AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy Biology Paper 2 (Higher), 2019: Question 4

12 marks · Standard Demand difficulty · Extended Answer

Classify animal adaptations, explain how orchid adaptations aid survival and competition, describe how flower colour may have evolved by natural selection, and use amino acid sequence data to identify the orchid species most closely related to an ancestral species.

Practise this question

Question

A biology exam question numbered 04 with four parts about adaptations and evolution. Part 04.1 is a matching task worth 2 marks showing three animal examples with photos and captions: male palm cockatoos use sticks to beat on hollow branches to attract females, the harmless hornet moth has black and yellow stripes to look like a bee or wasp, and sea spiders have automatic muscle contractions that move oxygen around their bodies; these must be matched to the labels structural, behavioural, and functional. Part 04.2 gives bullet points about orchid adaptations including growing attached to other plants, having brightly coloured flowers, producing large quantities of pollen, and producing thousands of tiny light seeds, then asks for a 4-mark description of how these adaptations help survival and competition. Part 04.3 describes a rare ancestral orchid species in the mountains in China with pale yellow flowers and states that all present-day orchids evolved from it; it asks for a 4-mark explanation of how a bright purple-flowered species may have evolved from the ancestral one. Part 04.4 states that DNA determines the amino acid sequence of a specific protein and shows a table of amino acid sequences for an ancestral species and Species A to D with flower colours pale yellow, pale yellow, pink, bright red, and purple; students must suggest which species is most closely related to the ancestral species and give a reason.
Question text

04 Animals have adaptations to survive in their environment.

These adaptations may be structural, behavioural or functional.

04.1 Draw one line from each animal adaptation to the type of adaptation it is.

[2 marks]

Animal adaptation Type of adaptation

Structural

Male palm cockatoos use

sticks to beat on hollow

branches to attract

females.

Behavioural

The harmless hornet moth

has black and yellow

stripes to look like a bee

or wasp.

Functional

Sea spiders have

automatic muscle

contractions that move

oxygen around their 15

bodies.

Plants also have adaptations.

There are more than 28 000 known species of orchid plants.

04.2 Many orchid plants:

• grow attached to other types of plants

• have brightly coloured flowers

• produce large quantities of pollen

• produce thousands of tiny, light seeds.

Describe how these adaptations help orchid plants to survive and compete.

[4 marks]

A rare orchid has been found in the mountains in China.

The orchid has pale yellow flowers.

DNA analysis of the genome shows that it is an ancestral species.

All other present day orchids evolved from this ancestral species millions of

years ago.

04.3 One present day species has bright purple flowers.

Describe how an orchid with bright purple flowers may have evolved from the

ancestral species which has pale yellow flowers.

[4 marks]

04.4 The DNA code determines the sequence of amino acids which are joined together to

form a specific protein.

Table 3 shows part of the amino acid sequence for the colour pigment protein in five

orchid species.

The rest of the amino acid sequence is the same for all the species.

Table 3

Species Amino acid sequence Flower colour

Ancestral species ala-leu-gly-isoleu-tyr-gly-ala-leu-gly-ala pale yellow

Species A ala-isoleu-gly-ala-tyr-gly-ala-tyr-gly-ala pale yellow

Species B ala-leu-ala-isoleu-tyr-gly-ala-tyr-gly-ala pink

Species C ala-isoleu-gly-ala-gly-tyr-gly-leu-gly-ala bright red

Species D ala-leu-gly-isoleu-tyr-tyr-ala-leu-gly-ala purple

Key:

ala = alanine

gly = glycine

*16* isoleu = isoleucine

leu = leucine

tyr = tyrosine

Suggest which orchid species is most closely related to the ancestral species.

Give a reason for your answer.

[2 marks]

Species

Reason

Mark scheme

Show the mark scheme The mark scheme shows answers for Question 04 totaling 12 marks. For 04.1, male palm cockatoos are matched to behavioural, hornet moth to structural, and sea spiders to functional; full marks require all correct, with 1 mark for one or two correct lines and extra lines from a left-hand box negating that box. For 04.2, acceptable points include orchids growing on other plants to gain support and more light for photosynthesis, bright colours attracting pollinators, producing lots of pollen increasing chances of pollination and reproduction, and tiny light seeds dispersing long distances and reducing competition; any four score 4 marks. For 04.3, accepted evolution points include mutation causing purple flowers, environmental change or isolation, purple-flowered plants surviving and breeding, passing on the allele or DNA, and eventual inability to interbreed. For 04.4, the correct species is D because it has the fewest amino acid differences from the ancestral sequence, with only one amino acid change accepted as the explanation.

