AQA GCSE Geography Paper 1, June 2025: Question 2
25 marks · Hard difficulty · Extended Response
Assess knowledge and understanding of tropical rainforests, compare climate graphs of hot desert and cold environments, and evaluate either the causes of desertification or the challenges of developing cold environments.
Practise this questionQuestion
Mark scheme
Show the mark scheme
Section B
Total
Qu Pt Marking guidance
marks
02 1 Using Figure 5, name the second largest area of tropical rainforest. 1
Congo
Accept Central Africa
AO4 – 1 mark
02 2 Using Figure 5, what percentage of the total area of tropical rainforest 1
was found in the Amazon in 2020? Give your answer to one decimal
place.
54.3 (%)
AO4 – 1 mark
02 3 Using Figure 6 and your own knowledge, outline two ways that plants in 2
the tropical rainforest are adapted to their environment.
The trees have buttress/long/thick/surface roots (which help to keep the trees
stable) (1).
Roots grow only for short distances below the ground/shallow (to tap nutrients
from the thin topsoil) (1).
The trees grow tall (to reach the sunlight) (1).
The trees have large/broad leaves (to maximise photosynthesis)
Lianas or vines wind around the trunks of trees (to reach the forest canopy) (1).
Trees usually have thin and smooth bark (as there is no need to conserve
moisture) (1).
Leaves usually have pointed drip tips (to allow excess rainwater to run-
off/prevent fungal growth) (1).
Many rainforest plants have thick, waxy coatings (to reduce water loss/ repel
excessive moisture) (1).
Epiphytes grow on larger trees rather than in the soil (so they access sunlight
and absorb moisture from the air) (1)
Credit other valid answers.
Note that answers may use the photograph and/or own knowledge.
Simply stating the unbracketed adaptation is sufficient.
1 mark for each correct answer. – – 8035/1 –
AO3 – 2 marks
02 4 Give one way rainforest vegetation can support large numbers of 1
animals.
The wide range of plant species supports many different animals, birds and
insects (1).
The canopy offers many sources of food, (shelter, and hiding places) (1).
There are habitats found in the different layers of the forest (1)
There is a vast amount of fruit, seeds, leaves, and nectar (1)
Predators (like jaguars, snakes, and birds of prey) thrive due to the large
18 number of prey species.(1)
Thick/dense vegetation provides (camouflage and) protection from
predators.(1)
Trees release moisture, helping to maintain humidity and water availability (for
amphibians and insects).(1)
Do not accept vague points eg ‘vegetation provides food’. ‘vegetation provides
a habitat’, ‘vegetation provides protection’
There should be an (inferred) link to rainforest vegetation eg large leaves
providing shelter
Credit other valid answers.
AO2 – 1 mark
02 5 Give one way climate affects the soils in tropical rainforests. 1
(Heavy) rain causes leaching/washing out of nutrients (1).
(Heavy) rain leads to infertile soils (1)
Heat of the sun causes laterite layer/hard pan to form (1).
High temperatures and moisture allow bacteria to quickly decompose leaf litter
(1).
(Heavy) rain means that rainforest soils tend to be (permanently) moist or
saturated (1).
Chemical weathering of rock in the equatorial forests is rapid, producing deep
soils (1).
(Heavy) rain (on exposed soils) causes soil erosion (1).
Credit other valid answers.
No credit for simply stating that the soil is infertile/eroded, unless linked directly
or indirectly to climate. – – 8035/1 –
AO1 – 1 mark
02 6 ‘Tropical rainforests are of value to people and the environment.’ 6
Discuss this statement.
Use Figure 7 and your own understanding.
Level Marks Description
3 5–6 AO2 – Shows thorough geographical understanding
(Detailed) of the value of tropical rainforests to people and the
environment.
AO3 – Demonstrates thorough application of
knowledge and understanding in assessing the
importance of tropical rainforests to people and the 19
environment.
2 3–4 AO2 – Shows reasonable geographical
(Clear) understanding of the value of tropical rainforests to
people and/or the environment.
AO3 – Demonstrates reasonable application of
knowledge and understanding in assessing the
importance of tropical rainforests to people and/or
the environment.
