AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy Biology Paper 1 (Higher), 2018: Question 6

14 marks · Standard Demand difficulty · Extended Answer

Answer a series of questions about stem cells, the cell cycle and therapeutic cloning, including recall, explanation and calculations from a cell cycle diagram.

Practise this question

Question

The question page is headed 'This question is about stem cells' and contains six sub-questions worth 14 marks in total. It asks for one place in a plant where stem cells are found, then a tick-box multiple-choice question on the economic use of plant stem cells, with options including genetically modified crops, new species, increased variation, and producing large numbers of identical plants. A pie chart labelled Figure 9 shows a human embryonic stem cell cycle with Stage 1 taking most of the circle, Stage 2 labelled mitosis, and a small Stage 3 sector; the Stage 2 sector is marked as 28 degrees and an arrow marks the start of the cycle. Later parts ask to convert 6 picograms to grams in standard form, calculate time spent in mitosis if the full cycle is 15 hours to 3 significant figures, describe what happens in each of the three stages of the cell cycle, and use Figure 10, a therapeutic cloning flow diagram, to give two advantages and two disadvantages of therapeutic cloning. Figure 10 shows a donated egg cell and a body cell from a patient combining to form an embryo, with some stem cells cultured and some cells not used.
Question text

06 This question is about stem cells.

06.1 Give one place in a plant where stem cells are found.

[1 mark]

06.2 What is one economic use of plant stem cells?

[1 mark]

Tick one box.

To create genetically modified crops

To create new species of plants

To increase variation in plants

To produce large numbers of identical plants20

Embryonic stem cells divide by mitosis.

Figure 9 represents a cell cycle for a human embryonic stem cell.

Figure 9

06.3 The mass of DNA in the cell at the start of the cycle is 6 picograms.

*19* A picogram is 10–3 nanograms.

Convert 6 picograms to grams.

Give your answer in standard form.

[1 mark]

21 Mass = g

06.4 The time taken for this complete cell cycle is 15 hours.

Calculate how many hours the cell spent in mitosis.

Give your answer to 3 significant figures.

[2 marks]

Time spent in mitosis = hours

06.5 Describe what happens in each of the three stages of the cell cycle.

[5 marks]

06.6 Figure 10 shows how embryonic stem cells are produced in therapeutic cloning for

use in patients.

Figure 10

Give two advantages and two disadvantages of therapeutic cloning in medical

treatments.

Use Figure 10 to help you.

[4 marks]

Advantage 1

Advantage 2

Disadvantage 1

Disadvantage 2

Mark scheme

Show the mark scheme The mark scheme is a table listing answers, extra information and marks for questions 06.1 to 06.6. It gives acceptable answers for plant stem cell location as meristems, tip of shoot or tip of root; the multiple-choice answer as producing large numbers of identical plants; the DNA mass conversion as 6 × 10^-12 grams; and the mitosis time calculation as 28/360 × 15 = 1.17 hours, with some rounding alternatives allowed. For the cell cycle description it awards marks for Stage 1 cell growth and DNA replication, Stage 2 mitosis with chromosomes moving to opposite ends and the nucleus dividing, and Stage 3 with cytoplasm and cell membrane dividing to form two genetically identical cells. For therapeutic cloning it credits advantages such as treating disease, producing replacement cells or tissues, low rejection risk, and research use, and disadvantages such as destruction of a potential life or embryo, shortage and risks of egg donors, unknown side effects, infection risk, or low success rate.

AO /

Question Answers Extra information Mark

Spec. Ref.

06.1 any one from: 1 AO1

• meristem(s) 4.1.2.3

• tip of shoot ignore stem and embryo 4.2.3.1

• tip of root

06.2 to produce large numbers of 1 AO1

identical plants 4.1.2.3

06.3 6 × 10−12 (grams) 1 AO2

4.1.2.1

4.1.2.2

06.4 an answer of 1.17 (hours) AO2

scores 2 marks 4.1.2.2

28 7 1

× 15 allow × 15

360 90

or allow correct rounding

1.166666666(r) allow 1.16

allow 1 mark for 1 hour 10 1

1.17 (hours)

minutes or 1 and 1/6 hours or

70 minutes only if units given

AO /

Spec. Ref.

