AQA GCSE Biology Biology Paper 2 (Foundation), November 2021: Question 1

9 marks · Low Demand difficulty · Short Answer

Identify scientists who proposed natural selection, define fossils and their formation, state causes of extinction, and identify evidence for evolution.

Practise this question

Question

Question 01 consists of five parts. Part 01.1 asks to select two scientists who proposed the theory of evolution by natural selection from Alexander Fleming, Alfred Russel Wallace, Carl Linnaeus, Carl Woese, and Charles Darwin. Figure 1 shows a photograph of a fossilised three-toed dinosaur footprint preserved in rock. Part 01.2 asks 'What is a fossil?'. Part 01.3 asks how the fossil footprint in Figure 1 was formed, choosing from: body parts were replaced by minerals, the animal walked on mud, or the animal was frozen in ice. Part 01.4 asks to give two causes of extinction. Part 01.5 asks to select two statements that provide evidence for evolution from four options: bacteria can become resistant to an antibiotic, early forms of life lived in the ocean, older fossils are simpler than more recent ones, and older layers of rock are closer to the surface.
Question text

01 The theory of evolution states that organisms alive today evolved by natural selection

from other species that are now extinct.

01.1 Which two scientists proposed the theory of evolution by natural selection?

[2 marks]

Tick ( ) two boxes.

Alexander Fleming

Alfred Russel Wallace

Carl Linnaeus

Carl Woese

Charles Darwin

Fossils provide evidence for evolution.

Figure 1 shows a fossil footprint of a dinosaur.

Figure 1

01.2 What is a fossil?

[2 marks]

01.3 How was the fossil in Figure 1 formed?

[1 mark]

Tick ( ) one box.

Body parts were replaced by minerals.

The animal walked on mud.

The animal was frozen in ice.

01.4 Dinosaurs are extinct.

Give two causes of extinction.

[2 marks]

01.5 Which two of the following provide evidence for evolution?

[2 marks]

Tick ( ) two boxes.

Bacteria can become resistant to an antibiotic.

Early forms of life lived in the ocean.

*03* Older fossils are simpler than more recent ones.

Older layers of rock are closer to the surface.

Mark scheme

Show the mark scheme Mark scheme for question 01 totalling 9 marks. 01.1 awards 1 mark each for Alfred Russel Wallace and Charles Darwin. 01.2 awards 1 mark for 'remains of an organism' and 1 mark for 'from a long time ago'. 01.3 awards 1 mark for 'the animal walked on mud'. 01.4 awards 2 marks for any two causes from flooding, drought, ice age, global warming, volcanic activity, asteroid collision, new predators, new disease/pathogen, competition for food or mates, lack of habitat or habitat change. 01.5 awards 1 mark each for 'bacteria can become resistant to an antibiotic' and 'older fossils are simpler than more recent ones'.

AO /

Question Answers Extra information Mark

Spec. Ref.

01.1 Alfred Russel Wallace 1 AO1

4.6.3.1

Charles Darwin 1 4.6.3.2

01.2 remains of an organism allow remains of an animal / 1 AO1

plant 4.6.3.5

from a long time ago allow from thousands / millions 1

of years ago

01.3 the animal walked on mud 1 AO2

4.6.3.5

01.4 any two from: 2 AO1

4.6.3.6

• flooding if none of these, allow

• drought climate change for 1 mark

• ice age ignore weather

• global warming

• volcanic activity if neither of these, allow

• asteroid collision catastrophic event

or natural disaster for 1 mark

• (new) predators allow hunters / poachers

• (new) disease / pathogen allow named example

• competition for food allow lack of food

• competition for mates allow lack of mates

ignore competition unqualified

• lack of habitat or habitat ignore environment change

change

ignore isolation

ignore pollution

01.5 bacteria can become resistant to 1 AO1

an antibiotic 4.6.2.2

4.6.3.4

older fossils are simpler than 1

more recent ones

Total 9

How to answer it

Evolution, Fossils, and Extinction

📌 What this question tests

This question assesses foundational recall from Topic 6: Inheritance, Variation, and Evolution. You need to identify key scientists associated with evolutionary theory, define what a fossil is, understand how trace fossils (footprints) form, list abiotic and biotic causes of extinction, and identify observable evidence supporting natural selection.

