AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy Biology Paper 1 (Higher), 2021: Question 5

17 marks · Standard Demand difficulty · Extended Answer

Identify blood vessels and blood flow through the heart, evaluate statins versus stents for reducing heart attack risk, explain breathlessness after a heart attack, and explain the use and advantages of stem cells for repairing heart tissue.

Practise this question

Question

A biology exam page shows Figure 5, a simple grey outline diagram of the human heart with four labelled blood vessels marked A, B, C and D at the top. Question 05.1 asks which labelled vessel transports blood with the highest oxygen concentration into the heart; 05.2 asks which labelled vessel transports blood at the highest pressure; and 05.3 asks for the correct route of blood flow through the heart to the lungs from four multiple-choice options. Lower on the page, 05.4 gives background that heart attacks happen when heart muscle cells do not get enough oxygen and asks for an evaluation of statins compared with a stent to reduce risk of heart attack in a 6-mark extended response. Question 05.5 asks why heart attack survivors get out of breath easily, 05.6 explains that patches of beating heart cells are made from a person's own cells converted into stem cells and asks why stem cells are used, and 05.7 asks for two advantages of using the person's own stem cells rather than embryonic stem cells.
Question text

05 Figure 5 shows the human heart.

Figure 5

05.1 Which blood vessel transports blood with the highest oxygen concentration into

the heart?

[1 mark]

Tick ( ) one box.

A B C D

05.2 Blood pressure is a measure of the force of the blood against the walls of the

blood vessels.

Which blood vessel transports blood at the highest pressure?

[1 mark]

Tick ( ) one box.

A B 19C D

05.3 What is the correct order for blood flowing through the heart to the lungs?

[1 mark]

Tick ( ) one box.

left atrium → left ventricle → pulmonary artery

left atrium → left ventricle → pulmonary vein

right atrium → right ventricle → pulmonary artery

right atrium → right ventricle → pulmonary vein20

Every year thousands of people in the UK have heart attacks.

A heart attack is caused when the heart muscle cells do not get enough oxygen,

causing the cells to die.

05.4 Statins and stents are two treatments used to reduce the risk of someone having a

heart attack.

Evaluate the use of statins compared with the use of a stent to reduce the risk of a

heart attack.

[6 marks]

05.5 Many people who survive a heart attack get out of breath easily when they

exercise gently.

Explain why heart attack survivors get out of breath easily.

[4 marks]

Scientists have developed patches of beating heart cells to repair damaged

heart tissue.

The patches are placed onto areas of the heart where cells have died. New cells grow

to replace the dead cells.

The patches are made using a person’s own cells that are converted into stem cells.

05.6 Explain why stem cells are used to make the patches.

[2 marks]

05.7 The scientists could have used human embryonic stem cells to make the patches.

Give two advantages of using stem cells made from the person’s own cells, rather

than using embryonic stem cells.

[2 marks]

Mark scheme

Show the mark scheme The mark scheme is a table listing answers and level descriptors. For 05.1 the answer is D, for 05.2 the answer is C, and for 05.3 the answer is right atrium to right ventricle to pulmonary artery. For 05.4, a level-of-response mark scheme awards up to 6 marks for evaluating statins and stents, with indicative points including advantages and disadvantages of statins such as lowering cholesterol, slowing fatty build-up and possible side effects, and advantages and disadvantages of stents such as holding an artery open immediately but with risks from surgery or blood clots. For 05.5 the points explain that damaged heart muscle pumps less effectively, so less oxygen reaches body cells and breathing rate increases; for 05.6 stem cells are undifferentiated and can form heart muscle cells; for 05.7 any two advantages are accepted, including reduced rejection, no embryo damage, and adult consent.

AO /

Question Answers Extra information Mark

Spec. Ref.

05.1 D 1 AO2

4.2.2.2

05.2 C 1 AO3

4.2.2.2

05.3 right atrium → right ventricle → 1 AO1

pulmonary artery 4.2.2.2

AO /

Spec. Ref.

Level 3: A judgement, strongly linked and logically supported by a 5‒6 AO3

05.4 sufficient range of correct reasons, is given.

Level 2: Some logically linked reasons are given. There may also 3‒4 AO3

be a simple judgement.

Level 1: Relevant points are made. They are not logically linked. 1‒2 AO1

No relevant content 0

4.2.2.4

Indicative content

Advantages of statins

• easy to take or not invasive (procedure)

• decrease blood cholesterol

• slow down build-up of fatty materials in arteries

• maintain blood flow to heart muscle cells

• low cost (compared to stent operation)

Disadvantages of statins

• might be side effects of drug eg muscle pain

• effects take time to happen

• drug will need to be taken long term

• might forget to take drug

Advantages of stent

• blocked artery is held open

• blood flow to heart muscle cells is increased

• stent will remain in place for a long time

• effect of stent is immediate

• rapid recovery from operation

Disadvantages of stent

• risk of infection from operation

• risk of surgery eg heart attack or bleeding

• risk of thrombosis or blood clot

For Level 3, arguments for and against both treatments are

needed.