06.5 max 4 if correct sequence but AO1

no reference to stage numbers 4.1.2.1

4.1.2.2

max 4 marks if no stage

numbers given

ignore names of phases

marks can be awarded for

labelled diagrams

stage 1 1

cell growth

or

increase in number of allow increase in named

organelles organelle eg ribosomes /

mitochondria

DNA replicates allow DNA duplicates / 1

or doubles 19

two copies of each chromosome ignore genetic information

form replicates

if this statement given as part

of stage 2 allow max 4 marks

stage 2 / mitosis

one set of chromosomes moves allow chromosomes separate or 1

to each end of cell are pulled apart

nucleus divides allow nucleus splits into two 1

stage 3

cytoplasm / cell membrane allow cytokinesis 1

divides to form two (genetically)

identical cells

06.6 ignore references to cost AO1

AO3

any two from: 2 4.1.2.3

4.1.1.4

advantages: 4.6.2.4

• may be used to cure / treat allow example eg diabetes /

(current / future) diseases paralysis

or ignore used for medical

cure medical conditions treatments

or

produce replacement cells /

tissues / organs

• cells / tissues of any type allow cells differentiate into

could be produced many types 20

• cells unlikely to be rejected ignore identical cells are

by the patient produced unqualified

• many cells produced

• cells produced could be

used for research

• would reduce waiting time

for organ transplants

any two from: ignore references to cost 2

ignore unethical unqualified

ignore references to religion /

beliefs

disadvantages:

• potential life is killed / allow embryo is destroyed

destroyed ignore cells destroyed or wasted

• shortage of donors / eggs

• egg donation / collection has

risks

• do not yet know risks /side allow may cause tumours /

effects of the procedure on cancer

the patient

• may transfer (viral) infection

• poor success rate to

produce viable eggs /

embryo

Total 14

How to answer it

Stem Cells, Cell Cycle and Therapeutic Cloning

What this question tests

This question checks your ability to recall stem cell locations and uses, convert units, read a pie chart, calculate proportions, describe the stages of the cell cycle in the correct order, and explain advantages and disadvantages of therapeutic cloning.

Question overview

This is a mixed recall + calculation question. The exam rewards short, precise scientific points. For the cell cycle and therapeutic cloning parts, marks are earned for correct sequence and specific biological detail.

Part 06.1

06.1 — Give one place in a plant where stem cells are found

✅ Correct answers

  • meristem(s)
  • tip of shoot
  • tip of root

1 mark for any one correct location.

💡 Key knowledge

  • Plant stem cells are found in meristems.
  • Meristems are regions of active growth at the shoot tip and root tip.

🧠 Exam technique

  • Give one clear location only.
  • If you write “stem” or “embryo”, this does not gain the mark for plant stem cells.

❌ Common errors

  • Writing just “stem cells” instead of where they are found.
  • Confusing plant stem cells with animal stem cells.
  • Giving a general plant part without a specific location.
Part 06.2

06.2 — What is one economic use of plant stem cells?

✅ Correct answer

To produce large numbers of identical plants

1 mark for this exact idea.

💡 Key knowledge

  • Plant stem cells can be cloned to make many genetically identical plants.
  • This is useful for agriculture because a successful crop plant can be copied quickly.

🧠 Exam technique

  • The key phrase is large numbers and identical plants.
  • “To create genetically modified crops” is not the answer here.

❌ Common errors

  • Choosing “to increase variation in plants” — cloning does the opposite.
  • Thinking stem cells are mainly used to make new species.
Part 06.3

06.3 — Convert 6 picograms to grams

📐 Calculations — step by step

  1. 1 picogram = 10⁻¹² grams
  2. 6 picograms = 6 × 10⁻¹² grams

Mass = 6 × 10⁻¹² g

1 mark for the correct conversion in standard form.

💡 Key knowledge

  • “Pico” means 10⁻¹².
  • Standard form should be written clearly as a × 10ⁿ .

🧠 Exam technique

  • Include the unit: grams, not just a number.
  • Use the correct power of 10.

❌ Common errors

  • Writing 6 × 10⁻¹² mg or another unit.
  • Forgetting that pico = 10⁻¹².
  • Writing the answer in ordinary form when the question asks for standard form.
Part 06.4

06.4 — Calculate how many hours the cell spent in mitosis

📐 Calculations — step by step

  1. The mitosis sector is 28°.
  2. A full circle is 360°.
  3. Fraction of cycle in mitosis = 28/360.
  4. Time in mitosis = 28/360 × 15
  5. = 1.1666... hours
  6. Rounded to 3 significant figures = 1.17 hours

Time spent in mitosis = 1.17 hours

2 marks: one for the correct method, one for the correct answer.

