and in
equilibrium.
Figure 4
04.1 State two necessary conditions for the beam to be in equilibrium.
[2 marks]
Condition 1
Condition 2
04.2 State what is meant by the centre of mass.
[1 mark]
04.3 Explain why the centre of mass of the beam in Figure 4 must be vertically below A.
[2 marks]
04.4 The weight of the beam is 12 000 N
Calculate the tension T1 in cable AB and the tension T2 in cable AC.
[4 marks]
T1 = N
14 T = N
04.5 The steel cable from the crane has a circular cross-section of diameter 1.5 × 10–2 m
The cable is 12 m long.
Calculate the extension of the cable caused by the weight of the beam. You can
assume that the weights of all cables are negligible.
Young modulus of steel = 2.0 × 1011 Pa
[3 marks]
extension = m
Mark scheme
Show the mark scheme
Question Answers Additional Comments/Guidelines Mark
resultant/overall/sum of force = 0 OR forces up equal forces down
AND forces left equal forces right 1
04.1
(sum of) anticlockwise moments (about any point) = (sum of) 1
clockwise moments/zero resultant moment/torque
EITHER
the point through which (the line of action of) a force has no turning
effect/causes no rotation/ no torque
04.2 OR 1
where the mass of the body can be considered to be concentrated
OR where the weight can be considered to act NOT where mass can be considered to act
Ignore reference to force of gravity
so there is not a resultant moment/turningeffect / turning forceOR Allow moments balanced for no resultant moment
04.3 moments do not balance OR (beam) does not rotate/oscilate/swing
about A/ because A is pivot
If T1 and T2 are the wrong way round get 3 out of 4
If scale drawing 2 max +/- 300(N)
If values out by a factor of 10 then -1 (i.e. confusion 1
over g) 1
04.4 T1 = 12 000 cos 53 1
T1 = 7200 (7221) (N) 1
T2 = 12 000 sin53
T2 = 9600 (9583) (N)
OR
– – –
T1 cos 53 + T2 cos 37 = 12 000
T1sin 53 = T2 sin 37
T2 = T1 sin53/sin37
hence
T1 cos53 + T1 sin53 cos37/sin37= 12 000
T1 = 7200 (7221) (N)
T2 = 7221 sin53/sin37 = 9600 (9583) (N)
(use of l = Fl/AE) No attempt to calculate area scores zero
–2 2 –4 wrong area (e.g. d2 or 2πr or 2πrl) maximum 1 1
A = × (0.75 × 10 ) (= 1.767 × 10 )
–4 9 mark unless diameter used for radius in πr2 then 1
04.5 l = 12 000 × 12/(1.767 × 10 × 200 × 10 )
–3 maximum 2 mark 1
l = 4.1 × 10 (m) –3
accept 4.0 × 10
If 4 × 10–3 then -1 as 1 sig. fig.
Total 12
How to answer it
Forces, Moments and Materials Study Guide
What this question tests
This question assesses core mechanics and materials principles: the conditions for static equilibrium, moments, resolution of forces into orthogonal components, centre of mass, and Hooke's Law / Young modulus calculations involving cross-sectional areas of cylinders.
Part 04.1: Conditions for Equilibrium
✅ Correct Answer
- Resultant force is zero (or forces up equal forces down, and forces left equal forces right).
- Resultant torque/moment is zero (or sum of anticlockwise moments equals sum of clockwise moments about any point).
💡 Key Knowledge
For an extended rigid body to be completely at rest (static equilibrium), both translational and rotational motion must be prevented.
Part 04.2: Centre of Mass
✅ Correct Answer
The single point through which the entire weight/mass of the body can be considered to act (or where a force has no turning effect).
❌ Common Errors
Students often incorrectly state it is "where gravity acts" instead of specifying that it is the point where the entire mass/weight can be considered concentrated.
Part 04.3: Position of Centre of Mass
✅ Correct Answer
- Point A acts as the pivot.
- The lines of action of tensions T₁ and T₂ both pass through point A, creating zero moment about A.
- Therefore, the weight (acting through the centre of mass) must also pass vertically below A so that its moment about A is zero, keeping the beam in equilibrium with no resultant turning moment.
🧠 Exam Technique
Always look for a smart pivot choice! Taking moments about point A eliminates tensions T₁ and T₂ from the turning moment equation because their lines of action intersect directly at A (distance = 0).
Part 04.4: Calculating Tensions
📐 Calculation Steps (Resolution Method)
- Recognise a closed triangle of forces: Since the beam is in equilibrium under three forces (Weight = 12000 N downwards, T₁ and T₂), they form a closed vector triangle.
- Resolve vertically: T₁ cos(53) = 12000 cos(37) or use triangle geometry. Looking at the vertical components: T₁ = 12000 cos(53) = 7220 N (or 7200 N to 2 s.f.).
- Resolve horizontally / use sine components: T₂ = 12000 sin(53) = 9583 N (or 9600 N to 2 s.f.).
✅ Correct Answers
T₁ = 7200 N (or 7221 N)
T₂ = 9600 N (or 9583 N)
❌ Common Calculation Traps
Mixing up sine and cosine functions due to misidentifying angles relative to the vertical/horizontal. Also, mixing up T₁ and T₂ values drops 1 mark.
Part 04.5: Extension of the Steel Cable
📐 Step-by-Step Calculation
- Recall formula: Δl = Fl / (A E)
- Calculate cross-sectional area (A): Diameter d = 1.5 × 10⁻² m , so radius r = 0.75 × 10⁻² m .
A = π r² = π × (0.75 × 10⁻²)² = 1.767 × 10⁻⁴ m² - Substitute values: Force F = 12000 N (weight of beam supported by the single main cable), length l = 12 m , E = 2.0 × 10¹¹ Pa .
Δl = (12000 × 12) / (1.767 × 10⁻⁴ × 2.0 × 10¹¹ ) - Evaluate extension: Δl = 4.08 × 10⁻³ m = 4.1 × 10⁻³ m (or 4.0 × 10⁻³ m )
❌ Common Calculation Traps
Using diameter instead of radius in the area formula ( π d² instead of π r² ) limits you to a maximum of 1 mark. Forgetting to convert cm/mm or diameter-to-radius correctly will ruin the power of ten.
Topics
Physics · 3.4 Mechanics and materials
Question and mark scheme from the AQA AS Level Physics examination, Paper 1, June 2018. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.