1 1–2 AO2 – Shows limited geographical understanding of
(Basic) the value of tropical rainforests to people and/or the
environment.
AO3 – Demonstrates limited application of
knowledge and understanding in assessing the
importance of tropical rainforests to people and/or
the environment.
0 No relevant content
• Level 3 (detailed) responses will be developed with accurate use of
geographical terms. Reasoned discussion of the importance of tropical
rainforests to both people and the environment, although coverage may not
be balanced. Makes effective use of Figure 7.
• Level 2 (clear) responses will have linked or elaborated statements and
some accurate use of geographical terms. Likely to outline the value of
tropical rainforests to people and/or the environment. Makes some use of
Figure 7.
• Level 1 (basic) responses are likely to consist of simple statements, with
limited use of subject vocabulary. Might be limited to generic statements
and basic ideas about the value of rainforests. May depend largely on
Figure 7 with limited development.
• Max marks can be awarded for discussion of one environmental and one
people based element
Indicative content
• Students are likely to consider a range of reasons why rainforests are of
value to people and the environment.
• They regulate the composition of the atmosphere, taking in carbon dioxide––8035/1–
through photosynthesis and releasing oxygen, regulating levels of carbon
dioxide in the atmosphere.
20 • The tree roots increase infiltration, allowing increased amounts of water to
percolate to groundwater stores and develop aquifers.
• They minimise soil erosion. The roots anchor the soil while the dense
canopy protects the soil from heavy rains.
• They provide ideal habitats for animals.
• They have very high biodiversity levels. Tropical forests cover just 6% of the
planet’s land surface but contain about 50% of the world’s terrestrial plant
and animal species.
• Tropical rainforests provide many goods and services such as:
o Food – rainforests can produce food, such as nuts, which forms part of the
diet of local people in the Amazon. Rainforests also produce cash crops.
o Raw materials – eg Palm oil is used in cosmetics, confectionary,
detergents and many other products.
• Application of understanding to Figure 7. Rainforests have been used to
search for medicines. For example, the rosy periwinkle can help treat
childhood leukaemia.
• Ecotourism aims to give jobs to local people whilst protecting the
environment. Ecotourists travel in small groups and often visit reserves
where the scenery and wildlife is protected and managed.
• Rainforests are home to many groups of people. Unfortunately,
deforestation has often affected their existence. Amerindians are left without
homes and many have been killed, either deliberately or by diseases
introduced by people coming to the rainforest.
• Rainforests sequester around twice as much carbon dioxide as they emit,
making them an important carbon sink, although this is under threat.
• They influence the hydrological cycle, acting as a water store by intercepting
rainfall. They release water into the atmosphere by evapotranspiration. This
then falls again as precipitation and so gives the people living in areas such
as the Amazon a constant supply of water.
• Rainforests can be logged to produce timber such as hardwoods for garden
furniture exports.
• There may be discussion of how the value of rainforests to people may be in
conflict with the protection of the environment. However, value to people
usually coincides with protection of the environment, eg without rainforests
continually recycling huge quantities of water, feeding the rivers, lakes and
irrigation systems, droughts would become more common, potentially
leading to widespread famine and disease.
• Credit reference to case studies, although these are not necessary to reach
Level 3.
– – 8035/1 –
AO2 – 3 marks
AO3 – 3 marks
02 7 Using Figure 8b, which month has the highest precipitation in Aklavik? 1
August
AO4 – 1 mark
02 8 Using Figures 8a and 8b, which one of the following statements is 1
correct?
D Total precipitation is higher in Aklavik than in Cairo.
AO4 – 1 mark
02 9 Suggest one reason for the difference in temperature between Cairo and 2
Aklavik.
1×2
Difference or comparison is required.
Aklavik receives less direct sunlight than Cairo (1).
Cairo has more solar radiation/insolation/intense heating/sunlight (1)
Cairo is closer to the Equator (1) so the sun’s rays are more concentrated
(d)(1).
Cairo is near the tropics, (whereas) Aklavik is near Polar/Arctic areas (1)
Aklavik is closer to the north pole (1) so sunlight is more dispersed (d)(1).
