AQA GCSE Biology Biology Paper 2 (Foundation), June 2024: Question 9

8 marks · Standard Demand difficulty · Short Answer

Describe the mechanisms of mutation and natural selection, identify the scientists who proposed the theory of evolution, and explain how mimicry helps the hoverfly survive.

Practise this question

Question

Question 9 starts with the statement: 'Evolution of new species occurs by mutation and natural selection.' Part 09.1 asks 'What is a mutation?' Part 09.2 asks to 'Describe the process of natural selection.' Part 09.3 asks to identify which scientists proposed the theory of evolution by natural selection from four multiple-choice options. Part 09.4 features Figure 12 showing black-and-white drawings of a hoverfly and a wasp, both showing banded abdomens, followed by text explaining that the wasp has a sting while the hoverfly does not, and asks to explain how yellow and black markings help the hoverfly survive.
Question text

09 Evolution of new species occurs by mutation and natural selection.

09.1 What is a mutation?

[1 mark]

09.2 Describe the process of natural selection.

[3 marks]

09.3 Which scientists suggested the theory of evolution by natural selection?

[1 mark]

Tick ( ) one box.

Alexander Fleming and Carl Woese

Alfred Wallace and Alexander Fleming

Alfred Wallace and Charles Darwin

Charles Darwin and Carl Woese 37

09.4 The hoverfly and the wasp are insects with bright yellow and black markings.

Figure 12 shows a hoverfly and a wasp.

Figure 12

The wasp has a sting to defend itself against predators.

The hoverfly does not have a sting.

Hoverflies and wasps live in the same habitat.

Explain how having yellow and black markings helps the hoverfly survive.

[3 marks]

Mark scheme

Show the mark scheme Mark scheme for Question 9. Part 09.1 credits a change in DNA, base sequence, gene, or chromosome (1 mark). Part 09.2 gives up to 3 marks for: variation, better adapted survive, reproduce, and pass on alleles. Part 09.3 gives 1 mark for Alfred Wallace and Charles Darwin. Part 09.4 gives 3 marks: hoverfly looks like a wasp, predator avoids wasps to avoid being stung, so predator does not attack or eat the hoverfly. Total 8 marks.

Question 9

AO /

Question Answers Extra information Mark

Spec Ref.

09.1 a change in: 1 AO1

4.6.2.1

• DNA

• base code or nucleotide

sequence

• base (in DNA)

• gene / allele

• part of a chromosome

• number of chromosomes

• genetic code / material ignore genetic information /

variation

ignore reference to amino acids

or proteins

AO /

Spec Ref.

09.2 allow in terms of an example AO1

4.6.2.1

any three from: 3

4.6.2.2

• variation (between members ignore mutation 4.6.3.1

of a species)

• better adapted survive allow survival of the fittest

• (better adapted or survivors)

reproduce allow converse

• pass on (favourable) ignore passing on genetic

allele(s) / gene(s) / material or chromosomes or

mutation(s) characteristic

AO /

Spec Ref.

09.3 Alfred Wallace and Charles 1 AO1

Darwin 4.6.2.2

– – – 4.6.3.1

4.6.3.2

AO /

Spec Ref.

09.4 hoverfly looks like a wasp allow pattern of the markings is 1 AO3

similar (on the hoverfly and 4.6.3.2

wasp) 4.7.1.1

24 4.7.1.4

ignore predator / animal thinks

the hoverfly is a wasp

predator / animal avoids wasps 1

so it does not get stung

(so) predator / animal does not allow correctly named predator 1

attack / eat hoverfly ignore bite / harm

Total Question 9 8

How to answer it

Mutation, Natural Selection & Warning Mimicry

SPECIFICATION CHECK: 4.6.2 & 4.6.3

What this question tests

This question assesses your understanding of the foundational mechanisms of evolution:

  • Defining a gene mutation at a molecular level (AO1).
  • Recalling the step-by-step process of evolution by natural selection (AO1).
  • Identifying the key scientists behind evolutionary theory (AO1).
  • Applying natural selection principles to explain survival adaptations (mimicry in hoverflies and wasps) (AO3).
QUESTION 09.1 • 1 MARK

Definition of a Mutation

What is a mutation?

