AQA GCSE Biology Biology Paper 1 (Foundation), June 2025: Question 4

11 marks · Standard Demand difficulty · Extended Answer

Describe aseptic techniques for culturing bacteria on an agar plate and predict and interpret zones of inhibition for different antibiotics.

Practise this question

Question

Question 4 consists of five sub-questions about culturing bacteria and testing antibiotics. Figure 5 shows equipment: a Bunsen burner, an inoculating loop, an empty Petri dish, a bottle of agar, and a bottle of bacteria. Question 04.1 asks for a 6-mark method to prepare a sterile agar plate and grow an uncontaminated sample. Figure 6 shows a Petri dish with four discs: antibiotic discs A, B, C, and a water control disc. Question 04.2 asks why incubation shouldn't exceed 25 °C. Question 04.3 asks the purpose of the water disc. Figure 7 shows antibiotic disc B with a shaded clear zone of inhibition around it. Question 04.4 asks to draw rings around discs A and C based on A being most effective and C least effective. Question 04.5 asks what effect resistant antibiotic D would have on bacteria.
Question text

04 A student investigated the effect of antibiotics on the growth of bacteria.

The student prepared an agar gel plate.

Figure 5 shows some of the equipment the student used.

Figure 5

04.1 Describe a method the student could use to:

• prepare a sterile agar gel plate

• grow an uncontaminated sample of bacteria on the agar gel plate.

Use the equipment in Figure 5 in your answer.

[6 marks]

The student used an agar gel plate to test three antibiotics, A, B and C.

*18* Figure 6 shows how the agar gel plate was set up.

Figure 6

04.2 The student incubated the agar gel plate at 25 °C.

Why should the temperature not be higher than 25 °C?

[1 mark]

04.3 What was the purpose of the paper disc soaked in water?

[1 mark]

Tick ( ) one box.

To check the bacteria were uncontaminated.

To make the investigation more accurate.

To show the effect of no antibiotics.21

04.4 The student removed the agar gel plate from the incubator after 48 hours.

Antibiotic A was the most effective at killing the bacteria.

Antibiotic C was the least effective at killing the bacteria.

Figure 7 shows the results for the disc soaked in antibiotic B.

Figure 7

Complete Figure 7 to show the results you would expect.

You should:

• draw a ring around the disc soaked in antibiotic A

• draw a ring around the disc soaked in antibiotic C.

[2 marks]

04.5 The student repeated the investigation with antibiotic D.

The bacteria were resistant to antibiotic D.

What effect would antibiotic D have had on the bacteria?

[1 mark]

Tick ( ) one box.

All of the bacteria would have been killed.

Some of the bacteria would have been killed.

None of the bacteria would have been killed.

Mark scheme

Show the mark scheme Mark scheme for Question 4. Part 04.1 uses a 3-level criteria (5-6, 3-4, 1-2 marks) with indicative content covering preparation of agar plate, transfer of bacteria, aseptic techniques, and bacterial growth conditions. Part 04.2 awards 1 mark for preventing the growth of pathogens/harmful microorganisms. Part 04.3 awards 1 mark for showing the effect of no antibiotics. Part 04.4 awards 1 mark for a larger ring around A than B, and 1 mark for a smaller ring around C than B. Part 04.5 awards 1 mark for 'none of the bacteria would have been killed'.

Question 4

Question AO /

Answers Mark

Spec Ref.

04.1 Level 3: The method would lead to the production of a valid

outcome. The key steps are identified and logically sequenced. 5-6 AO2

Level 2: The method would not necessarily lead to a valid

outcome. Most steps are identified, but the method is not fully 3-4 AO1

logically sequenced.

Level 1: The method would not lead to a valid outcome. Some AO1

1-2

relevant steps are identified, but links are not made clear. 4.1.1.6

RPA2

No relevant content. 0

Indicative content:

preparation of agar plate

• melt agar

• pour agar into Petri dish

• allow agar to cool / set

transfer of bacteria

• transfer bacteria to agar / Petri dish or spread bacteria on

agar / Petri dish

• transfer bacteria using (inoculating) loop or by pouring (liquid)

bacterial culture

techniques to ensure sterile conditions (aseptic technique)

• wipe table with a disinfectant / antibacterial solution

or

sanitise hands using sanitiser gel

• sterilise agar by heating or using autoclave / UV or pressure

cooker

• sterilise Petri dish by heating or using autoclave / UV or

pressure cooker or ethanol

• sterilise neck of agar / bacteria bottle by passing through a

flame

• only open lid of agar bottle minimally or only lift lid of Petri

dish minimally

• work next to a Bunsen flame

• sterilise inoculating loop before use by dipping in alcohol /

ethanol

• sterilise inoculating loop before use by passing through a

flame

growth of bacteria

• incubate Petri dish upside down

• tape lid (correctly)

• incubate at 25 °C or leave bacteria to grow

For Level 3, a valid method must include preparation of the agar

plate and transfer of the bacteria using sterile techniques.

For Level 2, a method must include preparation of the agar plate

and transfer of the bacteria.

AO /

Question Answers Extra information Mark

Spec Ref.

04.2 to prevent growth of pathogens allow to prevent growth of 1 AO2

harmful bacteria / fungi / 4.1.1.6

microorganisms RPA2

AO /

Spec Ref.

14 04.3 to show the effect of no 1 AO2

antibiotics 4.1.1.6

RPA2

AO /

Spec Ref.

04.4 ignore ring drawn around blank / AO3

water disc 4.1.1.6

ignore shading / hatching within RPA2

rings

larger ring drawn around 1

antibiotic A than B

smaller ring drawn around ignore no ring drawn around 1

antibiotic C than B antibiotic C

AO /

Spec Ref.

