AQA AS Level Physics Paper 1, June 2023: Question 4

9 marks · Medium difficulty · Short Answer

Calculate the tension in a bow string given force and angle, determine the initial acceleration of an arrow using a force-displacement graph, deduce displacement for a given stored energy, and calculate mass from velocity and efficiency.

Practise this question

Question

Figures 4, 5, and 6 showing an archer pulling a bow string, a free-body diagram of point P on the string with tension forces at 75 degrees to the horizontal, and a graph of force F against displacement s ranging from 0 to 0.45 m.
Question text

04 Figure 4 shows an archer using a bow in a competition.

Figure 4

The archer exerts a force F to pull point P on the string back through a distance s.

04.1 Figure 5 is a simplified diagram of the bow string showing the forces acting on P.

The tension in the string is T and the string makes an angle of 75° to the horizontal.

Figure 5

In Figure 5, F is 160 N and P is in equilibrium.

Calculate T.

[2 marks]

14 T = N

The bow is designed so that F varies with s as shown in Figure 6.

Figure 6

04.2 An arrow of mass 21 g is placed in the bow.

The archer pulls P back by a distance s of 0.22 m and then releases the arrow in a

horizontal direction.

Assume that there are no resistive forces acting on the arrow as it is released.

Determine the initial horizontal acceleration of the arrow.

[2 marks]

initial horizontal acceleration15 = m s−2

The arrow is replaced with a different arrow of mass m.

The archer pulls P back by a distance sr so that the energy stored in the bow is 64 J

*14* and F is 160 N.

04.3 Deduce sr.

[2 marks]

sr = m

04.4 The bow has an efficiency of 0.82

The arrow leaves the bow in a horizontal direction with a velocity of 190 km h−1.

Calculate m.

[3 marks]

m = kg

Mark scheme

Show the mark scheme Mark scheme showing the step-by-step calculation methods and allowed ranges for parts 04.1 to 04.4, including equilibrium equations, acceleration using F=ma, area under the graph for work done, and kinetic energy calculations involving efficiency.

Question Answers Additional Comments/Guidance Mark AO

04.1 Attempts to set forces equal with double a component of Expect to see F = 2T cos 75 OR 80 = T cos 75 2 2 ×

tension. AO2.1f

Condone F = 2 T sin 75 OR 160 = 2 T sin 75

OR

OR F = 2T sin (their acute angle)

Attempts to set forces equal with single horizontal component OR F = 2T cos (their acute angle)

of tension (T cos θ)

OR sin 75 seen and 83 N on answer line.

Condone F = T cos 75 OR 160 = T cos 75

OR (T=) with 620 N on answer line

cos 75

An answer of 83 N due to F and T being

interchanged obtains zero marks.

Alternative

closed triangle (75-75-30) of forces

(T =) 310 (N) An attempted use of Sine or Cosine Rule seen

with correct closed triangle MP1

Accept answer correctly rounded to at least 2 sf.

Answer = 309 (N) to 3 sf

Calculator display= 309.0962644

04.2 Read off for F = 208 N Range for read-off is 208 N to 210 N 2 AO1.1a

OR AO2.1b

use of F = ma In use of F = ma:

• must see substitution for F and m

• condone either POT error in m or F

outside range but not both.

Accepted range = 9900 to 10000

a = 9900 m s–2

( ) ( ) Penalise 1 x 104 N as a 1 sf answer.

04.3 Area under graph calculated in J for either s = 0.10 m or s = 0.385 m is approximately 64 blocks, 1 J per 2 2 ×

s= 0.385 m block (64 J) AO3.1b

s = 0.10 m gives 8 blocks at 1 J per block (8 J)

Or × 0.1 × 160 = 8 J (less than 64 J)

Range for sr between 0.38 m and 0.385 m

sr = 0.385 m

Do not accept W=Fs for MP1

Do not accept sr = 0.4 m for MP2

04.4 (Energy transferred to arrow =) 0.82 × 64 Energy transferred to arrow = 52.48 3 2 ×

OR AO1.1a

converts 190 km h–1 to 52.8 m s–1 or working seen

475 AO2.1b

52.8 = 52.7̇ = accept any answer that

rounds to 53

Use of Ek = mv

Use of is: 17

• A rearranged expression where m

would be subject.

• Substitution: condone one error in the

substitution either v or Ek where m

would be subject (condone rounding

error in v)

Do not accept their power (F v) equal to mv

m = 0.038 (kg)

Accept answer correctly rounded to at least 2 sf.

m = 2.2 x 10-16 kg where incorrect v of 6.84 x 108 is

used. (Worth 2 marks) (one error in v)

m = 0.056 kg where incorrect Ek is used ( = 78)

0.82

(Worth 2 marks) (one error in Ek)

Calculator display = 0.03768093075

Total 9

How to answer it

Forces, Equilibrium, Graphical Work, and Efficiency in Mechanics

What this question tests

This multi-part AS Physics question assesses your ability to resolve forces in equilibrium, apply Newton's second law ( F = ma ), interpret force-displacement graphs to find work done (area under the graph), handle system efficiency, and perform unit conversions (such as converting km h⁻¹ to m s⁻¹ and g to kg ).

