AQA GCSE Geography Paper 2, June 2025: Question 2

30 marks · Hard difficulty · Extended Response

Answer questions on global development, economic and social measures, rural population change in the UK, and evaluate the impacts of a transnational corporation (TNC) on an LIC or NEE host country.

Practise this question

Question

Question paper section covering Questions 02.1 to 02.10. Figure 7 shows a divided bar chart displaying the share of population with access to clean water across high income, upper-middle income, lower-middle income, and low income countries, requiring the low income bar to be completed. Subsequent questions ask for differences in safe water access, limitations of social measures, and causes of uneven development. Figure 8 is a horizontal bar chart displaying percentage population change by age group in a UK rural area from 2011 to 2021, with questions to complete the bar for ages 15-19, find the range, calculate the mean for age 65+, and discuss social and economic effects using Figure 9 headlines. Finally, Figure 10 provides an extract regarding government investment in water and sanitation in Peru, followed by an evaluative 9-mark essay on the impacts of a TNC on a host LIC or NEE.
Question text

Question 2 The changing economic world

Figure 7 is a graph showing access to clean water in different income groups of

countries in 2020.

02.1 Complete Figure 7 below using the following data for low income countries.

[2 marks]

Share of the population with access to clean water

Limited Unimproved None

17% 18% 6%

Figure 7

Key

None

Unimproved

Limited

Basic

Safe

Share of 60

population

with access

to clean

water (%) 40

High Upper- Lower- Low

income middle 13middle income

income income

02.2 What is the difference in access to safe water supply between high income and

lower-middle income countries?

[1 mark]

… %

(12)

02.3 Outline the limitation(s) of one social measure of development such as access

to clean water.

[2 marks]

02.4 Explain one or more causes of uneven development.

[4 marks]

Extra space …

Figure 8 is a graph showing percentage population change by age group in a

rural area of the UK from 2011 to 2021.

U

02.5 Complete Figure 8 using the following data.

(13) [1 mark]

Percentage

Age group

change

15–19 –24%

Figure 8

Decrease Increase

90+ 26%

85–89 18%

80–84 17%

75–79 14%

70–74 28%

65–69 5%

–2% 60–64

55–59 20%

–6% 50–54

–29% 45–49

–33% 40–44

–9% 35–39

30–34 5%

–4% 25–29

–16% 20–24

15–19

–7% 10–14

5–9 1%

–16% 0–4

–30 –20 –10 015 0 10 20 30

% %

02.6 What is the range between the largest percentage increase and largest percentage

decrease in population shown on Figure 8?

[1 mark]

(14) … %

02.7 Calculate the mean population change in the 65+ age groups shown on Figure 8.

Give your answer to the nearest whole number.

[1 mark]

… %

Study Figure 9, some newspaper headlines about rural areas in the UK.

Figure 9

‘Smallest school in the UK’ to

close as its only student moves Rural shops provide lifeline

away to the mainland. for isolated rural communities.

Government asked to support

rural bus services.

02.8 Suggest how population decline can lead to social and economic changes in the

rural landscape in the UK.

Use Figure 9 and your own knowledge.

[6 marks]

U

(15) …

Extra space …

… 17

(16)

Study Figure 10, an article about development in Peru, a NEE in South America.

Figure 10

The president of Peru

said the government is

always working to

improve citizens’ quality

The photograph showing the ceremonial laying

of life.

of the pipeline cannot be reproduced here due to third-party

He said that money would copyright restrictions.

always be spent on

projects that benefit those The image can be found at

most in need. It is https://andina.pe/ingles/noticia-peru-president-government-

particularly important to works-to-improve-citizens-quality-of-life-747884.aspx

improve sanitation in the

country if they are to

progress.

The president also stated

that much work had

already been done in the poorest regions and he guaranteed money for new projects to

expand the availability of clean water. (April 2019)

02.9 Use Figure 10 to suggest how economic development affects peoples’ quality of life.

[3 marks]

02.1 0 Evaluate the impacts of a transnational corporation (TNC) on a host country.

Use a case study of a LIC/NEE.

