AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy Physics Paper 1 (Higher), 2019: Question 2
14 marks · Standard Demand difficulty · Extended Answer
Explain and calculate how cooling air and its components affects pressure, changes of state, latent heat, and particle arrangement and movement.
Practise this questionQuestion
Question text
02 A scientist cooled the air inside a container.
02.1 The temperature of the air changed from 20 °C to 0 °C
The volume of the container of air stayed the same.
Explain how the motion of the air molecules caused the pressure in the container to
change as the temperature decreased.
[3 marks]
02.2 The air contained water that froze at 0 °C
The change in internal energy of the water as it froze was 0.70 kJ
The specific latent heat of fusion of water is 330 kJ/kg
Calculate the mass of ice produced.
Use the Physics Equations Sheet.
[3 marks]
Mass of ice = kg
02.3 The air also contained oxygen, nitrogen and carbon dioxide.
Oxygen boils at –183 °C and freezes at –218 °C
Nitrogen boils at –195 °C and freezes at –210 °C
Carbon dioxide sublimates at –78 °C
The scientist continued to cool the air to a temperature of –190 °C
What is the state of each substance at –190 °C?
[2 marks]
Tick ( ) one box for each row of the table.
Substance Solid Liquid Gas
Oxygen
Nitrogen
Carbon dioxide
02.4 The air also contained a small amount of argon.
As the temperature of the air decreased from 20 °C to –190 °C the argon changed
from a gas to a liquid to a solid.
Explain the changes in the arrangement and movement of the particles of the argon
as the temperature of the air decreased.
[6 marks]
Mark scheme
Show the mark scheme
AO /
Question Answers Extra information Mark ID
Spec. Ref.
02.1 pressure decreased 1 AO2.1 E
because molecules have less allow less speed/velocity 1 6.3.3.1
(kinetic) energy
so fewer collisions (with the allow collide with less force 1
wall/container each second)
allow less force on the walls
02.2 an answer of 0.0021(212121…) AO2.1 E
scores 3 marks
6.3.2.2
0.70 = m × 330 1 6.1.1.3
or
700 = m × 330 000
0.70 allow correct rearrangement 1
m = using converted value(s) of E to
or J and/or L to J/kg
m =
330 000
m = 0.0021 (kg) allow 0.0021(212121…) 1
allow correct calculation using
converted value(s) of E and/or L
3 marks can only be awarded
for m = 0.0021(212121…) (kg)
02.3 2 AO3/2b E
Substance Solid Liquid Gas
6.3.1.1
Oxygen
Nitrogen
Carbon dioxide
2 correct answers scores 1 mark.
if more than one tick in a row, neither tick can score a mark
8 02.4 Level 3: Relevant points (reasons/causes) are identified, given in 5–6
detail and logically linked to form a clear account. AO1.1 E
Level 2: Relevant points (reasons/causes) are identified, and there 6.3.1.2
3–4
are attempts at logical linking. The resulting account is not fully
clear.
Level 1: Points are identified and stated simply, but their relevance 1–2
is not clear and there is no attempt at logical linking.
No relevant content
Indicative content
cooling
• as the argon cools the particles slow down
• particles in a liquid move slower than particles in a gas
• particles in a solid move slower than particles in a liquid
• as the liquid/solid cools the particles get closer together
• as the liquid/solid cools the density increases
gas to liquid
• particles change from being spread apart to touching each
other
• particles will (collide with other particles more often and)
change direction more often
liquid to solid
• particles change from a random arrangement to a regular
pattern
• particles change from moving freely to fixed positions
• particles change from moving freely/randomly to vibrating
explanation
• (internal) energy (of the argon) decreases
• (kinetic) energy (of the particles) decreases with temperature
• (potential) energy (of the particles) changes with change of
state (of the argon)
• forces between particles in a gas are negligible/zero
• attractive forces act between atoms when they are close to
each other
• attractive forces between particles are stronger in a solid than
in a liquid
to access level 3 there must be an explanation of changes to
arrangement and movement of particles during either cooling or a
change of state
Total 14
How to answer it
Particle Motion, States of Matter and Latent Heat
This question checks your ability to explain pressure using particle motion, calculate mass from latent heat, identify states of substances from melting/boiling points, and describe how particle arrangement and movement change during cooling and freezing.
Question part 02.1 — Why does pressure change when air cools?
✅ Correct answer
Pressure decreased because the air molecules had less kinetic energy, so they moved more slowly and collided with the container walls less often each second.
💡 Key knowledge
- Gas pressure is caused by particles hitting the walls of the container.
- When temperature decreases, particles lose kinetic energy.
- Slower particles mean fewer collisions per second and less force on the walls.
- The volume stayed the same, so the pressure change is due to particle motion, not a change in space.
