AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy Biology Paper 1 (Higher), 2024: Question 6

11 marks · Standard Demand difficulty · Extended Answer

Describe mitosis and explain how smoking damages the lungs and increases cancer risk.

Practise this question

Question

The page shows Question 06 with three parts. In 06.1, a diagram labelled Figure 5 shows a lung cell dividing in four stages: chromosomes replicate, chromosomes separate to opposite ends, nuclei form, and the cell splits into two identical cells. The question asks: “Describe the process of the cell cycle shown in Figure 5.” worth 4 marks. In 06.2, the text says “Lung cancer is malignant. Explain what is meant by a malignant tumour.” worth 3 marks. In 06.3, Figure 6 compares two alveoli: Person A is a non-smoker with a more folded, larger-surface-area alveolus, and Person B is a smoker with a smoother, smaller-surface-area alveolus. The question says both people do the same exercise and asks why person B breathes much faster than person A during exercise, worth 4 marks.
Question text

06 Smoking increases the risk of lung cancer.

06.1 Figure 5 shows a lung cell dividing.

Figure 5

Describe the process of the cell cycle shown in Figure 5.

[4 marks]

06.2 Lung cancer is malignant.

Explain what is meant by a malignant tumour.

[3 marks]

06.3 Smoking can damage the lungs in different ways.

Figure 6 shows alveoli from the lungs of two people.

Figure 6

Person A and person B do the same exercise.

Explain why person B breathes much faster than person A during the exercise.

[4 marks]

Mark scheme

Show the mark scheme Mark scheme for AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy Biology Paper 1 (Higher), 2024: Question 6

Question 6

AO /

Question Answers Extra information Mark

Spec. Ref.

06.1 allow a maximum of 3 marks if AO2

the stages are out of order 4.1.2.2

DNA replicates allow DNA duplicates / doubles 1

or allow genetic material doubles

two copies of each chromosome ignore genetic information

form replicates

do not accept DNA reproduces

one set of chromosomes is allow one set of chromosomes 1

pulled to each end of the cell is moved to each end of the cell

ignore half the chromosomes

are moved to each end of the

cell

nucleus divides allow two (new) nuclei form 1

cytoplasm or cell membrane allow cytokinesis and two 1

divides and two genetically genetically identical cells form

identical cells form

ignore names of phases of

mitosis

if no other mark awarded allow 1

mark for mitosis

AO /

Spec. Ref.

06.2 uncontrolled cell division / 1 AO1

growth 4.2.2.7

invade neighbouring tissues 1

(tumour) cells spread to different allow tumour metastasises 1

parts of the body / tissues in the

blood / lymph

– – –

AO /

Spec. Ref.

06.3 allow the converse if clearly AO2

stated 4.2.2.6

4.2.2.2

(need to breathe faster / deeper) 1 4.4.2.1

to get more oxygen 4.4.2.2

(because) smaller surface area 1

(so) less oxygen in the blood allow (so) less oxygenation of 1

haemoglobin

(so) less (oxygen for) respiration allow (so) anaerobic respiration 1

increases

allow (so) lactic acid is produced

allow (so) an oxygen debt is

created

do not accept energy produced

/ made / created

Total Question 6 11

How to answer it

Cell Division, Cancer and Smoking Damage

What this question tests

This question tests your knowledge of the cell cycle and mitosis, what makes a tumour malignant, and how smoking damages alveoli and reduces gas exchange during exercise. To score well, you need clear biology terms, logical chains of reasoning, and answers linked directly to the diagrams and mark scheme wording.

Question 06.1

Part (a): Describe the cell cycle shown in Figure 5

4 marks

✅ Correct answer

A full-mark answer should include these stages in order:

  • DNA replicates, so there are two copies of each chromosome.
  • One set of chromosomes is pulled to each end of the cell.
  • The nucleus divides, or two new nuclei form.
  • The cytoplasm or cell membrane divides, forming two genetically identical cells.
4 marks = 1 mark for each correct stage.

💡 Key knowledge

  • This is mitosis as part of the cell cycle.
  • The new cells are genetically identical to the original cell.
  • The mark scheme accepts DNA replicates or two copies of each chromosome form .
  • The mark scheme says do not write “DNA reproduces”.
  • Names of mitosis stages are not needed.

🧠 Exam technique

  • Describe the stages you can see in the figure, in sequence.
  • Use simple, precise biological terms: DNA replicates , chromosomes pulled apart , nucleus divides , cell divides .
  • Examiner note: if the stages are out of order, a maximum of 3 marks can be awarded.
  • If you are unsure, writing mitosis may gain 1 mark only if nothing better is given.

❌ Common errors

  • Saying DNA reproduces instead of DNA replicates .
  • Missing the final idea that two genetically identical cells form.
  • Giving stages in the wrong order.
  • Talking vaguely about “the cell splits” without mentioning chromosomes or nucleus.

