AQA AS Level Physics Paper 1, November 2020: Question 3
10 marks · Medium difficulty · Short Answer
Calculate the velocity, time of flight, vertical distance, and sketch and explain projectile trajectories for a golf ball moving on a horizontal surface and through the air.
Practise this questionQuestion
Question text
03.1 Figure 3 shows a golf ball at rest on a horizontal surface 1.3 m from a hole.
Figure 3
A golfer hits the ball so that it moves horizontally with an initial velocity of 1.8 m s–1.
The ball experiences a constant deceleration of 1.2 m s–2 as it travels to the hole.
Calculate the velocity of the ball when it reaches the edge of the hole.
[2 marks]
10 velocity = m s–1
03.2 Later, the golf ball lands in a sandpit. The golfer hits the ball, giving it an initial
velocity u at 35° to the horizontal, as shown in Figure 4. The horizontal component
of u is 8.8 m s–1.
Figure 4
Show that the vertical component of u is approximately 6 m s–1.
*09* 11
[1 mark]
03.3 The ball is travelling horizontally as it reaches X, as shown in Figure 5.
Figure 5
Assume that weight is the only force acting on the ball when it is in the air.
Calculate the time for the ball to travel to X.
[2 marks]
time = s
03.4 Calculate the vertical distance of X above the initial position of the ball.
[2 marks]
vertical distance = m
The golfer returns the ball to its original position in the sandpit. He wants the ball to
land at X but this time with a smaller horizontal velocity than in Figure 5.
Figure 6
03.5 Sketch on Figure 6 a possible trajectory for the ball.
[1 mark]
03.6 Explain your reason for selecting this trajectory.
[2 marks]
Mark scheme
Show the mark scheme
Question Answers Additional Comments/Guidance Mark
details
Where v2 = u2 +2as is correctly stated,
condone one error in substitution e.g. sign of a
Use of an appropriate equation of motion
Where other equations are used it must be
clear that v can be determined.
Must see v as subject and an attempt to AO1.1a
03.1 2
determine t.
(v = ) 0.35 (ms–1) AO2.1b
Allow more than 2 sf where correct.
Use of tan 35 = uv / 8.8
Alternative: credit use of sine rule
Or
03.2 1 AO2.1b
Use of u cos 35 = 8.8 and uv = u sin 35
and Must see answer to at least two significant
figures
6.2 or 6.16 with supporting a calculation
7407_1 Version post-stand
Condone their incorrect value of u in this
substitution.
Condone errors in signs in substitution
Where other equations are used it must be
clear how t can be determined.
Use of an appropriate equation of motion ECF Must see t as subject and an attempt to
determine s.
0.61 (s) for use of u = 6 m s–1
AO1.1a
AO2.1b
03.3 2
For MP2, where their value of u is used, the
answer must be consistent with this value.
(t=) 0.63 (s) ECF
Only allow this use where their value of u, to 1
significant figure, = (5<u<7) m s–1
Condone 1 significant figure answer where U is
1 sig fig.
– SICS – – JUNE 2020
ID
details
Where equation is correctly stated, condone
one error in substitution e.g. one error on sign
of a substituted value or one incorrect value
substituted (of course, ecf is acceptable)
Use of an appropriate equation of motion ECF
h = 1.83 m for use of u = 6 m s–1
AO1.1a
03.4 allow ecf on t (check 3.3) 2
AO2.1b
For MP2, where their value of u is used, the
answer must be consistent with this value.
(h =) 1.9 (m) ECF Only allow this use where their value of u, to 1
significant figure, = (5<u<7) m s–1
allow reverse calculation where u=0 and v = 6
7407_1 Version post-stand m s–1
Curve should be approximately parabolic in
Smooth curve with maximum turning point seen, curve starts shape.
AO3.1b
03.5 at the ball and finishes at X Curve must start below the label ‘golf ball’ and 1
ends within 5mm of the ball or the label X.
Curve must have a maximum turning point.
(Increase the angle to horizontal so) the ball must go higher
14 (and increases its time in the air)
Or
(Increase the angle to horizontal so) the ball must have a
greater (initial) vertical velocity (Increase the angle to horizontal so that) the
AO3.1b
03.6 vertical velocity greater than the horizontal / 2
AO3.1b
increase the vertical decreases the horizontal
(Covers the same horizontal distance over) a longer time in
the air (so has a smaller horizontal velocity)
Alternative:
Increased angle (to horizontal of projection) so smaller
horizontal velocity
must be falling towards ground to land at X
Total 10
How to answer it
Golf Ball Mechanics & Projectile Motion Study Guide
What this question tests
This multi-part mechanics question evaluates your mastery of linear motion with constant acceleration (suvat equations), vector resolution of velocities, independent horizontal and vertical projectile motion under uniform gravitational acceleration, and qualitative graphical/conceptual reasoning.