05.5 heart (muscle) cannot contract / allow heart (muscle) is not as 1 AO2

pump as effectively / powerfully strong 4.2.2.2 17

4.2.2.4

(so) less blood pumped out of ignore reference to rate of blood 1 4.4.2.1

heart or to body (on each beat / flow

contraction)

(so) less oxygen (reaches cells / allow (so) more anaerobic 1

body) for (aerobic) respiration respiration

(so) breathing rate increases to 1

supply more oxygen

or

(so) breathing rate increases to allow (so) breathing rate

repay oxygen debt increases to break down lactic

acid

05.6 stem cells are undifferentiated allow stem cells can differentiate 1 AO1

cells allow stem cells can develop

into different types of cell

ignore stem cells can become

specialised

ignore stem cells are not

specialised

(therefore) can form heart allow (therefore) can form 1 AO2

(muscle) cells muscle cells 4.1.2.3

4.2.2.4

05.7 allow converse if clearly AO3

referring to embryonic stem cells 4.1.2.3

any two from: 2

• cells will not be rejected

• no risk of damage to embryo allow no (potential) human life

destroyed / damaged

• adult can give consent

ignore unethical unqualified

ignore religion unqualified

Total 17

How to answer it

Difficulty: Standard Demand

Heart vessels, blood flow, heart attack treatment and stem cells

What this question tests

This question checks whether you can label blood vessels on a heart diagram, remember the route of blood through the heart, and explain how treatments work. It also tests evaluation skills: comparing statins and stents, explaining why heart attack survivors get out of breath, and using key stem cell facts to explain tissue repair and why a person’s own cells are useful.

Short title

Blood flow, heart disease and stem cells

Total marks on the question: 17

Question 05.1

Which blood vessel transports blood with the highest oxygen concentration into the heart?

✅ Correct answer

D

In the diagram, D is the pulmonary vein, which brings oxygenated blood from the lungs into the heart.

💡 Key knowledge

  • The pulmonary vein carries the most oxygen-rich blood into the heart.
  • It returns blood from the lungs to the left atrium.
  • The pulmonary artery is different: it carries deoxygenated blood away from the heart to the lungs.

🧠 Exam technique

  • Use the direction of blood flow, not just the shape of the vessel.
  • Check whether the question says into the heart or out of the heart.

❌ Common errors

  • Choosing the pulmonary artery because it sounds like a vessel linked to lungs.
  • Thinking the vessel with the highest oxygen concentration must be an artery.

Question 05.2

Which blood vessel transports blood at the highest pressure?

✅ Correct answer

C

C is the aorta, which carries blood from the left ventricle to the body at the highest pressure.

💡 Key knowledge

  • Blood pressure is highest in the aorta because it leaves the heart directly after the left ventricle contracts.
  • The left ventricle has the thickest muscle wall because it pumps blood all around the body.

🧠 Exam technique

  • High pressure = vessel closest to the strongest pump on the left side of the heart.
  • Remember: arteries carry blood away from the heart, but pressure is not the same thing as oxygen content.

❌ Common errors

  • Picking the pulmonary artery because it is an artery.
  • Mixing up pressure with oxygen concentration.

Question 05.3

What is the correct order for blood flowing through the heart to the lungs?

✅ Correct answer

right atrium → right ventricle → pulmonary artery

This is the route for deoxygenated blood from the heart to the lungs.

💡 Key knowledge

  • Blood enters the right atrium first.
  • It then goes into the right ventricle.
  • The pulmonary artery takes it to the lungs.

🧠 Exam technique

  • Learn the pathway as a chain, not as separate facts.
  • For the lungs, remember: right side → lungs.

❌ Common errors

  • Writing pulmonary vein instead of pulmonary artery.
  • Starting on the left side of the heart when the question is about blood going to the lungs.

Question 05.4

Evaluate the use of statins compared with the use of a stent to reduce the risk of heart attack.

✅ What a full-mark answer needs

A strong answer must give advantages and disadvantages of both treatments, then make a clear judgement.

💡 Key knowledge

  • Statins are drugs that reduce blood cholesterol.
  • They help slow the build-up of fatty material in arteries.
  • They are easy to take and do not require surgery.
  • Possible disadvantages: side effects such as muscle pain, and they may need to be taken for life.
  • Stents hold a blocked artery open.
  • This increases blood flow to the heart muscle immediately.
  • Possible disadvantages: operation risks such as infection, bleeding or a blood clot.