Model 4-mark answer

First, the DNA replicates so there are two copies of each chromosome. Then one set of chromosomes is pulled to each end of the cell. The nucleus divides to form two nuclei. Finally, the cytoplasm and cell membrane divide, producing two genetically identical cells.

Question 06.2

Part (b): Explain what is meant by a malignant tumour

3 marks

✅ Correct answers

  • It is caused by uncontrolled cell division or uncontrolled growth.
  • The tumour invades neighbouring tissues.
  • Tumour cells can spread to other parts of the body, for example in the blood or lymph.
1 mark for each correct idea.

💡 Key knowledge

  • Malignant tumours are cancerous.
  • They do not stay contained in one place.
  • The spread of cancer cells to other parts of the body is called metastasis.
  • The mark scheme allows wording such as tumour metastasises .

🧠 Exam technique

  • For full marks, include both uncontrolled division and spread.
  • A short definition like “a cancerous tumour” is not enough on its own for 3 marks.
  • Link the ideas in a sequence: uncontrolled growth → invades tissues → spreads around body.

❌ Common errors

  • Describing a benign tumour instead.
  • Only saying “it grows fast” with no mention of invasion or spread.
  • Forgetting that the cells spread in the blood or lymph.

Model 3-mark answer

A malignant tumour is a mass of cells that grows by uncontrolled cell division. It can invade neighbouring tissues. Cells from the tumour can also spread to other parts of the body in the blood or lymph.

Question 06.3

Part (c): Explain why person B breathes much faster than person A during exercise

4 marks

✅ Correct answer points

  • Person B needs to breathe faster or deeper to get more oxygen.
  • This is because the smoker’s alveoli have a smaller surface area.
  • So less oxygen gets into the blood, or there is less oxygenation of haemoglobin.
  • So there is less oxygen available for respiration.
These marks are awarded as a linked explanation. A clear chain scores best.

💡 Key knowledge

  • Healthy alveoli have a large surface area for gas exchange.
  • Smoking damages alveoli, reducing their surface area.
  • Less surface area means less diffusion of oxygen into the blood.
  • During exercise, muscles need more oxygen for aerobic respiration.
  • The mark scheme also allows ideas such as more anaerobic respiration, lactic acid production, or oxygen debt if clearly linked.

🧠 Exam technique

  • This is an explain question, so do not just describe the alveoli drawings.
  • Use a because/so chain: smoking damages alveoli → smaller surface area → less oxygen enters blood → less oxygen for respiration → breathes faster
  • Top answers clearly connect the diagram difference to exercise and respiration.
  • The mark scheme allows the converse if clearly stated, but the safest route is to explain why person B gets less oxygen.

❌ Common errors

  • Saying smoking makes “more energy” without explaining oxygen supply. The mark scheme does not accept “energy produced / made / created” on its own.
  • Only saying person B has “damaged lungs” with no mention of smaller surface area.
  • Forgetting to link to the blood or to respiration.
  • Just stating that person B breathes faster because they smoke, with no biological explanation.

📐 Building the 4-mark explanation step by step

  1. The smoker’s alveoli have a smaller surface area.
  2. So less oxygen diffuses into the blood.
  3. So there is less oxygen for respiration in muscles during exercise.
  4. Therefore person B must breathe faster/deeper to take in more oxygen.

Model 4-mark answer

Person B’s alveoli have a smaller surface area because smoking has damaged them. This means less oxygen diffuses into the blood. So there is less oxygen available for respiration during exercise. Therefore person B has to breathe much faster or deeper to get enough oxygen.

Examiner insight across the whole question

💡 What distinguished stronger answers

  • They used exact mark scheme wording like DNA replicates , uncontrolled cell division , and smaller surface area .
  • They wrote in a logical order, especially for the cell cycle and the smoking explanation.
  • They linked structure to function: damaged alveoli → reduced gas exchange.

🧠 Best strategy in the exam

  • Count the marks and aim for that many separate science points.
  • For describe questions, give stages in order.
  • For explain questions, build a cause-and-effect chain.
  • Use terms from GCSE Biology specification rather than vague everyday language.

❌ Biggest mark-losers

  • Vague wording that is scientifically weak.
  • Missing the word identical in mitosis answers.
  • Not mentioning spread when defining malignant tumours.
  • Talking about “not enough energy” instead of “less oxygen for respiration”.

Quick full-answer checklist

  • 06.1: DNA replicates → chromosomes move to opposite ends → nucleus divides → cytoplasm/cell membrane divides → two genetically identical cells.
  • 06.2: uncontrolled division → invades nearby tissues → spreads in blood/lymph.
  • 06.3: smaller alveolar surface area → less oxygen enters blood → less oxygen for respiration → breathes faster/deeper.
Total for Question 6 = 11 marks

Topics

Biology · B1: Cell Biology · B2: Organisation · B5: Homeostasis and Response · B6: Inheritance, Variation and Evolution · B3: Infection and Response

Question and mark scheme from the AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy examination, Biology Paper 1 (Higher), 2024. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.