Ice and snow reflect more sunlight (rather than absorbing it in Aklavik (1),
which keeps temperatures lower (d) (1).
Cold polar winds reduce temperatures in Aklavik (1) compared to warm
(subtropical) air masses in Cairo (d)(1).
Aklavik has very few/no hours of daylight in winter (1) whereas Cairo has
similar amounts all year round (d)(1)
Cairo is 30 degrees N of the Equator, (whereas) Aklavik is 68 degrees N of the
Equator(1)
Do not credit idea that Akjlavik is further from the sun.
Do not credit ‘more’ sunshine or ‘more’ heat or ‘more’ daylight at Cairo.
Only credit one reason – – 8035/1 –
AO2 – 2 marks
02 10 Either (hot deserts) 9
To what extent does human activity contribute to desertification in areas
on the fringes of hot deserts?
Use Figure 9 and your own understanding.
Level Marks Description
3 7–9 AO1 – Demonstrates detailed knowledge of threats
(Detailed) from human activities in environments on the fringe
of hot deserts.
AO2 – Shows thorough geographical understanding
of the interrelationships between places,
environments and processes in the context of
environments on the fringe of hot deserts.
AO3 – Demonstrates application of knowledge and
understanding in a coherent and reasoned way in
evaluating the extent to which human activity poses
a risk to environments on the fringe of hot deserts.
2 4–6 AO1 – Demonstrates clear knowledge of threats
(Clear) from human activities in environments on the fringe
of hot deserts.
AO2 – Shows reasonable geographical
understanding of the interrelationships between
places, environments and processes in the context
of environments on the fringe of hot deserts.
AO3 – Demonstrates reasonable application of
knowledge and understanding in evaluating the
extent to which human activity poses a risk to
environments on the fringe of hot deserts.
1 1–3 AO1 – Demonstrates limited knowledge of threats
(Basic) from human activities in environments on the fringe
of hot deserts.
AO2 – Shows basic geographical understanding of
the interrelationships between places, environments
and processes in the context of environments on the
fringe of hot deserts.
AO3 – Demonstrates limited application of
knowledge and understanding in evaluating the
extent to which human activity poses a risk to
environments on the fringe of hot deserts.
0 No relevant content.
• Level 3 (detailed) responses will be well developed. Reasoned––8035/1 –
examination of a range of causes of desertification with some evaluation of
extent to which human activity is responsible. May acknowledge natural
causes (e.g., climate change, drought) alongside human factors. Makes 23
thorough use of Figure 9 as well as own understanding.
• Level 2 (clear) responses will have linked or elaborated statements and
some accurate use of geographical terms. May outline several causes of
desertification. May start to make an evaluation of the extent to which
human activity is responsible. Uses Figure 9 and/or own understanding.
• Level 1 (basic) responses are likely to consist of simple statements, with
limited use of subject vocabulary. Might be limited to generic statements, or
a list of risks to the environment without development. May be limited to a
single cause of desertification. May make a limited evaluation. Answer may
be largely reliant on Figure 9.
Max Level 2 for no (direct or inferred) reference to Figure 9
Indicative content
• The command ‘to what extent’ means that responses may state the degree
to which human activity causes desertification, with some support for the
view expressed. Eg the statement may be completely untrue, true to some
extent (partly but not completely true), to a great extent, or completely true.
• Knowledge of areas affected by the process. 20% of the world’s population,
in over 60 countries, have to cope with the threat of desertification. For
instance, the Sahara has advanced over 250 km southwards in the past 100
years.
• Understanding of how desertification occurs – the process of fertile land
changing into desert typically as a result of deforestation, drought, or
improper/inappropriate agriculture.
Causes which link to human activity include:
• Population growth – more people needing more food which puts pressure on
the land.
• Migration – leads to greater population pressure. Drought and desertification
in one region will displace people to another fragile environment.
• Overcultivation – growing too much without allowing the soil to recover
means it becomes exhausted.
• Deforestation – trees are cut down for fuel and building. The loss of roots
makes the soils more fragile. They are exposed to wind and the rain,
leading to gully erosion.
