AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy Biology Paper 1 (Higher), 2021: Question 3

10 marks · Standard Demand difficulty · Extended Answer

Explain the effect of temperature on fermentation in yeast, including why oil is used, why the mixture is left before measuring gas, and interpreting gas-volume results at 2 °C and 35 °C.

Practise this question

Question

The question page states that fermentation in yeast is used in bread and alcoholic drinks and gives the word equation glucose to ethanol plus carbon dioxide. It asks five parts: define exothermic, explain why a layer of oil is needed, explain why the mixture is left 20 minutes before attaching a gas syringe, explain results for a flask kept at 2 degrees Celsius then moved to 35 degrees Celsius, and explain results for a flask kept at 35 degrees Celsius. A labelled diagram shows a conical flask containing yeast in sugar solution with a layer of oil, connected by a delivery tube to a gas syringe, with the flask standing in a water bath and a thermometer beside it. Two tables give gas volumes in cubic centimetres every 5 minutes: at 2 degrees Celsius the flask produces 0 cm3 from 0 to 30 minutes, while at 35 degrees Celsius it rises from 0 to 115 cm3 by 30 minutes; in the final 15 minutes the flask moved from 2 to 35 degrees Celsius rises to 2, 7 and 22 cm3 at 35, 40 and 45 minutes, while the flask kept at 35 degrees Celsius rises more slowly from 120 to 124 cm3.
Question text

03 Fermentation in yeast is used in the manufacture of bread and alcoholic drinks.

The equation for fermentation is:

glucose → ethanol + carbon dioxide

03.1 Fermentation is an exothermic reaction.

What does exothermic mean?

[1 mark]

A student investigated the effect of temperature on fermentation in yeast.

Figure 3 shows the apparatus.

Figure 3

This is the method used.

1. Mix yeast with sugar solution in a flask.

2. Pour a layer of oil over the surface of the mixture.

3. Put the flask in a water bath at 2 °C and leave for 20 minutes.

4. Attach a gas syringe.

5. Record the volume of gas collected every 5 minutes for 30 minutes.

6. After 30 minutes move the flask to a water bath at 35 °C.

7. Continue to record the volume of gas collected every 5 minutes.

03.2 Suggest why a layer of oil was needed on the surface of the mixture.

[1 mark]

03.3 Suggest why the mixture was left for 20 minutes before the gas syringe was attached.

[1 mark]

Steps 1 to 4 of the method were repeated at 35 °C.

The volume of gas collected was recorded every 5 minutes for 45 minutes.

Table 2 shows the results for both flasks for the first 30 minutes.

Table 3 shows the results for the last 15 minutes, when both flasks were at 35 °C.

Table 2

Volume of gas collected in cm3

Time in minutes

Flask at 2 °C Flask at 35 °C

*11* 0 0 0

50 26

10 0 52

15 0 78

20 0 98

25 0 108

30 0 115

Table 3

Volume of gas collected in cm3

Time in minutes

Flask at 2 °C Flask kept at 35 °C

moved to 35 °C

35 2 120

40 7 123

45 13 22 124

03.4 Explain the results from 0 minutes to 45 minutes for the flask that was at 2 °C and was

then moved to 35 °C.

Use Table 2 and Table 3.

[3 marks]

03.5 Explain the results from 0 minutes to 45 minutes for the flask kept at 35 °C.

Use Table 2 and Table 3.

[4 marks]

Mark scheme

Show the mark scheme The mark scheme is a table listing acceptable answers for questions 03.1 to 03.5 with marks and specification references. It states that exothermic means releases energy to the surroundings; the oil keeps oxygen or air out so fermentation stays anaerobic; leaving the flask allows the mixture or yeast to reach the set temperature; at 2 degrees Celsius enzymes in yeast are too inactive so little or no carbon dioxide is produced, but at 35 degrees Celsius enzymes work and gas is produced. For the 35 degrees Celsius flask, the scheme credits that 35 degrees Celsius is a suitable temperature so carbon dioxide is produced rapidly at first, then the rate slows after about 15 minutes because glucose begins to run out or ethanol concentration increases and harms the cells.