[9 marks]

… U

(17) …

(18) …

Extra space …

… 20

… U

(19) …

End of Section B

Mark scheme

Show the mark scheme Mark scheme for Question 2 (parts 02.1 to 02.10). It provides specific numerical answers for graphical and calculation questions: Figure 7 plotting at 75%, 93%, and 100% with shading; difference of 40% for safe water; range of 61%; mean of 18%. It outlines levels of response and indicative content for 02.4 (causes of uneven development, 4 marks), 02.8 (social and economic changes from rural population decline, 6 marks), 02.9 (economic development and quality of life in Peru, 3 marks), and 02.10 (level-marked 9-mark essay evaluating TNC impacts on a host country such as Shell in Nigeria or Unilever in India).

Section B

Total

Qu Pt Marking Guidance

marks

02 1 Complete Figure 7 below using the following data for low income 2

countries.

One mark for both dividing lines correctly drawn.

Second mark for all segments correctly shaded or labelled.

Allow one mark if lines and segments mathematically correct and shaded but in

the wrong order.

Allow 1 mark if 2 segments are correctly plotted and shaded.

AO4 – 2 marks

02 2 What is the difference in access to safe water supply between high 1

income and lower-middle income countries?

One mark for correct answer.

40% – – –

AO4 – 1 mark

02 3 Outline the limitation(s) of one social measure of development such as 2

access to clean water.

One mark for an initial overall comment or single relevant statement, eg

• Death rate can be an unreliable measure (1).

• Number of people per doctor is not always a good measure of quality of life

(1)

• Access to safe water as % might not give a full picture of water supply (1).

Second mark for developing the comment or a separate point related to the

same measure.

• Death rate can be an unreliable measure (1) because it increases in many

advanced economies as their populations age (1).

• Number of people per doctor is not always a good measure of quality of life

(1) There are more doctors in some parts of the country than others (1)

• Access to safe water as % might not give a full picture of water supply (1) as

time may still be spent collecting it / or it may not be stored safely once

collected (d)(1).

Credit any reasonable statement and then subsequent development which

makes a link to a social aspect of people’s lives.

Accept a wide range of indicators, which need not be named.

No credit for GNI as purely economic.

No credit for saying what one indicator doesn’t measure.

AO1 – 2 marks

02 4 Explain one or more causes of uneven development. 4

Level Marks Description

2 3–4 AO1 – shows clear knowledge of factor(s) and the

(Clear) development process.

AO2 – Shows clear understanding of factor(s) and the

link to the development process.

1 1–2 AO1 – shows basic knowledge of factor(s) and the

(Basic) development process.

AO2 – Shows limited understanding of factor(s) and the

link to the development process.

0 No relevant content.

• Level 2 (clear) responses will link geographical knowledge and

understanding to present a reasoned explanation.

• Level 1 (basic) answers will be simplistic, perhaps simply descriptive, with

limited reasoning.

– – –

Indicative content

16 • Development need not be through named places but use of an example is

likely to add clarity. Development may also be found in explanation of

processes of development.

• One factor well developed and explained can achieve full marks.

• It is likely that answers will focus on the negative but it would be legitimate to

offer and answer focussed on positive aspects of development factors for

those countries which have greater levels of economic development and / or

an answer of contrasting fortunes.

• Landlocked countries will struggle to trade goods easily without ports.

Transport costs are higher as goods must travel longer distances over land,

often across several international borders.

• Natural hazards may limit economic growth as infrastructure will be

damaged, limiting industrial output and trade and funds will be needed for

repairing damage rather than new development which would allow progress.

• Climate related diseases and pests. Malaria is a serious health issue in

some tropical areas that affects productivity. It causes frequent illness,

leading to missed work, and financial hardship for communities. Irregular

rainfall will limit water supply, essential for settled farming. This is the least

secure physical and developmental link.

• Trade is dominated by HICs, particularly Europe and the USA, who will

control the process for their benefit, eg through the operation of the WTO.

• HICs and TNCs pay as little as possible for their commodities and raw

materials and LICs are further vulnerable to world market fluctuations.

• Many LICs are trapped in primary product dependency and rely for a large %

of their income on a single primary product, eg Zambia 60% GDP from

copper.

• Processing of raw materials takes place in HICs so LIC/NEEs are unable to

add value to their products, eg Cocoa Ivory Coast vs HIC chocolatiers.

• A legacy of colonialism has held back development in the formerly colonised

countries both in terms of the exploitative relationships established and an

often difficult process of independence such as civil wars.