🧠 Exam technique
To get all 3 marks, make sure you include all three ideas:
- Pressure decreases.
- Particles have less kinetic energy / move more slowly.
- There are fewer collisions with the walls each second.
The mark scheme allowed speed/velocity and less force on the walls as alternatives.
❌ Common errors
- Saying only “temperature decreases so pressure decreases” without explaining why.
- Talking about particles getting smaller or “losing mass” — this is wrong.
- Forgetting to mention collisions with the container walls.
- Saying particles stop moving completely — they still move, just more slowly.
Question part 02.2 — Calculate the mass of ice produced
📐 Calculations: step-by-step
Use the equation:
energy = mass × specific latent heat
E = m × L
- Convert the energy to joules: 0.70 kJ = 700 J
- Write the values into the equation: 700 = m × 330000
- Rearrange: m = 700 ÷ 330000
- Calculate: m = 0.00212... kg
- Round appropriately: m = 0.0021 kg
Mass of ice = 0.0021 kg
✅ Correct answer
0.0021 kg
This matches the mark scheme’s accepted answer of 0.0021(212121...).
💡 Key knowledge
- Specific latent heat of fusion is the energy needed to change 1 kg of a substance from solid to liquid, or released when it freezes.
- For AQA questions, always check units carefully: kJ must be changed to J.
- The formula uses J, kg, and J/kg.
❌ Common errors
- Using 0.70 instead of 700 J.
- Rearranging incorrectly: the mass must be E ÷ L , not L ÷ E .
- Writing the answer in grams without converting correctly.
- Not giving enough significant figures — 0.0021 kg is the expected form.
Question part 02.3 — Identify the state of each substance at −190 °C
✅ Correct answers
- Oxygen: liquid
- Nitrogen: gas
- Carbon dioxide: solid
💡 Key knowledge
- Oxygen boils at −183 °C, so at −190 °C it is below its boiling point and therefore liquid.
- Nitrogen boils at −195 °C, so at −190 °C it is above its boiling point and therefore gas.
- Carbon dioxide sublimes at −78 °C, so at −190 °C it is solid.
🧠 Exam technique
The key is to compare the temperature to the substance’s change-of-state point:
- If the temperature is below freezing point, it is solid.
- If the temperature is between freezing and boiling point, it is liquid.
- If the temperature is above boiling point, it is gas.
For carbon dioxide, remember the word sublimes means it changes directly from solid to gas.
❌ Common errors
- Choosing the state based only on the word “air” rather than the given boiling/freezing data.
- Mixing up boiling point and freezing point.
- Putting oxygen as gas because “oxygen is a gas at room temperature” — you must use −190 °C.
- Ticking more than one box in a row, which scores no mark for that row.
Question part 02.4 — Explain how argon particles change as it cools from 20 °C to −190 °C
6-mark level-of-response question
✅ What a top-level answer includes
- Argon cools, so particles lose kinetic energy and move more slowly.
- In the gas state, particles are far apart and move randomly in all directions.
- As cooling continues, particles come closer together and collisions become more frequent.
- Argon condenses from a gas to a liquid.
- As it cools further, the liquid particles lose more energy.
- The particles become arranged in a more regular pattern and finally form a solid, where they are fixed in position and only vibrate.
💡 Key knowledge
- Internal energy decreases as temperature decreases.
- Kinetic energy decreases with temperature.
- During a change of state, particles become closer together and attractive forces become more important.
- In a solid, particles are in fixed positions and vibrate.
- Attraction between particles is stronger in a solid than in a liquid.
🧠 Exam technique
This is a Level 3 answer if you do two things well:
- Describe both arrangement and movement of particles.
- Link the changes clearly to cooling and change of state.
Use a clear sequence like this:
gas → liquid → solid
That helps you show the full journey from 20 °C to −190 °C.
❌ Common errors
- Only describing temperature dropping without mentioning particles.
- Saying particles “stop moving” at low temperature — they still vibrate in a solid.
- Not explaining the change from random motion to vibration in fixed positions.
- Forgetting that particles get closer together as gases condense and liquids freeze.
📐 Model answer structure
- As the argon cools, its internal energy decreases and its particles lose kinetic energy.
- In the gas, particles are far apart and move randomly very quickly.
- As they lose energy, they move more slowly and collide less/come together more often, so the gas condenses to a liquid.
- In the liquid, particles are closer together and move more slowly than in a gas.
- On further cooling, particles lose even more kinetic energy, become arranged in a regular pattern and form a solid.
- In the solid, particles are fixed in position and only vibrate.
Topics
Physics · P3: Particle Model of Matter
Question and mark scheme from the AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy examination, Physics Paper 1 (Higher), 2019. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.