Question 04.1

Resolving Forces in Equilibrium

💡 Key Knowledge

  • When an object is in equilibrium, the resultant force in any direction is zero.
  • To find tension T , resolve the two angled tension forces horizontally to balance the pulling force F .
  • Horizontal component of one side of string = T cos(75°) . Since there are two sides, total horizontal force is 2T cos(75°) .

✅ Correct Answer

T = 310 N (Accept 309 N to 310 N depending on rounding; calculator value is 309.096... N).

📐 Step-by-Step Calculation

  1. Equilibrium condition: F = 2T cos(75°)
  2. Rearrange for T: T = F / (2 cos(75°))
  3. Substitute values: T = 160 / (2 cos(75°))
  4. Evaluate: T = 309.096 N → round to 2 significant figures: 310 N .

❌ Common Errors

  • Forgetting the factor of 2: Omitting the fact that the string pulls from both above and below point P loses the method mark.
  • Trig confusion: Mixing up sin and cos by referencing the vertical angle instead of the horizontal angle provided.
Mark breakdown: 2 marks total. 1 mark for attempting to equate forces with a double component (or correct single component setup), 1 mark for the correct final answer.
Question 04.2

Newton's Second Law & Graph Reading

🧠 Exam Technique

Read graph values with extreme care. For s = 0.22 m , locate 0.22 on the horizontal axis of Figure 6, track up to the curve, and read the corresponding force value F on the vertical axis.

✅ Correct Answer

Initial horizontal acceleration = 9900 m s⁻² (Acceptable range: 9900 to 10000 m s⁻² ).

📐 Step-by-Step Calculation

  1. Read F from graph: At s = 0.22 m , F = 208 N (accepted range 208 N to 210 N).
  2. State equation: F = ma → a = F / m
  3. Convert mass to SI: m = 21 g = 21 × 10⁻³ kg
  4. Calculate acceleration: a = 208 / (21 × 10⁻³) = 9904.76... m s⁻² → 9900 m s⁻² (2 s.f.).

❌ Common Errors

  • Failing to convert grams to kilograms ( 21 g used as 21 kg ), resulting in a power-of-ten error.
  • Writing an unacceptable 1 significant figure answer like 1 × 10⁴ m s⁻² .
Mark breakdown: 2 marks total. 1 mark for reading F correctly from the graph (or correct use of F=ma structure), 1 mark for the calculated acceleration.
Question 04.3

Work Done and Energy Stored (Graphical Integration)

💡 Key Knowledge

The work done in pulling the bow string—which equals the energy stored in the bow—is represented by the area under the force-displacement ( F-s ) graph.

✅ Correct Answer

sᵣ = 0.385 m (Acceptable range between 0.38 m and 0.385 m ).

🧠 Exam Technique

Since the curve isn't a standard geometric shape, use square-counting on the grid. Determine the energy represented by one small square, then count squares backwards from the peak until you accumulate 64 J of energy at displacement sᵣ .

❌ Common Errors

  • Using the simple formula W = Fs (assuming constant force). This is incorrect because force varies continuously with distance as shown by the curve.
Mark breakdown: 2 marks total. 1 mark for calculating/verifying area under the graph corresponding to energy, 1 mark for stating the correct displacement sᵣ .
Question 04.4

Efficiency and Kinetic Energy

💡 Key Knowledge

  • Efficiency formula: Efficiency = (Useful output energy / Total input energy)
  • Kinetic energy transferred to the arrow: Eₖ = 0.5 × m × v²
  • Velocity unit conversion: 190 km h⁻¹ must be converted to m s⁻¹ by dividing by 3.6 .

✅ Correct Answer

m = 0.038 kg (or 38 g ).

📐 Step-by-Step Calculation

  1. Find useful energy transferred to arrow: Eₖ = 0.82 × 64 J = 52.48 J
  2. Convert velocity: v = 190 / 3.6 = 52.778 m s⁻¹
  3. Rearrange kinetic energy equation for mass: m = 2 Eₖ / v²
  4. Substitute and solve: m = (2 × 52.48) / (52.778)² = 104.96 / 2785.5 = 0.03768 kg → round to 2 s.f.: 0.038 kg .

❌ Common Errors

  • Forgetting to apply the efficiency factor (using 64 J directly instead of 52.48 J).
  • Forgetting to square the velocity term in the kinetic energy equation ( v instead of v² ).
Mark breakdown: 3 marks total. 1 mark for factoring efficiency into energy / velocity conversion, 1 mark for correct application of Eₖ = 0.5mv² , 1 mark for final mass value with correct units ( kg ).

Topics

Physics · 3.4 Mechanics and materials

Question and mark scheme from the AQA AS Level Physics examination, Paper 1, June 2023. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.