AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy Biology Paper 2 (Higher), 2022: Question 6

11 marks · Standard Demand difficulty · Extended Answer

Classify the polar bear, calculate the rate of Arctic sea ice loss from a graph, and use ecological evidence to explain and evaluate how changes in sea ice affect polar bear populations.

Practise this question

Question

The question page is about polar bears in Arctic habitats and contains four parts labelled 06.1 to 06.4. Part 06.1 shows a classification table for Ursus maritimus with some entries already filled: chordata, mammalia, carnivora, ursidae, Ursus and maritimus; the student must complete the missing classification groups and names, for 2 marks. Below is Figure 5, a scatter graph of September sea ice area in the Arctic from about 1980 to 2017 with year on the x-axis and area of sea ice in millions of square kilometres on the y-axis, plus a downward sloping trend line; part 06.2 asks for the annual rate of loss of sea ice between 1985 and 2017 using the trend line, for 3 marks. Further text explains uncertainty in polar bear numbers, reduced hunting in some areas, decreases in average mass and height in some populations, dependence on seals that live and breed on sea ice in winter and feed in summer, seasonal feeding and fat storage by polar bears, and unexpectedly high metabolic rates with long-distance swimming in winter 2017; part 06.3 asks why polar bears find it harder to catch seals in autumn than in spring, and part 06.4 asks students to evaluate what might happen to the future Arctic polar bear population, for 4 marks.
Question text

06 The polar bear is a mammal that lives in arctic habitats.

06.1 Complete Table 2 for the classification of the polar bear, Ursus maritimus.

[2 marks]

Table 2

Classification group Name

Domain

Kingdom

chordata

Class mammalia

Order carnivora

ursidae

Genus Ursus

Species 19 maritimus

Scientists have been measuring the area of sea ice in the Arctic since 1980.

Figure 5 shows the area covered by sea ice every September.

Figure 5

06.2 Determine the annual rate of loss of sea ice between 1985 and 2017.

A trend line has been drawn on Figure 5 to help you.

[3 marks]

Rate of loss = million square kilometres per year

The total number of polar bears living on the arctic ice is not known.

The hunting of polar bears has been banned or reduced in some areas.

In some populations the average mass and height of polar bears has decreased.

*19* Polar bears eat seals. Seals live on the sea ice in winter and raise their pups there in

early spring. In the summer seals live mainly in the sea catching fish to eat.

Polar bears spend much of the year hunting seals on the sea ice and in the sea

nearby. The sea ice area is at its lowest each year in September at the end of

summer. The polar bears feed mainly in early spring, and again in autumn to build fat

stores to survive the next winter.

During the winter of 2017 scientists measured the metabolic rates of nine female

polar bears and found them to be much higher than expected. Cameras attached to

the female polar bears showed they had to swim long distances to find seals to eat.

06.3 Suggest why polar bears find it harder to catch seals in autumn than in spring.

[2 marks]

06.4 Evaluate what might happen to the population of polar bears in the Arctic in the future.

[4 marks]

Mark scheme

Show the mark scheme The mark scheme is presented in separate tables for questions 06.1 to 06.4. For 06.1 it awards 2 marks for all four correct classification entries, or 1 mark for two or three correct, with accepted answers including eukaryote or eukaryota, animalia, phylum or phyla, and family; italics and letter case are ignored. For 06.2 it gives graph readings of about 7.75 and 4.32, a gradient calculation of 3.43 divided by 32, and a final rate of about 0.1 million square kilometres per year, allowing small tolerances. For 06.3 it credits points such as fewer seals left on ice, most seals being in the sea, seals being older and faster, or increased competition between polar bears. For 06.4 it uses level-based marking, with indicative content including population decrease due to global warming, reduced sea ice habitat, fewer seals, greater swimming distances, higher energy demands, poorer fat storage, continued hunting and possible extinction, but also possible maintenance or increase if hunting is reduced further, laws or quotas are introduced, emissions are reduced, or polar bear behaviour changes; to reach the higher level both decrease and increase or maintenance must be considered.

AO /

Question Answers Extra information Mark

Spec. Ref.