• War – many sub-Saharan countries have suffered for years from civil war,
where crops and animals have been destroyed, leading to famine. Millions
of people have been forced to move into desert fringe areas by armed
conflicts. Some become refugees. The resources in and around the cities
and camps where these people settle come under severe pressure.
• Enhanced greenhouse effect, partially caused by human activity globally,
may contribute to increased risks of drought and higher temperatures in
areas on fringe of hot deserts.
• Mining operations often involve clearing large areas of vegetation, disturbing
the soil, and generating waste, which can lead to habitat loss and soil
degradation
• Other threats include extraction of fossil fuels and high impact tourism in––8035/1–
vulnerable areas such as the edge of the Thar desert and in East Africa.
• Application of understanding to Figure 9.
• Figure 9a shows a dry parched surface with little or no grazing land.
24 Overgrazing – too many goats, sheep, cattle can destroy the vegetation.
Nomadic groups are now restricted in movement and this places more
pressure on land resources. The soil may turn to dust and become infertile.
• Figure 9b shows the effects of gully erosion, where the soils are stripped of
vegetation and are washed away in occasional heavy storms. The land is
left infertile. This may be caused by deforestation or over-cultivation.
• Figure 9c illustrates the problem of removing vegetation for use as firewood.
As the population in desert areas increases, there is a greater need for fuel
wood. When the land is cleared of trees, the roots of the trees no longer
hold the soil together so it is more vulnerable to soil erosion.
• Understanding of natural factors leading to desertification. Less rainfall,
higher temperatures which lead to increased evaporation/drought, or rainfall
becoming more irregular, which means that vegetation dies and soils dry out
and are removed by soil erosion. Climate is changing; this is part of a
natural cycle of climate change as ocean currents and patterns of winds
change. Human and physical factors may be linked.
• Credit idea that human activity may have positive impacts on/reduce rates of
desertification eg through replanting and other management schemes.
Human intervention can take place in careful ways that do not contribute to
desertification
• Credit examples of desertification, eg in Kenya, nomadic Masai farmers have
been forced onto marginal land. Traditional migration patterns have been
affected and they have been forced to use smaller areas of land for their
cattle. Overgrazing has resulted from this, leading to soil erosion by wind
and water.
• Evaluation of extent to which human activities pose a risk. Eg although
climate change, as part of a natural cycle, may contribute to desertification,
there is little doubt that human misuse of the land poses a major threat.
Desertification is a huge environmental problem affecting many countries on
the edge of hot deserts, which to a great extent is driven by human factors.
Credit the counter-argument that human activity doesn’t contribute to
desertification because of good management and irrigation, and may help to
reverse/limit the process through strategies such as the Green Wall.
AO1 – 3 marks
AO2 – 3 marks – – 8035/1 –
AO3 – 3 marks
Or (cold environments)
To what extent does the physical environment create challenges for
development in cold environments?
Use Figure 10 and your own understanding.
Level Marks Description
3 7–9 AO1 – Demonstrates detailed knowledge of
(Detailed) challenges to development in a cold environment.
AO2 – Shows thorough geographical understanding 25
of the challenges of a cold environment.
AO3 – Demonstrates thorough application of
knowledge and understanding in discussing the
challenges to development in a cold environment,
using source.
2 4–6 AO1 – Demonstrates clear knowledge of challenges
(Clear) to development in a cold environment.
AO2 – Shows reasonable geographical
understanding of the challenges of a cold
environment.
AO3 – Demonstrates reasonable application of
knowledge and understanding in discussing the
challenges to development in a cold environment,
using source.
1 1–3 AO1 – Demonstrates limited knowledge of
(Basic) challenges to development in a cold environment.
AO2 – Shows limited geographical understanding of
the challenges of a cold environment.
AO3 – Demonstrates basic application of knowledge
and understanding in discussing the challenges to
development in a cold environment, using source.
0 No relevant content
• Level 3 (detailed) responses will be well developed with accurate use of
geographical terms. Reasoned discussion of how far development is
challenged by the physical environment, or whether challenges can be
managed with evidence from Figure 10.