🧠 Exam technique

  • To reach the top level, you need both sides of the comparison.
  • Use comparative phrases: However , On the other hand , In contrast , Therefore .
  • End with a judgement such as: Statins are better for long-term prevention, but stents are better for immediate relief.
  • The examiner looks for a logical argument, not just a list.

❌ Common errors

  • Only describing statins or only describing stents.
  • Not saying which one is better for which situation.
  • Forgetting that statins are a preventative treatment, while stents are a more direct treatment for a narrowed artery.

📐 How to structure a 6-mark evaluation

  1. State a point for statins.
  2. Explain why that point matters.
  3. State a disadvantage of statins.
  4. State a point for stents.
  5. Explain why that point matters.
  6. Finish with a balanced conclusion.

✅ Example top-band answer

Statins can be useful because they are easy to take and they reduce cholesterol, which slows the build-up of fatty material in arteries. This can reduce the risk of a heart attack over time. However, they may cause side effects and have to be taken for a long time. A stent is useful because it holds a blocked artery open straight away, so blood flow to the heart muscle increases immediately. This is a big advantage if the artery is badly narrowed. On the other hand, a stent needs an operation, so there is a risk of infection, bleeding or a blood clot. Overall, statins are better for long-term prevention, but stents are better when blood flow needs to be improved quickly.

Mark scheme insight: Level 3 responses were strongly linked and had a clear judgement. Students lost marks when they gave a list of facts without comparing them.

Question 05.5

Explain why heart attack survivors get out of breath easily.

✅ Correct answer points

  • The heart muscle cannot contract as effectively / powerfully.
  • So less blood is pumped out to the body each beat.
  • So less oxygen reaches body cells for aerobic respiration.
  • Breathing rate increases to supply more oxygen or to repay oxygen debt / break down lactic acid.

💡 Key knowledge

  • A heart attack damages heart muscle, so the pump becomes weaker.
  • Less oxygen means cells may carry out more anaerobic respiration.
  • Anaerobic respiration produces lactic acid, which contributes to fatigue and breathlessness.

🧠 Exam technique

  • Use a chain of cause and effect: damage → weaker pumping → less oxygen delivery → breathlessness.
  • For 4 marks, give at least 4 linked points.
  • You can also mention oxygen debt and the need to remove lactic acid.

❌ Common errors

  • Just writing “they have a bad heart” without explaining the effect on blood flow.
  • Talking only about the lungs and ignoring the weakened heart pump.
  • Confusing breathing rate with heart rate.

Question 05.6

Explain why stem cells are used to make the patches.

✅ Correct answer

Stem cells are undifferentiated, so they can differentiate into heart muscle cells.

💡 Key knowledge

  • Stem cells are cells that have not yet specialised.
  • They can develop into different types of cells.
  • Here, they are needed because the damaged tissue needs new heart muscle cells.

🧠 Exam technique

  • For 2 marks, include both: undifferentiated and can become heart muscle cells.
  • Use the word therefore to show the link between the two ideas.

❌ Common errors

  • Saying only “they are stem cells” without explaining why that helps.
  • Writing “they can become any cell” without naming heart muscle cells.
  • Using “specialised” instead of “undifferentiated”.

Question 05.7

Give two advantages of using stem cells made from the person’s own cells, rather than embryonic stem cells.

✅ Correct answers: any two

  • Cells will not be rejected.
  • No risk of damage to embryo.
  • Adult can give consent.

💡 Key knowledge

  • Using a person’s own cells means the body recognises them as “self”.
  • Embryonic stem cells involve using an embryo, which raises ethical concerns.
  • Consent is possible from an adult, but not from an embryo.

🧠 Exam technique

  • Give two separate advantages.
  • Write them clearly as two numbered points to avoid losing one mark.
  • If you choose “not rejected”, make it clear that this is because the cells come from the person’s own body.

❌ Common errors

  • Giving ethical opinions without linking them to the mark scheme.
  • Saying “they are better” without saying why.
  • Repeating the same idea twice, e.g. “not rejected” and “compatible” without extra detail.

Quick recall recap

💡 Heart and blood vessel facts

  • Pulmonary vein carries oxygenated blood into the heart.
  • Aorta carries blood at the highest pressure.
  • Blood to the lungs travels: right atrium → right ventricle → pulmonary artery.

💡 Treatment facts

  • Statins lower cholesterol and help prevent further artery narrowing.
  • Stents open blocked arteries immediately.
  • Top-band evaluation means comparing both, then judging which is better in which case.

💡 Stem cell facts

  • Stem cells are undifferentiated.
  • They can become specialised cells such as heart muscle cells.
  • Using a person’s own cells avoids rejection.

Topics

Biology · B2: Organisation · B1: Cell Biology

Question and mark scheme from the AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy examination, Biology Paper 1 (Higher), 2021. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.