AO /

Question Answers Extra information Mark

Spec. Ref.

03.1 releases energy (to the allow transfers (thermal) energy 1 AO1

surroundings) to the surroundings 4.4.2.1

ignore transfers energy

unqualified

03.2 to keep oxygen out allow to keep air out 1 AO3

allow (because) fermentation is 4.4.2.1

an anaerobic reaction

allow to prevent aerobic

respiration

03.3 to allow the mixture / yeast / allow to reach 2 °C 1 AO3

cells to reach the temperature allow so yeast can equilibrate 4.4.2.1

allow idea that contraction of

gas (on cooling) would hinder

results collection

03.4 (2 °C is) too cold for enzymes / allow (at 2 °C) few / no collisions 1 AO2

yeast to work (between sugar and enzymes) 4.2.2.1

4.4.2.1

(so) no carbon dioxide / gas do not accept an incorrect gas 1

produced

or

(so) fermentation did not occur

or

fermentation was very slow

enzymes become active at allow at 35 °C the enzymes 1

35 °C so carbon dioxide / gas started to work so carbon

was produced dioxide / gas was produced

03.5 ideal / suitable temperature for 1 AO1

enzymes / yeast to work

(so) carbon dioxide / gas do not accept an incorrect gas 1 AO2

produced (rapidly)

(after time / ≥ 15 minutes) rate / allow (after time / ≥ 15 minutes) 1 AO2

fermentation slowed less gas produced per minute

(because) sugar / glucose / food 1 AO2

began to run out

or

(because) increased

concentration of ethanol / 4.2.2.1

alcohol started to kill the cells 4.4.2.1

Total 10

How to answer it

Fermentation in yeast: temperature investigation

What this question tests

This question checks your knowledge of fermentation, why oil is used to exclude oxygen, why the mixture is left to reach the correct temperature, and how to use results from tables to explain the effect of temperature on the rate of fermentation.

Mark focus: short, precise biology answers; use the data to compare the two temperatures; explain results using enzyme activity, temperature, and limiting factors.

Question 03

Yeast fermentation and temperature

Fermentation: glucose → ethanol + carbon dioxide

✅ Key fact

Fermentation in yeast is used to make bread and alcoholic drinks. It is an anaerobic process, meaning it happens without oxygen.

Part (a) — 03.1 What does exothermic mean? [1]

✅ Correct answer

Releases energy to the surroundings.

💡 Key knowledge

  • “Exothermic” means energy is transferred out of the reaction.
  • The mark scheme allows: releases energy or transfers thermal energy to the surroundings.

🧠 Exam technique

  • For 1 mark, keep it simple and direct.
  • Say what happens to energy, not just “it gets hot”.

❌ Common errors

  • “Gives off heat” can be okay, but “transfers energy” without saying where is too vague.
  • Don’t write “energy is used up” — that is not the definition.

Part (b) — 03.2 Why was a layer of oil needed? [1]

✅ Correct answer

To keep oxygen out.

💡 Key knowledge

  • Fermentation is an anaerobic reaction.
  • The oil layer stops air/oxygen reaching the yeast.
  • This also helps prevent aerobic respiration.

🧠 Exam technique

If you want to improve the answer, add the science idea behind it:

“To keep oxygen out because fermentation is anaerobic.”

❌ Common errors

  • Writing “to stop gases escaping” is not the reason here.
  • Don’t say it stops carbon dioxide entering — the point is to exclude oxygen.

Part (c) — 03.3 Why was the mixture left for 20 minutes before attaching the gas syringe? [1]

✅ Correct answer

To allow the mixture / yeast / cells to reach 2 °C.

💡 Key knowledge

  • The mixture must be at the same temperature before measurements begin.
  • This makes the test fair and gives more reliable results.

🧠 Exam technique

  • Always link this to temperature control in experiments.
  • Good wording: “to equilibrate” or “to reach the water bath temperature”.

