AQA GCSE Biology Biology Paper 1 (Higher), November 2021: Question 1

13 marks · Standard Demand difficulty · Extended Answer

Identify microscope parts and preparation equipment, suggest why cells were not visible, compare the structure of a red blood cell to a plant cell, and explain osmotic bursting in water.

Practise this question

Question

Question 01 includes Figure 1, depicting hands lowering a coverslip at an angle onto a microscope slide with a liquid droplet, and Figure 2, a diagram of a light microscope with Part A indicating the eyepiece and Part B indicating the focusing knob. Sub-questions 01.1 to 01.4 ask to name preparation equipment, identify Part A, state the function of Part B, and suggest why no cells were seen. Sub-question 01.5 is a 6-mark question asking to compare the structure of a red blood cell with a plant cell, followed by 01.6 asking to explain why a red blood cell bursts in water but a plant cell does not.
Question text

01 A student prepared some animal cells to view using a microscope.

Figure 1 shows the student preparing the cells.

Figure 1

01.1 Name two pieces of laboratory equipment the student could have used to prepare

cells to view using a microscope.

[2 marks]

Figure 2 shows the student’s light microscope.

Figure 2

01.2 Name part A.

[1 mark]

01.3 What is the function of part B?

[1 mark]

01.4 The student tried to look at the cells using the microscope.

Suggest one reason why the student could not see any cells when looking through

part A.

[1 mark]

01.5 Red blood cells are specialised animal cells.

Compare the structure of a red blood cell with the structure of a plant cell.

[6 marks]

01.6 When placed into a beaker of water:

• a red blood cell bursts

• a plant cell does not burst.

Explain why the red blood cell bursts but the plant cell does not burst.

[2 marks]

Mark scheme

Show the mark scheme Mark scheme for question 01 listing answers and guidance: 01.1 accepts slide, cover slip, dye/stain, mounted needle, pipette, scalpel, forceps; 01.2 is eyepiece / lens; 01.3 is to focus the image; 01.4 accepts slide not in position, lens dirty/not clicked in, no cells in field of view, or not focused. 01.5 provides a level of response grid for 6 marks comparing differences (nucleus, cell wall, haemoglobin, chloroplasts, vacuole, shape/size) and similarities (cytoplasm, cell membrane). 01.6 awards 1 mark for water entering by osmosis and 1 mark for the plant cell having a cell wall preventing it from bursting.

AO /

Question Answers Extra information Mark

Spec. Ref.

01.1 any two from: 2 AO1

• (microscope) slide 4.1.1.5

• cover slip RPA1

• dye / stain allow named dye / stain

ignore water

• (mounted) needle

• pipette / dropper

• scalpel ignore knife

• forceps / tweezers

allow swab (to collect cells)

01.2 eyepiece / lens do not accept objective lens 1 AO1

4.1.1.5

RPA1

01.3 to focus (the image / cells) allow to make the cells / image 1 AO1

clear(er) 4.1.1.5

RPA1

allow to improve resolution (of

the image)

ignore to move the stage up /

down

do not accept reference to

magnification

01.4 any one from: 1 AO3

• no cells in the field of view 4.1.1.5

• slide not in the correct RPA1

position

• mirror not in correct position allow light / microscope not

switched on / plugged in

• (objective) lens not clicked

into place

or

(objective) lens dirty

• (student is) looking at a

(large) air bubble

• (the microscope is) not

focussed

allow student did not stain the

cells

allow idea of magnification not

being high enough

01.5 Level 2: Scientifically relevant features are identified; the way(s) in 4‒6 AO2

which they are similar/different is made clear and (where

appropriate) the magnitude of the similarity/difference is noted.

Level 1: Relevant features are identified and differences noted. 1‒3 AO1

No relevant content 0

Indicative Content 4.1.1.2

4.2.2.3

Differences:

• red blood cell has no nucleus or plant cell has a nucleus

• red blood cell has no cell wall or plant cell has a cell wall

• red blood cell is a biconcave disc or there are many different

shapes of plant cell

• red blood cell contains haemoglobin or plant cells do not contain

haemoglobin

• red blood cells do not contain chlorophyll or plant cells (may)

contain chlorophyll

• red blood cell has no chloroplasts or plant cell has chloroplasts

• red blood cell has no (permanent) vacuole or plant cell has

(permanent) vacuole

• red blood cells are (much) smaller than plant cells

Similarities:

both have:

• cytoplasm

• cell membrane

• pigments (although they are different)

ignore references to mitochondria and ribosomes

for Level 2, consideration of both red blood cells and plant cells is

required.

01.6 water enters (the cells) by allow water enters and the cell 1 AO2

osmosis / diffusion starts to swell

ignore explanations of osmosis

plant cell has a cell wall (which allow red blood cell has no cell 1 AO1

prevents it from bursting) wall (so it swells and bursts)

4.1.3.2

4.1.1.2

Total 13

How to answer it

Microscopy, Cell Structure & Osmosis Study Guide

📋 What This Question Tests

This question assesses practical skills and recall from AQA Required Practical 1 (Microscopy) and fundamental cell biology (spec references 4.1.1.2, 4.1.1.5, 4.1.3.2, and 4.2.2.3):

  • Equipment and techniques used to prepare microscope slides and operate a light microscope.
  • Troubleshooting common practical issues when using a light microscope.
  • Comparing the structures of specialised animal cells (red blood cells) with plant cells (differences and similarities).
  • Explaining the effect of osmosis on animal and plant cells with reference to the plant cell wall.