• Conflict and corrupt government mean money is spent on things other than

development.

Credit any reasonable factor linked to development

Credit comments about uneven development within countries e.g. urban/rural

differences, North-South divide in the UK

– – –

AO1 – 2 marks

AO2 – 2 marks

02 5 Complete Figure 8 using the following data. 1

One mark for correct completion. Bar need not be shaded or labelled.

AO4 – 1 mark

02 6 What is the range between the largest percentage increase and largest 1

percentage decrease in population shown on Figure 8?

One mark for correct answer.

Ignore any minus sign.

61% – – –

AO4 – 1 mark

02 7 Calculate the mean population change in the 65+ age groups shown on 1

Figure 8.

One mark for correct answer.

18%

AO4 – 1 mark

02 8 Suggest how population decline can lead to social and economic 6

changes in the rural landscape in the UK.

Use Figure 9 and your own knowledge.

Level Marks Description

3 5–6 AO2 – Shows detailed understanding of population

(Detailed) decline and the resulting effects in rural areas.

AO3 – Demonstrates thorough application of

knowledge and understanding to offer precise

interpretation of the information provided and the link

with social and economic changes.

2 3–4 AO2 – Shows clear understanding of population

(Clear) decline and the resulting effects in rural areas.

AO3 – Demonstrates some application of knowledge

and understanding to offer clear interpretation of the

information provided and the link with social and / or

economic changes.

1 1–2 AO2 – Shows limited understanding of population

(Basic) decline and the resulting effects in rural areas.

AO3 – Demonstrates limited application of knowledge

and understanding to offer basic interpretation of the

information provided and / or simply asserts the link

with social and / or economic changes.

0 No relevant content.

• Level 3 (detailed) responses will cover the figure and well-developed

geographical understanding and provide a considered interpretation of the

link.

• Level 2 (clear) responses will show reasonable understanding of the link

using interpretation of the figure or more considered explanation of the link

using just their own understanding.

• Level 1 (basic) responses will show simple understanding of the link with

basic use of the figure and / or simple assertion of a connection.

Indicative content

• Figure 9 shows decline in both social infrastructure in the school closure,–––

with the ‘mainland’ indicating a more remote island and also in economic

infrastructure with shop closures.

• Additionally, the use of the term ‘lifeline’ suggests a social aspect to the

provision of rural shops in their service to communities.

• Candidates may make use of Figure 8 in their answer, though that should 19

not be credited as reference to the Figure as it is Figure 9 that is required by

the question.

• An example is not required as development may be shown through

developed geography, but is likely to add clarity.

• Likely examples are: Outer Hebrides (accept Lewis / Harris), South

Lakeland, Mid Wales. Any rural area is acceptable.

Social changes such as:

• Younger people leave in search of opportunities elsewhere, leaving a higher

proportion of older residents, resulting in school closures and a less vibrant /

varied community.

• This may also present issues with social / health care with an ageing

population.

Economic changes such as:

• There is an increasing cost to local / national government to provide services

in these areas as smaller populations reduce economies of scale.

• A reduced / less varied population makes businesses less viable, therefore

having a negative effect on the local economy.

• Max L2 if answer uses Figure 9 or own understanding only.

• Max L2 if social or economic changes only.

– – –

AO2 – 3 marks

AO3 – 3 marks

02 9 Use Figure 10 to suggest how economic development affects peoples’ 3

quality of life.

Figure 10 shows the involvement of the president in improving water supplies

and sanitation in Peru.

Credit any reasonable explanation or development of point, eg

• Economic development increases wages (1) and therefore tax receipts for

the government (1) which can be spent on better sanitation (1).

• Quality of life improves (1) because the government improves infrastructure

(1) which means they may be more likely to succeed (1).

• Better sanitation (1) will reduce disease/ people will be healthier (1) and

more productive at work / happier as a result (1).

• Improved sanitation will reduce infant / maternal mortality (1) which will help

to reduce the need to have children / the birth rate (1) so overall rates of

mental health / nutrition / illness will reduce (1).

• Accept answers which argue negatively i.e. that a lack of development will

decrease quality of life.

1×3, 3×1, or (1+1)+1 – – –

Max 1 mark if no reference can be seen or inferred to Figure 10.