💡 Key knowledge

  • Pie charts show proportion of time.
  • Use the angle to find the fraction of the full cycle.

🧠 Exam technique

  • Set up the ratio correctly: 28/360 × 15
  • Give the answer with units.
  • Round to 3 significant figures because the question asks for it.

❌ Common errors

  • Using 28/15 or 15/28 instead of part ÷ whole × total.
  • Forgetting to multiply by the total cycle time.
  • Giving an answer without units, or rounding too early.
  • Writing 1 hour 10 minutes without clear units if not asked that way.
Part 06.5

06.5 — Describe what happens in each of the three stages of the cell cycle

✅ Correct answers: the marking points

  • Stage 1: cell growth or increase in number of organelles.
  • Stage 1: DNA replicates / doubles / two copies of each chromosome form.
  • Stage 2 (mitosis): one set of chromosomes moves to each end of the cell.
  • Stage 2: nucleus divides.
  • Stage 3: cytoplasm / cell membrane divides to form two genetically identical cells.

Up to 5 marks available. Correct sequence matters for full credit.

💡 Key knowledge

  • The cell cycle is: growth → DNA replication → mitosis → cell division.
  • Mitosis produces genetically identical daughter cells.
  • The stage labels in the diagram help you match each process to the correct stage.

🧠 Exam technique

  • Use the three stages in order.
  • Names like “interphase” are not needed here; the mark scheme wants the described events.
  • Marks can be gained from a labelled diagram if you cannot write lots of words.
  • To get the top marks, include the idea that the cells formed are identical.

❌ Common errors

  • Mixing up the order of DNA replication and mitosis.
  • Saying only “the cell divides” without describing what happens to the nucleus or chromosomes.
  • Forgetting to mention that the final two cells are identical.
  • Using stage numbers wrongly or not referring to the stages at all.
Examiner insight: Students lost marks when they gave vague descriptions like “the cell grows and then divides”. The best answers named the key biological events: growth, DNA replication, chromosome separation, nucleus division, and cytokinesis producing identical cells.
Part 06.6

06.6 — Give two advantages and two disadvantages of therapeutic cloning

✅ Correct answers — advantages

  • May be used to cure/treat diseases or medical conditions.
  • Can produce replacement cells / tissues / organs.
  • Cells/tissues of any type could be produced.
  • Cells are unlikely to be rejected by the patient.
  • May reduce waiting time for organ transplants.
  • Cells could be used for research.

✅ Correct answers — disadvantages

  • Potential life is killed / destroyed (embryo destroyed).
  • Shortage of donors / eggs.
  • Egg donation / collection has risks.
  • Do not yet know risks / side effects for the patient.
  • May transfer viral infection.
  • Poor success rate to produce viable eggs / embryo.

🧠 Exam technique

  • You need any two advantages and any two disadvantages.
  • Use short, distinct points to avoid repeating the same idea.
  • For full marks, make the answer clearly about therapeutic cloning in medicine.
  • Examples like diabetes or paralysis can help, but are not required.

❌ Common errors

  • Writing about cost — ignore cost references here.
  • Giving ethical points in vague terms only; the mark scheme wants specific biological or medical disadvantages.
  • Saying “identical cells are produced” as a disadvantage — that is not credited.
  • Repeating the same point twice, which only counts once.

💡 Key knowledge: what therapeutic cloning is

  • An embryo is created using a donated egg cell and the patient’s body cell nucleus.
  • Stem cells from the embryo can be cultured and used to make replacement cells.
  • The stem cells are genetically matched to the patient, so rejection is less likely.
Examiner insight: The strongest answers linked the process to medical use: making replacement cells, tissue or organs, and reducing rejection. On the disadvantage side, the best responses mentioned embryo destruction or uncertainty about risks. Answers that only said “it is unethical” or “it costs a lot” did not score from the mark scheme.

Quick model answers

06.1 model answer

Tip of root.

06.2 model answer

To produce large numbers of identical plants.

06.3 model answer

6 × 10⁻¹² g

06.4 model answer

1.17 hours

🧠 How to score full marks overall

  • Be precise with scientific vocabulary: meristem, mitosis, DNA replicates, genetically identical.
  • In calculations, show the full method and give the correct units.
  • For process questions, keep the correct order of events.
  • For advantages/disadvantages, give distinct points that match the biology of therapeutic cloning.

Topics

Biology · B1: Cell Biology · B6: Inheritance, Variation and Evolution

Question and mark scheme from the AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy examination, Biology Paper 1 (Higher), 2018. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.