❌ Common errors

  • “To let the yeast settle” is not the point.
  • “To let the gas syringe warm up” is irrelevant.

Part (d) — 03.4 Explain the results from 0 to 45 minutes for the flask that was at 2 °C and then moved to 35 °C. [3]

📐 Data to use

  • At 2 °C, the gas volume stays at 0 cm³ from 0 to 30 minutes.
  • After moving to 35 °C, gas increases from 2 cm³ at 35 min to 22 cm³ at 45 min.

✅ Full-mark explanation

At 2 °C, it is too cold for the enzymes in yeast to work properly, so no carbon dioxide is produced or fermentation is very slow. When the flask is moved to 35 °C, the enzymes become active, so carbon dioxide is produced.

💡 Key knowledge

  • Enzymes work more slowly at low temperature because there is less kinetic energy and fewer successful collisions.
  • At a warmer temperature, enzymes work faster, so more CO₂ is produced.

🧠 Exam technique

  • Use the data in your explanation: 0 cm³ at 2 °C, then 2 → 22 cm³ after moving to 35 °C.
  • For 3 marks, you usually need:
    • a description of the pattern,
    • a temperature/enzyme explanation,
    • and a link to carbon dioxide production / fermentation.

❌ Common errors

  • Saying the gas is oxygen — the gas produced is carbon dioxide.
  • Only describing the data without explanation.
  • Writing “the yeast died at 2 °C” — that is usually too strong and not needed.

Part (e) — 03.5 Explain the results from 0 to 45 minutes for the flask kept at 35 °C. [4]

📐 Use the data carefully

  • At 35 °C, gas is produced quickly at first: 0 cm³ → 120 cm³ by 35 minutes.
  • After about 15 minutes, the rate slows down: the increase becomes smaller (for example, 115 cm³ at 30 min, 120 cm³ at 35 min, 123 cm³ at 40 min, 124 cm³ at 45 min).

✅ Model answer

35 °C is a suitable temperature for yeast enzymes, so carbon dioxide is produced rapidly at first. After about 15 minutes, the rate of fermentation slows down because the glucose / sugar starts to run out or because the ethanol concentration increases and starts to damage the cells.

💡 Key knowledge

  • 35 °C is close to the optimum temperature for yeast enzymes in this question.
  • Fermentation rate can slow when the substrate runs out.
  • Ethanol is a product of fermentation and can become harmful to yeast cells.

🧠 Exam technique

  • To reach full marks, include all of these:
    • temperature explanation — enzymes work well at 35 °C,
    • data quote — rapid gas production at first,
    • slowdown after 15 minutes,
    • cause — sugar runs out or ethanol builds up.
  • Use the graph/table trend, not just one number.

❌ Common errors

  • Confusing the gas again — it is carbon dioxide, not oxygen.
  • Saying “temperature causes more sugar” — incorrect.
  • Not mentioning why the rate slows later on.

Quick memory points

💡 Fermentation facts

  • Yeast ferments glucose to produce ethanol and carbon dioxide.
  • It happens without oxygen.
  • Enzymes control the reaction rate.

🧠 How to score marks

  • Use short, scientific phrases.
  • Quote data from the table when asked to explain results.
  • Always link temperature to enzyme activity.

❌ Biggest traps

  • Wrong gas: it is carbon dioxide.
  • Ignoring the table.
  • Not explaining the slowdown at 35 °C.

Examiner-style summary

Students usually lost marks when they gave vague statements like “the reaction got hotter” or named the wrong gas. The top answers were the ones that used the results accurately, referred to enzyme activity, and explained why the rate changed over time.

In the highest-quality responses, students linked the low temperature to enzymes not working well, then linked the higher temperature to faster fermentation, and finally explained the later slowdown by running out of glucose or ethanol build-up.

Topics

Biology · B4: Bioenergetics

Question and mark scheme from the AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy examination, Biology Paper 1 (Higher), 2021. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.