AO3 – 3 marks

02 10 Evaluate the impacts of a transnational corporation (TNC) on a host 9

country.

Use a case study of a LIC/NEE.

Level Marks Description

3 7–9 AO1 – Demonstrates detailed knowledge of the

(Detailed) operations of a TNC in a named LIC/NEE.

AO2 – Shows a thorough understanding of how a TNC

causes different impacts.

AO3 – Demonstrates thorough application of

knowledge and understanding in evaluating the relative

impact of changes caused by a TNC.

2 4–6 AO1 – Demonstrates clear knowledge of the operations

(Clear) of a TNC in a named LIC/NEE.

AO2 – Shows a reasonable understanding of how a

TNC causes different impacts.

AO3 – Demonstrates reasonable application of

knowledge and understanding in evaluating the relative

impact of changes caused by a TNC.

1 1–3 AO1 – Demonstrates basic knowledge of the

(Basic) operations of a TNC in a named LIC/NEE.

AO2 – Shows a limited understanding of how a TNC

causes different impacts.

AO3 – Demonstrates limited application of knowledge

and understanding in evaluating the relative impact of

changes caused by a TNC.

0 No relevant content.

• Level 3 (detailed) responses will provide specific detail of a named TNC

and country with well-reasoned evaluation of the impacts resulting from the

TNCs operation.

• Level 2 (clear) responses will either provide specific detail of a named TNC

and implicit evaluation of the impacts or well-reasoned evaluation of the

impacts for a generic country / TNC.

• Level 1 (basic) responses will give basic link(s) between a TNC and the

impacts that result or merely assert a connection between them.

• Max top L2 if no named country or TNC.

• Max top L2 if HIC country but comments could still apply.

• Max L2 if no evaluative comments.

– – –

Indicative content

• Candidates are likely to have studied a range of TNCs and countries, with

likely textbook examples being Unilever in India and Shell in Nigeria.

• Using the latter as an example:

• Answers could suggest positive impacts such as:

o Direct employment for 65 000 Nigerians and a further 250 000 indirectly.

o 91% of Shell contracts go to Nigerian companies.

o Shell makes significant contributions to Nigeria’s tax coffers and thereby

increases national wealth.

o Credit development of the above to show how they increase security of

employment and thereby disposable income, increase government

revenue to allow funding of infrastructure and social provision, and create

multiplier effects which have wider benefits.

• Answers should also address the need to evaluate and therefore may show

negative impacts such as:

o Oil spills, particularly in the Bodo region, cause conflict and resentment

and ruin fishermen’s livelihoods.

o Oil flaring is still used, increasing greenhouse emissions and air pollution.

o Oil wealth has provoked armed conflict and new terrorist groups such as

the Niger Delta Avengers who cause loss of life and revenue for the

government.

• Answers should be brought to a conclusion, or at least have evaluative

comments in their text, perhaps with an overall judgement of whether the

positives outweigh the negatives or vice versa. Either view is perfectly

acceptable.

• An updated version of a textbook has provided revised figures regarding the

numbers of workers employed by Shell and who work in the oil industry in

Nigeria. Give credit to responses which correctly use figures provided above

or those that suggest Shell provides direct employment for 2700 people and

9000 contractors, of whom 97 per cent are Nigerian.

• Examiners should be aware of updated figures for a range of case studies.

AO1 – 3 marks

AO2 – 3 marks

AO3 – 3 marks

How to answer it

Development, Rural Change & TNCs in LICs/NEEs

AQA GCSE Geography • Paper 2 • Section B Master Guide

📋 What this question tests

This section assesses your core geographical skills and thematic knowledge across The Changing Economic World:

  • Cartographic & Graphical Skills: Completing divided compound bar charts, population change graphs, reading scale values, and calculating statistical range and mean.
  • Development Indicators: Evaluating social measures of development (such as water quality) and explaining physical, historical, and economic causes of global uneven development.
  • UK Rural Landscape Challenges: Linking demographic decline (ageing populations, youth out-migration) to social isolation and service decline using newspaper stimuli.
  • Resource Quality & Evaluation: Assessing quality of life improvements in NEEs and delivering a balanced 9-mark evaluation of a TNC (e.g. Shell in Nigeria).
Question 02.1 • Skills (2 Marks)

Completing a Divided Bar Chart

Data: Low-income countries – Limited: 17%, Unimproved: 18%, None: 6%

✅ Model Answer

The base bars are already plotted up to 59% (Safe = 29%, Basic = 30%):

  • Line 1: Plot a horizontal line at 76% (59 + 17 = 76%). Shade this segment with vertical diagonal lines (Limited).
  • Line 2: Plot a horizontal line at 94% (76 + 18 = 94%). Shade this segment with criss-cross diagonal lines (Unimproved).
  • Top segment (94% to 100%): Represents the remaining 6% (None). Shade with dense grid hatching.