04.5 none of the bacteria would have 1 AO3

been killed 4.1.1.6

4.3.1.8

Total Question 4 11

How to answer it

AQA GCSE Biology: Investigating Bacterial Growth & Antibiotics

📋 What this question tests

Core Knowledge & Practical Skills (Required Practical 2):

  • Aseptic techniques: Preparing sterile nutrient agar plates and inoculating bacteria safely without contamination.
  • Safe incubation: Why school laboratories incubate cultures at a maximum of 25 °C.
  • Experimental design: Identifying the purpose of a negative control (filter paper soaked in sterile water).
  • Data representation & analysis: Comparing clear zones of inhibition to deduce antibiotic effectiveness and resistance.

Question 04.1 (6 Marks)

Aseptic Technique: Preparing and Inoculating an Agar Plate

✅ Model 6-Mark Method (Level 3)

  1. 1 Sterilise area: Disinfect the workbench and wash hands. Work close to a lit Bunsen burner so upward convection currents carry airborne microbes away.
  2. 2 Pour plate: Flame the neck of the molten agar bottle. Lift the Petri dish lid slightly at an angle, pour the agar in, and allow it to set completely.
  3. 3 Sterilise loop: Pass the metal inoculating loop through the Bunsen flame until red hot, then allow it to cool so it doesn't kill the bacteria.
  4. 4 Inoculate: Flame the neck of the bacterial culture bottle. Dip the loop in and streak the bacteria evenly over the set agar, opening the lid minimally.
  5. 5 Incubate: Secure the lid with adhesive tape (not all the way around), invert the dish (upside down), and incubate at 25 °C.

🧠 How to Secure Level 3 (5–6 Marks)

  • The "Holy Trinity" of RP2: Examiners look for three clear stages: (1) Preparing the plate, (2) Inoculating with bacteria, and (3) Specific aseptic actions.
  • To reach Level 3, your method must be logically sequenced. You cannot streak bacteria before the agar sets!
  • Always state how equipment is sterilised (e.g., passing loop through Bunsen flame, wiping bench with disinfectant).

❌ Common Errors & Misconceptions

  • Taping all the way round: Never say "seal the dish completely". Sealing prevents oxygen entry, promoting the growth of dangerous anaerobic pathogens.
  • Forgetting to cool the loop: Dipping a red-hot loop directly into bacterial culture kills the bacteria.
  • Taking the lid off completely: Leaving the lid flat on the desk exposes the open agar to falling airborne spores.

💡 Mark Scheme Breakdown

  • Level 3 (5–6 marks): Valid, logically sequenced method covering agar plate preparation, bacterial transfer, and aseptic techniques.
  • Level 2 (3–4 marks): Covers plate preparation and bacterial transfer, but some steps missed or unordered.
  • Level 1 (1–2 marks): Fragmented aseptic steps without clear coherence.

Question 04.2 (1 Mark)

Incubation Temperature Safety

✅ Correct Answer

To prevent the growth of pathogens (harmful microorganisms / bacteria / fungi).

🧠 Exam Technique

Always use the word pathogen or "harmful / disease-causing microorganisms". Human pathogens thrive at human body temperature (37 °C). Keeping school cultures at 25 °C greatly reduces the risk of culturing something dangerous.

❌ Examiner Pitfall

Do NOT write "bacteria will be denatured" or "bacteria will die at higher temperatures". Bacteria grow faster at 37 °C; the restriction is purely for safety!

Award 1 mark for: prevent growth of pathogens / harmful bacteria.

Question 04.3 (1 Mark)

Control Disc Function

✅ Correct Box to Tick

☑ To show the effect of no antibiotics.

💡 Why is this needed?

The paper disc soaked in sterile water acts as a negative control. It proves that the paper disc itself or the water is not inhibiting bacterial growth—only the antibiotic active ingredients are.

Award 1 mark for selecting "To show the effect of no antibiotics".

Question 04.4 (2 Marks)

Drawing Expected Results (Clear Zones)

📐 How to Draw on Figure 7

  • Around Disc A: Draw a circular clear ring (zone of inhibition) that is noticeably larger in diameter than the shaded ring around disc B.
  • Around Disc C: Draw a circular clear ring that is noticeably smaller in diameter than the ring around B (or leave no clear ring at all, touching the disc).
  • Note: Shading/hatching is not required by examiners, but the boundary circle must be clear.

💡 Scientific Principle

The larger the clear zone (zone of inhibition) around an antibiotic disc, the more effective the antibiotic is at killing or preventing the reproduction of the bacteria.

  • Antibiotic A (Most effective): Largest clear zone.
  • Antibiotic B (Intermediate): Medium clear zone (already drawn).
  • Antibiotic C (Least effective): Smallest clear zone (or none).
Mark 1: Larger ring drawn around antibiotic A than B.
Mark 2: Smaller ring drawn around antibiotic C than B (or no ring around C).

Question 04.5 (1 Mark)

Antibiotic Resistance

✅ Correct Box to Tick

☑ None of the bacteria would have been killed.

💡 Key Recall Fact

Bacterial resistance means the bacteria are entirely unaffected by that specific antibiotic. They will grow right up to the edge of the disc, resulting in a zone of inhibition of 0 mm.

Award 1 mark for selecting "None of the bacteria would have been killed".

Topics

Biology · Required Practicals · B1: Cell Biology · B3: Infection and Response · Required Practicals

Question and mark scheme from the AQA GCSE Biology examination, Biology Paper 1 (Foundation), June 2025. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.