Question 01.1 • Recall

Scientists and the Theory of Natural Selection

Identify the two scientists who jointly proposed evolution by natural selection

✅ Correct Choices (2 Marks)

  • ☑ Alfred Russel Wallace [1 mark]
  • ☑ Charles Darwin [1 mark]

💡 Key Knowledge

Darwin is most famous for publishing On the Origin of Species (1859), but Wallace independently proposed the same theory at the same time, prompting their joint presentation in 1858.

❌ Distractor Breakdown

  • Alexander Fleming: Discovered penicillin (antibiotics).
  • Carl Linnaeus: Devised the binomial classification system (Kingdom to Species).
  • Carl Woese: Introduced the 3-domain system based on RNA evidence.
Question 01.2 • Definition

Definition of a Fossil

State what is meant by the term "fossil"

✅ Mark Scheme Answer (2 Marks)

  • Remains of an organism (or plant/animal) [1 mark]
  • From a long time ago (or thousands/millions of years ago) [1 mark]

🧠 Exam Technique

Notice that this definition question is worth 2 marks. You must state what it is (remains/traces of living things) and when it is from (millions of years ago / a long time ago). Giving only one part caps your score at 1 mark.

❌ Common Errors

  • Writing just "old bones" (too vague; leaves, impressions, and insects in amber are also fossils).
  • Forgetting to mention the timescale (must state "from a long time ago").
Question 01.3 • Application

Trace Fossil Formation

Identify how the footprint fossil in Figure 1 was formed

✅ Correct Choice (1 Mark)

☑ The animal walked on mud. [1 mark]

💡 Types of Fossilisation

  • Impressions/Traces: Footprints, burrows, and root tracks left in soft mud that later hardens into sedimentary rock.
  • Mineral replacement: Hard parts (teeth, bones, shells) slowly replaced by minerals as they decay.
  • Preservation: Organisms trapped in amber, ice, or peat bogs where decay cannot happen (no oxygen or warmth).

🧠 Look at the Clue in the Image

The image shows a hollow 3D print in stone (a trackway). It is clearly not a bone or a preserved body, meaning it must be an impression in sediment.

Question 01.4 • Recall & Application

Causes of Extinction

Give two causes that can lead to a species becoming extinct

✅ Acceptable Answers (Any 2, 1 Mark Each)

  • Catastrophic events: Asteroid collision or volcanic activity.
  • Climate changes: Global warming, ice age, drought, or flooding.
  • Biotic factors: A new predator (or human hunters), a new disease / pathogen.
  • Competition: Competition for food or mates.
  • Habitat loss: Loss or rapid change of natural habitat.

❌ Common Errors & Uncredited Words

  • "Weather" (ignored — weather is day-to-day; climate change is required).
  • "Competition" on its own without stating what is being competed for (must say food, mates, or territory).
  • "Pollution" or "Isolation" (specifically rejected by the mark scheme for this dinosaur context).

🧠 Top Tip

Group your revision into abiotic factors (e.g. asteroid collision, temperature drop) and biotic factors (e.g. new disease, introduction of a new predator). This makes recalling two distinct factors straightforward.

Question 01.5 • Analysis

Evidence for Evolution

Select two statements that provide evidence that organisms have evolved

✅ Correct Choices (2 Marks)

  • ☑ Bacteria can become resistant to an antibiotic. [1 mark]
  • ☑ Older fossils are simpler than more recent ones. [1 mark]

💡 Why These Support Evolution

  • Antibiotic resistance: Demonstrates natural selection happening in real time. A random mutation confers resistance, non-resistant bacteria die, and resistant bacteria survive and reproduce.
  • Fossil record progression: Deeper, older rocks contain simple single-celled and marine life; younger rocks show increasing complexity and biodiversity over geological time.

❌ Why the Others Are False

  • "Older layers of rock are closer to the surface": Factually incorrect — older rock strata lie deeper underground (Law of Superposition).
  • "Early forms of life lived in the ocean": A true statement about early Earth, but by itself does not demonstrate the mechanism or progression of evolution.

Topics

Biology · B6: Inheritance, Variation and Evolution

Question and mark scheme from the AQA GCSE Biology examination, Biology Paper 2 (Foundation), November 2021. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.