🧠 Exam Technique & Mark Breakdown

  • Mark 1: Both dividing lines accurately plotted at 76% and 94%.
  • Mark 2: All three sections correctly shaded using the precise patterns from the key.
  • Tip: Always add values cumulatively rather than measuring raw block sizes from zero!

❌ Common Errors

Plotting from 0% instead of adding onto 59%, confusing the shading styles between 'Limited' and 'Unimproved', or failing to use a ruler for dividing lines.

Question 02.2 • Skills (1 Mark)

Difference in Access to Safe Water

High income vs Lower-middle income countries

📐 Step-by-Step Calculation

  1. High-income 'Safe' access = 98%
  2. Lower-middle income 'Safe' access = 58%
  3. Calculate the difference: 98% − 58% = 40%

✅ Correct Answer

40%

Award 1 mark for exactly 40%.
Question 02.3 • Application (2 Marks)

Limitations of Social Measures of Development

Outline limitation(s) of one social measure such as access to clean water

✅ Model Answer

Access to clean water:

"Data on access to safe water can hide internal inequalities (1), as piped clean water is often concentrated in wealthy urban neighbourhoods while poor rural areas rely on untreated standpipes (1)."

Alternative (Death Rate):

"Death rate can be misleading as an indicator of development (1) because developed nations like Germany have an older population structure, causing higher natural mortality despite having excellent healthcare (1)."

🧠 How Marks are Awarded

  • 1 mark: Stating an initial limitation or valid critique.
  • 2nd mark: Developing the comment with a clear geographical link explaining why it distorts the true picture of development.

❌ Common Errors

Discussing economic measures like GNI per capita (the question specifically asks for a social measure), or simply saying "the data might be wrong" without explaining why.

Question 02.4 • Explanation (4 Marks)

Causes of Uneven Development

Explain one or more causes of uneven development globally

💡 Key Knowledge Categories

  • Physical: Being landlocked (no direct sea trade ports, higher shipping transit tariffs); extreme climate/tropical diseases (malaria reducing labour productivity); natural hazards destroying infrastructure.
  • Economic: World trade dominated by HICs; reliance on primary commodity exports with fluctuating global prices (e.g. coffee, copper).
  • Historical: Colonial exploitation where wealth was extracted and colonies were left with unstable borders and poor institutional systems.

✅ Model Answer (Level 2 • 4 Marks)

"One major cause of uneven development is being landlocked. Countries without a coastline, such as Chad, must pay high transportation tariffs and cross international borders to export goods. This increases transit costs and delays trade, making their exports uncompetitive on the global market and reducing government tax revenue for infrastructure.

Furthermore, many LICs suffer from an unfavourable trade balance. They primarily export raw agricultural commodities which have low added value and volatile prices, while having to import expensive manufactured goods and machinery from HICs, trapping them in persistent debt."

Level 2 Criteria (3–4 marks): Clear explanation of factors linked explicitly to the process of development (trade, income, investment), using well-reasoned connectives.
Questions 02.5 – 02.7 • Graphical & Maths Skills (3 Marks)

Working with Population Data (Figure 8)

02.5 Complete Figure 8 (1 Mark)

Data to plot: 15–19 age group = −24%

  • Locate the 15–19 age row on the vertical axis.
  • Draw a horizontal bar going left into the 'Decrease' side precisely to the −24% line (two small grid divisions past −20%).
  • Note: The mark scheme states shading/labelling is not strictly required, but the bar length must be exact.