• Level 2 (clear) responses will have linked or elaborated statements and
some use of geographical terms. May outline some challenges to
development in a cold environment. Uses Figure 10 and/or own
understanding.
• Level 1 (basic) responses are likely to consist of simple statements, with
limited use of subject vocabulary. Might be limited to generic statements.
May be limited to a single challenge in a cold environment. Answer may be––8035/1–
largely reliant on Figure 10.
An answer that lacks (direct or inferred) reference to Figure 10 is limited to
26 Level 2.
Indicative content
• The command ‘to what extent’ means that responses may state the degree
to which developed is affected by a range of challenges, with some support
for the view expressed. Eg the statement may be completely untrue, true to
some extent (partly but not completely true), to a great extent, or completely
true.
• The question requires discussion of ways in which a cold environment poses
challenges for development.
• Answers may focus on specific challenges, scale of development and control
over the inhospitable conditions.
• Challenges include environmental constraints, costs/remoteness, and
conflicts with indigenous populations, extreme low temperatures, low
precipitation, variable daylight hours, permafrost/active layer, fragile
ecosystems, and relief barriers.
• Construction disrupts and melts the permafrost, creating unstable ground.
Exposure to extreme cold can injure and kill, and healthcare may be many
miles away. Restricted employment opportunities are a real problem for
people living in remote areas, and there is a lack of services due to low
population density. Climate change may lead to widespread and rapid
changes which are difficult to adapt to.
• Application of knowledge and understanding to Figure 10. Photograph 10a
shows a snow-covered mountainous environment. The area appears to be
remote and inaccessible, with no sign of communications.
• Photograph 10b shows the use of a pipeline to transport oil. It is elevated to
prevent the pipes cracking in the ground. Building roads, railways and
pipelines for water and electricity supplies is very difficult on frozen ground
that is liable to melting. Despite the challenges of a cold environment, the
large-scale drilling for oil may be worthwhile as it produces a good financial
return.
• Photograph 10c shows a road that has been affected by ice heave or
subsidence due to melting of frozen ground. Melting of permafrost, moving
soil layer can make buildings sink and subside, roads crack and even make
trees topple and fall. Roads are constructed of gravel, and houses are often
built on stilts to reduce the risk of subsidence.
• Credit answers that focus on Arctic or Antarctic regions. Allow reference to
tundra as well as polar areas.
• Support for answers may be based on Northern Canada and/or Alaska,
although a case study is not essential. Challenges to development include
getting access to resources, finding a workforce to exploit them, and
providing protection from the extreme weather. Providing buildings and
infrastructure that can cope with the ground and weather conditions is
difficult and expensive. The value of some resources means that people find
ways to overcome the challenges, eg some parts of the Trans-Alaska oil
pipeline are raised on stilts, to prevent it melting the permafrost, which would
make the ground unstable.
• Discussion may consider relationships between the nature of the challenges
and the desire/ability to overcome them in order for development to take
place. This might reflect, for example, the value of resources and the––8035/1 –
technological advances enabling their exploitation.
AO1 – 3 marks 27
AO2 – 3 marks
AO3 – 3 marks
How to answer it
Living with the Physical Environment: Tropical Rainforests & Extreme Environments
This paper tests core knowledge and graphical skills across tropical rainforests and extreme environments (hot deserts and cold environments):
- Distribution & Maths Skills: Global rainforest distribution, percentage calculations to one decimal place, and climate graph analysis.
- Plant & Soil Adaptations: Interdependence of climate, vegetation, and nutrient-poor tropical soils (leaching).
- Value of Ecosystems (6-marker): Evaluating environmental services vs economic benefits to human populations.
- Physical Processes: Solar insolation differences linked to latitude and climate variation.
- Evaluative Essay (9-marker): Weighing human activity vs natural physical factors in desertification OR environmental challenges to development in cold environments.
Rainforest Distribution & Percentage Calculation
✅ Question 02.1 Correct Answer
Congo (or Central Africa)
📐 Question 02.2 Calculation Steps
- Identify total global rainforest area: 958 million hectares .
- Identify Amazon area from Figure 5: 520 million hectares .
