AQA GCSE Biology Biology Paper 2 (Foundation), June 2024: Question 3

8 marks · Low Demand difficulty · Short Answer

Explain genetic engineering of yeast to produce viral vaccines and the ecological implications of using herbicide-resistant genetically modified crops.

Practise this question

Question

Question 3 presents Figure 3, a diagram illustrating how a vaccine is produced using genetic engineering. A viral DNA section labelled 'Gene for antigen' is isolated from a virus and inserted into a yeast cell nucleus to create a genetically-engineered yeast cell. Many yeast cells produce antigens, resulting in pure antigen used as a vaccine. Questions 03.1 and 03.2 ask which viral part is transferred to the yeast and which part is produced. Question 03.3 is a multiple-choice question on why heat-treated whole virus vaccines might be dangerous. Question 03.4 asks for three resources crop plants and weeds compete for. Questions 03.5 and 03.6 ask for one advantage and one non-cost problem of using glyphosate herbicide on fields growing glyphosate-resistant GM maize.
Question text

03 Genetic engineering can be used for making many useful products.

Figure 3 shows how a vaccine against a virus can be made by genetic engineering.

Figure 3

Use information from Figure 3 to answer questions 03.1 and 03.2.

03.1 Which part of the virus is put into the yeast cell?

*12* [1 mark]

03.2 Which part of the virus is made by the yeast cell?

[1 mark]

03.3 A long time ago, vaccines were made in a different way.

The virus was heated to stop it reproducing.

The vaccine contained whole viruses.

Why might the vaccine containing heat-treated viruses be dangerous?

[1 mark]

Tick ( ) one box.

The viruses may be inactive.

The viruses may cause an infection.

The viruses will not mutate. 14

Genetic engineering can also be used in agriculture.

Weeds are a problem for farmers because the weeds compete with crop plants.

03.4 Give three factors that the weeds and crop plants compete for.

[3 marks]

Glyphosate is a weed killer used in agriculture.

Genetically modified (GM) maize is a food crop that is resistant to glyphosate

weed killer.

Farmers can spray glyphosate on a field to kill the weeds where the GM maize

is growing.

03.5 Suggest one advantage of using glyphosate on fields where GM maize is growing.

[1 mark]

03.6 Suggest one problem of using glyphosate on fields where GM maize is growing.

Do not refer to cost in your answer.

[1 mark]

Mark scheme

Show the mark scheme Mark scheme for Question 3 with six parts totaling 8 marks. 03.1 accepts 'gene (for antigen)' or 'DNA / allele for antigen' (1 mark). 03.2 accepts '(pure) antigen(s)' (1 mark). 03.3 accepts 'the viruses may cause an infection' (1 mark). 03.4 awards 3 marks for any three of: (sun)light, water, ions / minerals / salts, oxygen in the soil, or space. 03.5 awards 1 mark for 'crop plants grow better' or 'crop plants have higher yield'. 03.6 awards 1 mark for harms to other plants, water/soil pollution, harm to humans/animals, or reduced biodiversity.

Question 3

AO /

Question Answers Extra information Mark

Spec Ref.

03.1 gene (for antigen) allow DNA / allele for antigen 1 AO3

ignore DNA / allele unqualified 4.6.2.4

AO /

Spec Ref.

03.2 (pure) antigen(s) 1 AO3

4.6.2.4

AO /

Spec Ref.

03.3 the viruses may cause an 1 AO3

infection 4.6.2.4

AO /

Spec Ref.

03.4 any three from: 3 AO1

4.7.1.1

• (sun) light ignore sun

• water allow moisture / rain

• ions / minerals / salts allow a named example

allow two named ions for 2

marks

ignore nutrients / food

• oxygen in the soil ignore carbon dioxide

• space

AO /

Spec Ref.

03.5 crop plants grow better ignore reference to competition 1 AO2

4.6.2.4

or

4.7.5.4

crop plants have higher yield 4.7.3.1

– – –

AO /

Spec Ref.

03.6 any one from: 1 AO2

4.6.2.4

• may kill / harm / poison other ignore it is poisonous 4.7.3.1

plants unqualified 4.7.3.6

• may pollute streams / rivers /

soil

• may kill / harm / poison

humans / animals

allow may alter taste of (GM)

maize

allow may reduce biodiversity

ignore reference to cost

Total Question 3 8

How to answer it

Genetic Engineering in Vaccines & Agriculture

What this question tests

This 8-mark question assesses understanding across two core biology topics: Genetic Engineering (Topic 6 - Inheritance, Variation and Evolution) and Competition & Ecosystems (Topic 7 - Ecology).