06.1 2 marks for all 4 correct 2 AO1

1 mark for 2 or for 3 correct AO2

eukaryote / 4.6.4

eukaryota

animal(ia)

phylum

/ phyla

family

ignore italics and upper / lower

case letters

AO /

Spec. Ref.

06.2 two readings from graph allow in range of 7.7 to 7.8 and 1 AO2

view with 7.75 and 4.32 4.3 to 4.4 4.7.3.5

Figure 5 allow two readings from two

identified points on the line,

allowing a tolerance of ± ½ a

small square

calculation of gradient allow calculation of gradient 1

3.43 using correct readings from

32 dy

graph, dx

correct answer allow correct answer using 1

0.1(071875) student’s correct readings from

– OMBINED SCIENCE: TRIgraphLOGY – –

AO /

Spec. Ref.

06.3 any two from: 2 AO3

in autumn 4.7.3.5

• no / fewer seals left on ice

20 or

all / most seals are in the sea ignore seals are in the sea

unqualified

• seals are adults / older so

swim faster

• more competition between

polar bears – OMBINED SCIENCE: TRILOGY – –

AO /

Question Answers Mark

Spec. Ref.

06.4 Level 2: A judgement, strongly linked and logically supported by a 3–4 AO3

sufficient range of correct reasons, is given.

Level 1: Some logically linked reasons are given. There may also 1–2 AO2

be a simple judgement.

No relevant content 0

4.7.1.1

Indicative content 4.7.3.5

may decrease because:

• global warming is melting sea ice

• less sea ice each year so less habitat / hunting area

• as ice / habitat disappears seals will decrease in number

• having to swim longer distances to find seals, wastes energy

• increased metabolic rate means more food is required

• not building up fat stores in the autumn means fewer will survive

each winter

• decrease in mass / height may reduce hunting ability / strength

• hunting in some / most areas continues

• less likely to find mates

• eventually the species may become extinct

may increase / maintain numbers if:

• more laws put in place to stop hunting or laws to stop hunting will

allow bears to reproduce

• quotas introduced to reduce hunting

• nations / people work to reduce carbon dioxide emissions to halt

global warming

• (feeding / hunting) behaviour of polar bears changes

For Level 2 both increase / maintenance and decrease of the polar

bear population must be considered 21

Total Question 6 11

How to answer it

Polar bears, sea ice and classification

What this question tests
This question tests biological classification, reading values from a graph, finding a gradient, and explaining how environmental change affects polar bears. You need to use correct scientific terms, pick values from a trend line, and give linked reasons in an evaluation.

Overall mark demand: Standard Demand

Short title: Polar bears and shrinking sea ice

This question mixes recall, graph skills, and explanation. The last part is the most challenging because it needs a balanced judgement.

Part 06.1 — Complete the classification table

✅ Correct answers

  • Domain: eukaryota / eukaryote
  • Kingdom: animalia / animal
  • Phylum: chordata
  • Family: ursidae

💡 Key knowledge

  • The classification sequence is: Domain, Kingdom, Phylum, Class, Order, Family, Genus, Species.
  • Ursus maritimus is the binomial name: Ursus = genus, maritimus = species.
  • Polar bears are mammals, so they are in the animal kingdom and chordate phylum.

🧠 Exam technique

  • Use the given clues in the table to work out the missing group names.
  • Case and italics are not important here — the mark scheme says to ignore them.
  • There are 2 marks for all 4 correct; 1 mark for 2 or 3 correct.

❌ Common errors

  • Writing phylum or family in the name column instead of the taxon name.
  • Mixing up class and order.
  • Forgetting that the domain is eukaryote.

Part 06.2 — Determine the annual rate of loss of sea ice

Use the trend line on Figure 5

📐 Calculations — step by step

  1. Choose two points on the trend line, not random dots.
  2. From the graph, suitable readings are about 7.75 million km² in 1985 and 4.32 million km² in 2017.
  3. Find the change in area: 7.75 - 4.32 = 3.43 million km².
  4. Find the time interval: 2017 - 1985 = 32 years.
  5. Calculate the rate: 3.43 ÷ 32 = 0.1071875 million km² per year.
  6. Round appropriately: 0.11 million km² per year, or 0.1 million km² per year if using the graph estimate given in the mark scheme.