AO /

Question Answers Extra information Mark Spec.

R f

04.1 2 AO2

4.7.1.4

all correct for 2 marks

allow 1 mark for one or two correct line(s)

additional lines from a box on the left negates the mark for that box

04.2 any four from: 4 AO2

4.7.1.4

• growing on other plants allow to obtain water / minerals / 4.7.1.1

means support to absorb ions / glucose from the other 4.4.1.1

more light (for plant

photosynthesis) ignore nutrients

• bright colours attract

pollinators

or

bright colours attract insects allow fertilisation for transfer of

to transfer pollen pollen

• large quantities of pollen

(increases the likelihood of

pollen transfer) and so more

seeds / reproduction

• tiny / light seeds will travel allow tiny / light seeds will travel

long distances to grow in new away from competitors

areas

• many seeds mean many new allow many seeds so more

plants so will out-compete (orchids) will survive

other species

AO /

Question Answers Extra information Mark

Spec. Ref.

04.3 any four from: 4 AO2

4.7.1.4

• mutations for purple flower (in allow genetic variation gives 4.7.1.1

ancestral species) purple flowers 4.4.1.1

• isolation or change in allow purple orchid more suited 13

environment e.g. area had to a new environment

more insects

• (plants with purple flowers)

survive and breed

• (plants with purple flowers) allow genetic material for allele

pass on allele / gene / DNA /

mutation

• until they were so different allow breed successfully for

they could no longer interbreed

interbreed (with the ancestral

species)

04.4 species D must be an attempt at an 1 AO3

explanation to gain this mark 4.6.4

4.6.1.3

4.6.1.4

because it has the lowest allow because it has the highest 1

number of amino acids different number of amino acids which

(in the sequence) are the same (in the sequence)

or

because it has the lowest allow because it has only one

number of differences in the difference in the sequence

sequence

or

only one / sixth amino acid is allow only the glycine / gly has

different been changed to tyrosine / tyr

Total 12

How to answer it

Animal and Plant Adaptations + Orchid Evolution

What this question tests

You need to recognise types of adaptation, explain how plant adaptations help survival and reproduction, describe evolution by natural selection, and compare amino acid sequences to identify the closest relative.

04.1 — Match each animal adaptation to its type

2 marks

✅ Correct answers

  • Male palm cockatoos use sticks to beat on hollow branches to attract females → Behavioural
  • The harmless hornet moth has black and yellow stripes to look like a bee or wasp → Structural
  • Sea spiders have automatic muscle contractions that move oxygen around their bodies → Functional

💡 Key knowledge

  • Structural = a physical feature of the body.
  • Behavioural = something the animal does.
  • Functional = an internal process or chemical action in the body.

🧠 Exam technique

  • Look at what the animal is doing, not just what it looks like.
  • For 2 marks, you need all three lines correct.
  • If one line is wrong, you can still gain 1 mark for one or two correct matches.

❌ Common errors

  • Calling the cockatoo’s stick-beating a structural adaptation because a stick is involved.
  • Thinking mimicry is always behavioural — the stripes are a physical feature, so this is structural.
  • Mixing up functional and behavioural: moving oxygen around the body is an internal process, not a behaviour.
Examiner note: all correct = 2 marks. One or two correct lines = 1 mark. Extra incorrect lines from a box can cancel a correct match for that box.

04.2 — How orchid adaptations help them survive and compete

4 marks

✅ Correct answer points

  • Growing attached to other plants gives support, so the orchid can reach more light for photosynthesis.
  • Brightly coloured flowers attract pollinators / insects, increasing pollination and fertilisation.
  • Large quantities of pollen increase the chance of pollen being transferred.
  • Thousands of tiny, light seeds can be carried long distances to new areas, away from competitors.
  • Many seeds increase the chance that some will survive and grow into new plants.