Question 01.1: Preparing Microscope Slides

Identifying laboratory apparatus for slide preparation [2 marks]

✅ Mark Scheme Accepted Answers (Any two):

  • (Microscope) slide
  • Cover slip
  • Dye / stain (e.g., methylene blue, iodine)
  • (Mounted) needle
  • Pipette / dropper
  • Scalpel
  • Forceps / tweezers
  • Swab (to collect cheek cells)

❌ Common Errors & What Not to Write

  • Water: The mark scheme explicitly states ignore water. Water is a liquid medium, not a specific lab tool or reagent for staining.
  • Knife: The mark scheme says ignore knife — use the scientific term scalpel.
  • Microscope: The question asks what was used to prepare the cells, not to view them.

Questions 01.2 & 01.3: Microscope Anatomy & Function

Identifying parts and their operational roles [1 mark + 1 mark]

✅ Correct Answers

01.2 (Part A): Eyepiece or eyepiece lens [1 mark]

01.3 (Part B): To focus (the image / cells) [1 mark]

Also accepted for 01.3: to make the cells / image clearer, or to improve resolution.

❌ Common Misconceptions

  • For Part A: Do not write "objective lens". Part A points directly to the top lens you look through (eyepiece). The objective lenses are on the rotating nosepiece below.
  • For Part B: Do not write "magnification" or "zooming in". The focusing wheel moves the stage to focus the light rays; it does not change magnification.
  • Do not just say "moves the stage up and down" — state the scientific function (to focus).

Question 01.4: Microscope Troubleshooting

Explaining why no cells are visible [1 mark]

✅ Any One Valid Reason [1 mark]:

  • No cells in the field of view
  • Slide is not in the correct position / not over the light hole
  • Mirror is not aligned / light is not turned on or plugged in
  • Objective lens not clicked into place
  • Objective lens is dirty
  • The student is looking at an air bubble
  • The microscope is not focused
  • Cells were not stained (too transparent to see)

🧠 Exam Technique: Think Practically!

When asked why a sample can't be seen under a microscope, mentally walk through setting up the instrument:

  1. Light: Is it on/reflected properly?
  2. Lens: Is it locked into place and clean?
  3. Stage: Is the specimen centered directly above the condenser lens?
  4. Focus: Has the focal plane been reached?

Question 01.5: Comparing Red Blood Cells & Plant Cells

Extended response: Structures, similarities, and differences [6 marks]

Level of Response: 6-Mark Question

🧠 How Examiners Grade This 6-Marker

  • Level 2 (4–6 marks): Clear comparison showing both similarities and differences, covering both cell types. The response is coherent and scientifically accurate.
  • Level 1 (1–3 marks): Isolated points listed about one or both cells; mostly differences with few or no structural links.
  • Examiner tip: The mark scheme says ignore mitochondria and ribosomes. Focus on the major visible organelles and structural adaptations!

✅ Differences to Include

  • Nucleus: Red blood cells have no nucleus (mature), whereas plant cells have a nucleus.
  • Cell Wall: Red blood cells have no cell wall; plant cells have a rigid cellulose cell wall.
  • Chloroplasts / Chlorophyll: Red blood cells do not contain chloroplasts/chlorophyll; plant cells often do (e.g. leaf cells).
  • Vacuole: Red blood cells lack a permanent vacuole; plant cells have a large permanent vacuole filled with cell sap.
  • Haemoglobin: Red blood cells contain haemoglobin; plant cells do not.
  • Shape & Size: Red blood cells are a biconcave disc and much smaller; plant cells are typically rectangular/angular and much larger.

💡 Similarities to Include

  • Cell membrane: Both have a cell membrane that encloses the cytoplasm.
  • Cytoplasm: Both contain cytoplasm where cellular reactions take place.
  • Pigments: Both contain pigments (haemoglobin in red blood cells; chlorophyll in photosynthetic plant cells).
Model Linking Sentence:
"Both red blood cells and plant cells have a cell membrane and cytoplasm. However, red blood cells lack a nucleus, permanent vacuole, and cell wall, which are all present in typical plant cells."

Question 01.6: Osmosis & Cell Lysis

Explaining why red blood cells burst in pure water while plant cells do not [2 marks]

✅ Two Required Marking Points:

  1. Mark 1: Water enters the cells by osmosis (or diffusion).
  2. Mark 2: The plant cell has a cell wall which prevents it from bursting (or: the red blood cell has no cell wall so it swells and bursts).

❌ Common Errors in Osmosis Explanations

  • Forgetting the mechanism: Many students write "water goes in" without naming osmosis. You must state the process by name to secure Mark 1.
  • Confusing cell wall and cell membrane: Writing "the plant's cell membrane stops it bursting" scores 0 for Mark 2. It is specifically the rigid cellulose cell wall that withstands turgor pressure.
  • Overcomplicating water potential: You do not need a lengthy definition of osmosis here; the mark scheme notes: "ignore explanations of osmosis". Focus on entry of water + presence/absence of cell wall.

Topics

Biology · Required Practicals · B1: Cell Biology · B2: Organisation · Required Practicals

Question and mark scheme from the AQA GCSE Biology examination, Biology Paper 1 (Higher), November 2021. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.