✅ Correct Answers

Any one of the following:

  • A change in the DNA
  • A change in the base sequence (or nucleotide sequence)
  • A change in a gene or allele
  • A change in the number or structure of chromosomes

❌ Common Errors & Mark Scheme Traps

  • "A change in genetic information" — Ignored by examiners as it is too vague.
  • "A change in a protein / amino acid" — Ignored; a mutation occurs in the DNA itself, not the protein product.
  • Confusing mutation with variation.
Mark Scheme Note: Award 1 mark for mentioning DNA, gene, allele, or base sequence. Avoid generic terms like "traits" or "information".
QUESTION 09.2 • 3 MARKS

The Mechanism of Natural Selection

Describe the process of natural selection.

✅ Marking Points (Any 3)

  1. There is variation between members of a species.
  2. Organisms with characteristics best suited to the environment are better adapted and survive ("survival of the fittest").
  3. The surviving individuals reproduce.
  4. They pass on their favourable alleles / genes to their offspring.

🧠 Exam Technique: Use the "V.S.R.G." Framework

Always write natural selection answers using four sequential keywords:

  • V – Variation exists in the population.
  • S – Better adapted individuals Survive.
  • R – Survivors Reproduce.
  • G – Favourable Genes / alleles are passed on.

❌ Lost Marks to Avoid

  • "Pass on characteristics / traits": Examiners explicitly ignore this. You must state they pass on genes or alleles.
  • Stating "animals choose to adapt" or "they adapt over their lifetime" (Lamarckian idea — 0 marks).

💡 Key Term Distinction

Gene vs. Allele: An allele is a version of a gene. A mutation creates a new allele that gives a survival advantage in that specific environment.

QUESTION 09.3 • 1 MARK

Historical Pioneers of Evolution

Which scientists suggested the theory of evolution by natural selection?

✅ Correct Answer

[✓] Alfred Wallace and Charles Darwin

Darwin and Wallace jointly presented their theory of evolution by natural selection to the Linnean Society in 1858.

💡 Who Were the Other Scientists?

  • Alexander Fleming: Discovered penicillin (the first antibiotic) in 1928.
  • Carl Woese: Proposed the three-domain classification system (Archaea, Bacteria, Eukaryota) based on RNA analysis.
QUESTION 09.4 • 3 MARKS

Applying Evolution: Batesian Mimicry in Hoverflies

Explain how having yellow and black markings helps the hoverfly survive.

✅ Model Answer (3 Marks)

  • Mark 1: The hoverfly's yellow and black markings make it look like a wasp (warning colouration).
  • Mark 2: Predators (birds/animals) avoid wasps so they do not get stung.
  • Mark 3: As a result, predators do not attack / eat the hoverfly.

🧠 Structuring an Adaptation Explanation

To score full marks on mimicry questions, connect all three links in the cause-and-effect chain:

  1. Appearance: What does the mimic look like? (Looks like a wasp)
  2. Predator experience: Why do predators avoid the model? (Fear of sting)
  3. Outcome: What happens to the mimic? (Not eaten / survives)

❌ Examiner Pitfalls

  • Anthropomorphism: Do not write "the bird thinks the hoverfly is a wasp" — examiners explicitly ignore statements attributing conscious thought to animals. Write: "the markings are similar" or "it looks like a wasp".
  • Vague survival claims: Writing only "it protects them" without explaining that predators avoid eating them to escape being stung loses marks 2 and 3.
  • Do not say "predators avoid getting bitten" — the prompt clearly specifies wasps sting.
Total for Question 9: 8 Marks

Topics

Biology · B6: Inheritance, Variation and Evolution · B7: Ecology

Question and mark scheme from the AQA GCSE Biology examination, Biology Paper 2 (Foundation), June 2024. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.