💡 Key knowledge

  • Orchids rely on pollinators for sexual reproduction.
  • Seed dispersal helps plants spread into new habitats.
  • Competition is for light, space, water, minerals, and pollinators.

🧠 Exam technique

  • The question says describe how, so you must link each adaptation to a benefit.
  • To score full marks, give at least four distinct points.
  • Use “therefore”, “so”, or “this means” to show the cause-and-effect link.

❌ Common errors

  • Just repeating the adaptation without saying why it helps.
  • Saying “bright colours make the plant pretty” instead of explaining attraction of pollinators.
  • Saying tiny seeds help them “travel” without mentioning new areas or reduced competition.
  • Confusing pollen with seeds.

📐 Mark-building model

  1. Growing on other plants gives support so they can reach more light for photosynthesis.
  2. Bright flowers attract insects/pollinators so pollination is more likely.
  3. Large amounts of pollen increase the chance of transfer.
  4. Tiny light seeds are dispersed further, allowing new orchids to grow away from competitors.
Examiner note: any four relevant explained points gain the 4 marks. Simple statements without explanation often lose marks.

04.3 — How a bright purple orchid species evolved from the ancestral species

4 marks

✅ Correct answer points

  • A mutation occurred in the ancestral species, creating variation in flower colour.
  • Some plants had purple flowers because of this genetic variation.
  • If purple flowers were better suited to the environment, those plants survived and reproduced more.
  • They passed the allele / gene / DNA for purple flowers to their offspring.
  • Over many generations, the purple-flowered plants became more common, until they were so different they could no longer interbreed with the ancestral species.

💡 Key knowledge

  • Mutation creates new alleles.
  • Natural selection means individuals with advantageous features survive and reproduce more.
  • Speciation happens when populations become so different they can no longer interbreed.

🧠 Exam technique

  • Write the sequence: mutation → variation → selection → inheritance → speciation.
  • Marks are awarded for the process, not just for the word “evolution”.
  • Use “over many generations” to show gradual change.

❌ Common errors

  • Saying an individual orchid “changed because it needed to”.
  • Forgetting that the new trait must be passed on to offspring.
  • Describing only survival, not reproduction.
  • Not mentioning that speciation takes place when populations can no longer interbreed.
Examiner commentary: full-mark responses were clear about mutation and inheritance, and linked the colour change to selection in a new environment. Top answers showed a step-by-step evolutionary chain.

04.4 — Which orchid is most closely related to the ancestral species?

2 marks

✅ Correct answer

Species D

  • It has the fewest amino acid differences from the ancestral sequence.
  • Only one amino acid is different, so it is the most closely related.

💡 Key knowledge

  • DNA determines the sequence of amino acids in a protein.
  • Species with more similar amino acid sequences are usually more closely related.
  • In this question, compare the sequences and count differences.

🧠 Exam technique

  • Always give both parts: species and reason.
  • To earn the mark for the explanation, you must make an attempt at a reason.
  • Use wording like “fewest differences” or “most amino acids the same”.

❌ Common errors

  • Choosing the species with the most obvious colour change instead of the most similar sequence.
  • Saying “it looks most similar” without referring to the amino acid sequence.
  • Forgetting to count differences carefully.

📐 Quick sequence check

  1. Read the ancestral sequence.
  2. Compare each species to it amino acid by amino acid.
  3. Count the number of different amino acids.
  4. Species D has the lowest number of differences, so it is most closely related.
Examiner note: 1 mark for species D, 1 mark for a valid comparison such as “fewest differences” or “only one amino acid different”.

Final revision checklist

💡 Remember these definitions

  • Structural = body feature
  • Behavioural = action
  • Functional = internal process
  • Mutation = change in DNA
  • Natural selection = best adapted individuals survive and reproduce more

🧠 How to score well

  • Use precise biology words.
  • Always explain how the adaptation helps survival or reproduction.
  • For evolution questions, describe a population changing over time.
  • For sequence questions, compare the number of differences.

Topics

Biology · B7: Ecology · B6: Inheritance, Variation and Evolution · B4: Bioenergetics

Question and mark scheme from the AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy examination, Biology Paper 2 (Higher), 2019. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.