- Calculate percentage: (520 ÷ 958) × 100 = 54.2797...%
- Round to one decimal place: 54.3%
❌ Common Errors
- 02.1: Writing "Africa" alone. Africa is a continent, not the specific named rainforest region (Congo Basin).
- 02.2: Failing to round to one decimal place (e.g., writing 54% or 54.28%). Always check the requested precision in the question.
Ecosystem Adaptations & Soil Interactions
💡 02.3: Plant Adaptations (2 Marks)
Any two from the photograph (Figure 6) or own knowledge:
- Buttress roots: Large, wide ridge roots that stabilize tall trees in thin topsoil and capture nutrients near the surface.
- Drip tips: Leaves with pointed downward tips allow heavy rainwater to run off quickly, preventing fungal growth and leaf damage.
- Lianas: Woody climbing vines that root in the ground and wind around tree trunks to reach canopy sunlight.
- Thin, smooth bark: Allows water to run off easily since trees do not need thick bark to protect against cold.
✅ 02.4: Supporting Animals (1 Mark)
Give one linked way:
- Provides a vast variety of food sources all year round (e.g. fruits, nuts, nectar, leaves).
- Complex vertical layers (strata) create distinct ecological niches and breeding habitats.
- Dense canopy foliage provides camouflage and protection from predators.
✅ 02.5: Climate & Soil Interaction (1 Mark)
Give one effect:
- Leaching: Torrential daily rainfall washes soluble nutrients downwards through the soil, leaving it infertile and acidic.
- Rapid decomposition: High temperatures and moisture accelerate bacteria breaking down leaf litter, creating a thin, rich humus layer.
❌ Examiner Pitfalls (02.4 & 02.5)
- Vague answers: Simply writing "provides food" or "shelter" scores 0 marks in 02.4. You must explain why/how vegetation does this (e.g., "layers of trees provide varied nesting habitats").
- Missing the climate link: Stating "soil is infertile" without linking it to heavy rainfall causing leaching scores 0 in 02.5.
'Tropical rainforests are of value to people and the environment.' Discuss.
🧠 Exam Technique: Structuring a 6-Mark "Discuss" Question
To reach Level 3 (5–6 marks), you must provide a balanced argument discussing the value to BOTH people AND the environment, integrating prompts from Figure 7 with your own specific knowledge.
💡 Value to People
- Medicine: Over 25% of modern medicines originate from rainforest plants (e.g., rosy periwinkle used for leukaemia treatment; quinine for malaria).
- Resources & Trade: Hardwoods (teak, mahogany) provide timber; crops like cocoa, rubber, and palm oil support local and national economies.
- Indigenous Survival: Provides food, shelter, and cultural homelands for isolated tribes (e.g., Yanomami) living sustainably.
- Ecotourism: Generates non-destructive jobs, guides, and foreign currency for developing nations.
💡 Value to the Environment
- Carbon Sink: Rainforests absorb huge volumes of CO₂ via photosynthesis, storing carbon and regulating global atmospheric temperatures.
- Water Cycle: Transpiration generates vast clouds (flying rivers); intercepting torrential rain reduces flash flooding and prevents soil erosion.
- Biodiversity: Hosts over 50% of the world’s terrestrial plant and animal species, maintaining vital global gene pools.
✅ Model Paragraph Transition (Level 3 Standard)
"While the rainforest is of immediate economic value to people through hardwood timber extraction and commercial ingredients for life-saving pharmaceuticals (such as the rosy periwinkle), its environmental value is fundamentally more critical. As a global carbon sink, it sequesters billions of tonnes of carbon, directly mitigating climate change. Therefore, destroying it for short-term economic gain undermines the global climatic systems upon which all humans depend."
❌ Common Errors
- One-sided answers: Writing solely about indigenous people or logging, completely ignoring environmental benefits like carbon storage or the water cycle (capped at Level 2).
- Figure copying: Listing items directly from Figure 7 without elaborating with own knowledge or real-world examples.
Climate Comparisons: Cairo vs Aklavik
✅ 02.7: Month with Highest Precipitation (Aklavik)
August (bar reaches approx. 42 mm)
✅ 02.8: Multiple Choice
D: Total precipitation is higher in Aklavik than in Cairo.