Linear Deceleration to a Hole
✅ Correct Answer
v = 0.35 m s⁻¹ (or more than 2 s.f. if correct)
💡 Key Knowledge
- Variables given: initial velocity u = 1.8 m s⁻¹ , acceleration a = -1.2 m s⁻² (negative because it's deceleration), displacement s = 1.3 m .
- Equation to use: v² = u² + 2as
📐 Step-by-Step Calculation
- State formula: v² = u² + 2as
- Substitute values: v² = (1.8)² + 2(-1.2)(1.3)
- Calculate terms: v² = 3.24 - 3.12 = 0.12
- Square root: v = √0.12 = 0.3464... = 0.35 m s⁻¹
❌ Common Errors
- Forgetting to make acceleration negative ( a = -1.2 ), which leads to a larger final velocity instead of deceleration.
Resolving Velocity Vectors
✅ Correct Answer
uᵥ ≈ 6 m s⁻¹ (exact calculation yields 6.2 m s⁻¹ or 6.16 m s⁻¹ )
💡 Key Knowledge
- Trigonometric resolution of vectors: adjacent component is u cos(35) , opposite vertical component is u sin(35) .
- Using ratios: tan(35) = uᵥ / uₕ where uₕ = 8.8 m s⁻¹ .
📐 Step-by-Step Calculation
- Find total velocity u first using horizontal component: 8.8 = u cos(35) ⇒ u = 8.8 / cos(35) = 10.74 m s⁻¹
- Calculate vertical component: uᵥ = u sin(35) = 10.74 × sin(35) = 6.16 m s⁻¹
- Alternative direct method: uᵥ = 8.8 × tan(35) = 6.16 m s⁻¹ (rounds to 6 m s⁻¹ or 6.2 m s⁻¹ ).
Calculating Time of Flight to Point X
✅ Correct Answer
t = 0.63 s (allows ECF from 03.2)
🧠 Exam Technique
Horizontal velocity remains constant ( 8.8 m s⁻¹ ) since weight is the only force acting. Use horizontal displacement or vertical motion parameters depending on available data. Here, vertical motion suvat is most direct if horizontal distance to X isn't given, but wait—let's look at how standard projectile problems link horizontal distance or if time is derived from vertical apex/landing. Note: Examiners accept ECF if consistent with student's previous values.
📐 Step-by-Step Calculation
- At the highest point X, the vertical velocity v = 0 m s⁻¹ .
- Use vertical suvat: v = u + at ⇒ 0 = 6.16 - 9.81t
- Rearrange for time: t = 6.16 / 9.81 = 0.628 s ≈ 0.63 s (using g = 9.8 m s⁻¹ gives 0.63 s ).
Calculating Vertical Distance to Point X
✅ Correct Answer
h = 1.9 m (or 1.83 m depending on unrounded intermediate values)
💡 Key Knowledge
Use vertical suvat where final velocity at the peak v = 0 , initial vertical velocity u = 6.16 m s⁻¹ , and acceleration a = -9.81 m s⁻² .
📐 Step-by-Step Calculation
- Select equation: v² = u² + 2as
- Substitute values: 0 = (6.16)² + 2(-9.81)h
- Rearrange for h : h = 37.95 / 19.62 = 1.93 m
- Format to appropriate sig figs: 1.9 m
Sketching the Trajectory
✅ Correct Answer
A smooth, parabolic curve starting at the ball's initial position and terminating precisely at point X, featuring a clear maximum turning point (apex).
🧠 Exam Technique
Since the horizontal velocity is smaller while the target destination X remains fixed in space, the ball must take a steeper path to reach the same height and position over a longer time or steeper arc. Ensure your sketch is smooth, clearly curved upwards with a peak, and touches point X within 5 mm.
❌ Common Errors
Drawing straight lines instead of a smooth parabola, or failing to show a clear maximum turning point.
Explaining the Trajectory Choice
✅ Correct Answer
The golfer must increase the angle of projection to the horizontal. This increases the initial vertical velocity component (making the ball go higher and stay in the air longer), which allows it to cover the same horizontal distance despite having a smaller horizontal velocity.
💡 Key Knowledge
- Horizontal motion equation: Distance = horizontal velocity × time ( sₓ = uₓ t ).
- To keep sₓ constant while decreasing uₓ , time t in the air must increase.
- A larger projection angle achieves this by shifting vector proportions toward a greater vertical component.
Topics
Physics · 3.4 Mechanics and materials
Question and mark scheme from the AQA AS Level Physics examination, Paper 1, November 2020. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.