✅ Correct answer

  • Rate of loss = 0.1 million square kilometres per year
  • Accept values close to this if calculated from correct graph readings.

💡 Key knowledge

  • Rate = change in y ÷ change in x.
  • Here, y is area of sea ice and x is time.
  • The unit must be written as million square kilometres per year.

❌ Common errors

  • Using two random dots instead of the trend line.
  • Subtracting the years in the wrong order and getting a negative rate.
  • Forgetting the units or writing only 0.1 with no unit.
  • Giving the area loss without dividing by time.

🧠 Exam technique

  • The examiner allows small variation in the graph readings if they come from the trend line.
  • To gain full marks, show the working clearly: readings → subtraction → division → final answer.
  • Top answers made clear use of the trend line and gave the answer with correct units.

Part 06.3 — Explain why polar bears find it harder to catch seals in autumn

✅ Correct answers

Any two of the following:

  • In autumn there are fewer seals left on the ice / most seals are in the sea.
  • Seals are adults or older, so they swim faster.
  • There is more competition between polar bears.

💡 Key knowledge

  • In spring, seals are on the ice raising pups, so they are easier to find.
  • By autumn, the ice area is at its lowest, so hunting opportunities are reduced.
  • Polar bears may need to travel further, which uses more energy.

🧠 Exam technique

  • Give two separate, clear reasons for 2 marks.
  • Write the answer as cause → effect.
  • Use wording from the mark scheme ideas, but not necessarily exact phrases.

❌ Common errors

  • Saying only that “there are seals in the sea” without explaining why that makes catching them harder.
  • Giving vague answers such as “it is colder” or “they are hungry” without linking to hunting success.
  • Repeating the same idea twice.

Part 06.4 — Evaluate what might happen to the polar bear population in the future

This is a 4-mark evaluation question

💡 Key knowledge

  • Global warming is melting sea ice.
  • Less sea ice means less habitat and less hunting area.
  • Polar bears may need to swim longer distances to find seals, wasting energy.
  • Less food means they may build up less fat, so fewer survive winter.
  • Decreased mass/height may reduce hunting ability and strength.
  • Hunting bans or reduced hunting could help the population recover in some areas.
  • Reducing carbon dioxide emissions could slow future habitat loss.

✅ What a strong answer includes

  • A clear judgement: the population will likely decrease unless conditions improve.
  • At least two reasons for decrease.
  • At least one reason why numbers could increase or be maintained.
  • A linked conclusion showing which effect is more likely overall.

🧠 Exam technique

  • For Level 2, you must consider both decrease and increase/maintenance.
  • Make a judgement such as: “Overall, the population is likely to decrease because…”
  • Support each point with a chain of reasoning, not just a list of facts.
  • Good evaluation answers are balanced and then reach a final conclusion.

❌ Common errors

  • Only describing sea ice loss without linking it to polar bear survival.
  • Talking about one side only, for example only why the population could fall.
  • Not making a conclusion.
  • Writing “global warming is bad” without explaining the biological effect.

📐 Suggested full-mark style response

The polar bear population is likely to decrease in the future because global warming is melting sea ice, so they will have less habitat and less area to hunt seals. They may need to swim longer distances to find food, which wastes energy. If they catch less food in autumn they will build up smaller fat stores, so fewer will survive winter. Their mass and height may also decrease, making hunting harder. However, the population could increase or be maintained in some places if hunting is reduced or banned and if carbon dioxide emissions are lowered. Overall, the population is more likely to fall unless sea ice loss is slowed.

Examiner insight: what separated top answers?

💡 Top-level responses

  • Used precise scientific terms like habitat, energy, fat stores, and competition.
  • Gave a balanced evaluation in 06.4.
  • Showed calculation steps clearly in 06.2.

❌ Where marks were lost

  • Misreading the graph and using values from a single point instead of the trend line.
  • Not stating the unit for the rate.
  • Giving incomplete explanations, especially in 06.3 and 06.4.

Topics

Biology · B6: Inheritance, Variation and Evolution · B7: Ecology

Question and mark scheme from the AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy examination, Biology Paper 2 (Higher), 2022. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.