(Cairo's bars sum to under 25 mm/year, while Aklavik exceeds 200 mm/year).
💡 02.9: Reason for Temperature Difference (2 Marks)
Point (1 mark): Cairo is located at a lower latitude (30°N) closer to the Equator than Aklavik (68°N, near the Arctic Circle).
Explanation (1 mark): Because Cairo is closer to the Equator, the sun's rays hit the Earth at a higher/more direct angle. The incoming solar radiation is concentrated over a smaller surface area with less atmospheric scattering, resulting in much higher average temperatures than in Aklavik, where rays hit at an oblique angle and are dispersed.
❌ Common Errors in 02.9
- Vague proximity answers: Writing "Cairo is closer to the sun" (scientifically false).
- Incomplete comparisons: Stating "Aklavik has snow" without linking it to latitude, angle of solar insolation, or albedo effect.
Option A: Desertification OR Option B: Cold Environments
Students must answer EITHER Hot Deserts (Figure 9) OR Cold Environments (Figure 10). Level 3 requires clear evidence from the photos, extended geographical knowledge, and an explicit evaluative conclusion.
Option 1: Desertification in Fringes of Hot Deserts (Figure 9)
Using Figure 9 Evidence
- Figure 9a (Overgrazing): High densities of cattle/goats strip sparse vegetation. Hooves trample and compact topsoil.
- Figure 9b (Soil Erosion): Barren soil left vulnerable; heavy rain carves deep gullies, stripping fertile topsoil.
- Figure 9c (Fuelwood Collection): Women carrying branches; stripping trees/shrubs destroys root networks that bind soil.
Human vs Natural Factors
- Human Causes: Population growth increases demand for food and fuelwood; over-cultivation exhausts soil minerals; sedentarisation of nomadic herders.
- Natural/Climate Causes: Long-term droughts, declining rainfall, climate change causing extreme heat and increased evapotranspiration.
✅ Model Evaluative Conclusion
"In conclusion, while human activities like overgrazing and deforestation trigger the immediate stripping of soil on desert margins (as shown in Figure 9), climate change and prolonged droughts create the underlying baseline vulnerability. Therefore, human activities heavily accelerate and worsen a process fundamentally enabled by harsh physical climates."
Option 2: Challenges for Development in Cold Environments (Figure 10)
Using Figure 10 Evidence
- Figure 10a (Extreme Relief & Snow): Steep, snow-covered mountains isolate settlements, halt construction, and cut off transport links.
- Figure 10b (Permafrost & Engineering): The Trans-Alaska pipeline must be raised on insulated stilts so hot oil does not melt the permafrost.
- Figure 10c (Thermokarst/Frost Heave): Melting permafrost causes ground subsidence and uneven collapse, cracking roads and bucking foundations.
Overcoming Challenges
- Physical Challenges: Sub-zero winter temperatures (-30°C), months of darkness, frozen sea routes, permafrost active layers.
- Human Adaptations: Triple-glazed buildings, utilidors (elevated utility pipes), building on gravel pads, seasonal ice highways for heavy machinery.
✅ Model Evaluative Conclusion
"To conclude, the physical environment creates profound engineering and logistical challenges, particularly permafrost melting and road destruction (Figure 10c). However, modern engineering—such as raised pipeline stilts (Figure 10b)—shows these challenges can be overcome when high economic rewards (like oil and rare earth minerals) justify the extreme investment."
❌ Critical Pitfalls for 9-Mark Essays
- No figure reference: Failing to directly mention or describe the images (Figure 9a/b/c or 10a/b/c) automatically caps your mark at Level 2 (maximum 6 marks).
- Missing evaluation: Simply describing causes or challenges without answering "To what extent?" in a clear concluding judgement prevents you from achieving full marks.
Topics
3.1 Living with the physical environment · 3.4 Geographical skills · 3.1.2 Section B: The living world · 3.4.2 Graphical skills · 3.4.3 Numerical skills
Question and mark scheme from the AQA GCSE Geography examination, Paper 1, June 2025. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.