  • Diagram Comprehension: Tracing the transfer of genetic material and protein expression in a flowchart.
  • Vaccination Safety: Understanding the risks of live or heat-inactivated pathogens compared to modern subunit vaccines.
  • Plant Competition: Recalling the specific resources that plants compete for in an ecosystem.
  • Genetically Modified (GM) Crops: Evaluating the benefits and environmental impacts of herbicide-resistant crops.
Questions 03.1 & 03.2 • 2 Marks total

Using Flow Diagrams in Genetic Engineering

Identifying transferred material vs. synthesized products

✅ Correct Answers

03.1: Gene (for antigen)
Also accepted: DNA for antigen / allele for antigen.

03.2: (Pure) antigen(s)

💡 Key Knowledge

  • Genes carry instructions: In genetic engineering, a specific gene (a section of DNA) is isolated from a donor and inserted into a vector or host cell.
  • Expression: The host cell (yeast) reads the viral gene and uses its own ribosomes to manufacture the foreign protein (the antigen).

🧠 Exam Technique

When a question states "Use information from Figure 3", look carefully at the arrow labels:

  • The arrow pointing into the yeast points from "Gene for antigen".
  • The arrow showing what the yeast produces points to "Antigen".

❌ Common Errors

  • 03.1: Writing just "DNA" or "allele" without qualification was rejected by examiners. It must be specified as the gene for the antigen.
  • Writing "nucleus" or "whole virus" for what is inserted into the yeast cell.
Award 1 mark each for correct identification of the gene transferred and the antigen produced.
Question 03.3 • 1 Mark

Vaccine Safety & Heat-Treated Viruses

Understanding the risk of traditional whole-virus vaccines

✅ Correct Answer

Tick Box 2: "The viruses may cause an infection."

💡 Key Knowledge

Older vaccines used weakened (attenuated) or heat-inactivated whole viruses. If the heat-treatment process is incomplete or ineffective, live viral particles remain capable of replicating and causing disease in the patient.

By contrast, genetically engineered subunit vaccines (like the yeast method shown) contain only pure antigens (proteins), never whole pathogens, making an infection impossible.

❌ Common Errors

  • Ticking "The viruses may be inactive" — Inactivity is the goal of heat treatment, not the danger!
  • Ticking "The viruses will not mutate" — Lack of mutation is not why a vaccine is dangerous.
Award 1 mark for ticking the correct box only. Ticking multiple boxes scores 0.
Question 03.4 • 3 Marks

Plant Competition in Agroecosystems

Resources that weeds and crop plants compete for

✅ Correct Answers (Choose any three)

  • Light / sunlight
  • Water / rain / soil moisture
  • Mineral ions / salts / minerals (or specific named ions, e.g. nitrates, magnesium, phosphates)
  • Space (or room to grow)
  • Oxygen in the soil (for root respiration)

💡 Key Knowledge: Plants vs. Animals

Be very careful not to confuse what plants compete for with what animals compete for:

  • Plants compete for: Light, space, water, and mineral ions from the soil.
  • Animals compete for: Food, mates, and territory.

❌ Common Errors & Mark Traps

  • "Food" or "Nutrients": Plants make their own food by photosynthesis! Examiners explicitly reject "food" and "nutrients".
  • "Carbon dioxide": CO₂ is abundant in the open atmosphere and is generally not considered a limiting competitive factor in open fields.
  • "Sun": Too vague; you must specify sunlight or light.
Award 1 mark per valid factor up to a maximum of 3 marks.
Questions 03.5 & 03.6 • 2 Marks total

GM Herbicide Resistance: Advantages & Problems

Evaluating the agricultural use of glyphosate

✅ 03.5 Advantage (Any one)

  • Crop plants grow better / grow larger
  • Crop plants have a higher yield / produce more maize

Note: The question already explains weeds are killed, so saying "it kills weeds" or just "less competition" without linking to crop growth was not credited.

✅ 03.6 Problem (Any one)

  • May kill / harm / poison other (non-target) plants or wild flowers
  • May pollute / contaminate streams, rivers, or soil
  • May kill / harm / poison animals, insects, or humans
  • May reduce biodiversity / disrupt food chains
  • May alter the taste of the GM maize

🧠 Exam Technique: Follow Restrictions

  • Read the bold condition: Question 03.6 explicitly states: "Do not refer to cost in your answer." Any mention of herbicide cost, seed expense, or farmer profit immediately scores 0 marks.
  • Be specific about harm: Avoid writing "it is poisonous" on its own. State what it harms (e.g. harmless insects, hedgerow wildflowers, aquatic life).

❌ Common Misconceptions

  • Confusing herbicide (weed killer) with insecticide / pesticide. Glyphosate kills unwanted plants.
  • Stating that the GM maize itself will be killed by the weed killer (the prompt states it is resistant to glyphosate).
Award 1 mark for 03.5 and 1 mark for 03.6.

Topics

Biology · B6: Inheritance, Variation and Evolution · B7: Ecology

Question and mark scheme from the AQA GCSE Biology examination, Biology Paper 2 (Foundation), June 2024. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.