02.6 Range Calculation (1 Mark)

Formula: Highest Value − Lowest Value

  • Largest increase: +28% (70–74 age group)
  • Largest decrease: −33% (40–44 age group)
  • Range = 28 − (−33) = 61%

Answer: 61% (ignore any minus sign)

02.7 Mean of 65+ Age Groups (1 Mark)

Identify all groups 65 and above:

  • 65–69: 5% | 70–74: 28% | 75–79: 14%
  • 80–84: 17% | 85–89: 18% | 90+: 26%

Sum: 5 + 28 + 14 + 17 + 18 + 26 = 108%

Divide by n (6 groups): 108 ÷ 6 = 18%

Answer: 18%

❌ Common Calculation Traps

Range Trap: Subtracting 33 from 28 to get −5%. The range is the span between extremes on a number line, so you must add the absolute distances (28 + 33 = 61).
Mean Trap: Missing out the 65–69 bar or dividing by the wrong number of categories.

Question 02.8 • Extended Application (6 Marks)

Rural Landscape Changes in the UK

Suggest how population decline leads to social AND economic changes

🧠 Exam Requirement Check

  • Must cover both social AND economic changes (Max Level 2 if only one is covered).
  • Must use Figure 9 (school closure, rural shops as lifelines, bus service cuts) AND own knowledge (e.g. Outer Hebrides, rural Wales, South Lakeland).
  • Level 3 (5–6 marks): Balanced, detailed explanation linking cause and effect with clear rural evidence.

💡 Social vs Economic Impacts

Social:

  • Closure of village schools forces long commutes for young families.
  • Isolation and loneliness among older residents when youth out-migrate.
  • Loss of community hubs like pubs and community halls.

Economic:

  • Loss of local threshold population leads to village shop closures.
  • Reduction in council tax revenue makes public transport (buses) unprofitable to subsidise.
  • Downward spiral: lack of jobs and services encourages further outward migration.

✅ Model Answer (Level 3 • 6 Marks)

"As shown in Figure 9, rural depopulation has severe knock-on effects. Socially, the out-migration of young working-age adults leads to school closures, as shown by the 'smallest school in the UK' closing after its sole student moved away. This leaves an ageing population behind, leading to social isolation and reduced community vitality, especially for elderly residents who struggle to interact without local community hubs.

Economically, population decline reduces the threshold population required to keep businesses viable. As local customer numbers dwindle, rural post offices and village shops are forced to shut down. Furthermore, declining fare revenue makes public bus services commercially unviable, forcing councils to cut routes. This creates a spiral of decline: without transport or basic services, remote rural areas become unattractive to new businesses and young workers, entrenching economic stagnation."

Question 02.9 • Interpretation (3 Marks)

Economic Development & Quality of Life in Peru

Use Figure 10 to suggest how economic development affects quality of life

✅ Model Answer (Full 3 Marks)

"Figure 10 indicates that economic growth generates government revenue, which the president has pledged to invest in clean water pipelines and sanitation for the poorest regions (1).

Access to clean, piped water directly reduces waterborne diseases like cholera, significantly improving public health and cutting infant mortality rates (1).

With better health, children can attend school consistently and adults miss fewer workdays through illness, increasing family incomes and overall well-being (1)."

🧠 Mark Scheme Rule

  • Max 1 mark if no direct reference can be seen or inferred from Figure 10 (e.g. government funding, poorest regions, clean water/sanitation pipeline).
  • Can be awarded as 1 × 3 marks, 3 × 1 mark, or (1 + 1) + 1 for linked, progressive development points.
Question 02.10 • Case Study Evaluation (9 Marks)

Evaluating the Impacts of a TNC on a Host Country

Use a case study of an LIC or NEE (e.g. Shell in Nigeria)

💡 Case Study Facts: Shell in the Niger Delta, Nigeria

Positive Impacts:

  • Employs 6,000+ workers directly (90%+ Nigerian) and creates 250,000+ indirect supply chain jobs.
  • Contributes substantial tax revenues and export royalties to the Nigerian government (historically up to 50–70% of government revenue).
  • Shell Foundation funds clinics, micro-loans, and secondary school scholarships.

Negative Impacts:

  • Frequent oil spills (e.g. Bodo community) contaminate freshwater creeks, destroying fishing grounds and farmland.
  • Gas flaring releases toxic fumes, sulfur dioxide (acid rain), and greenhouse gases.
  • Profits are repatriated to corporate headquarters abroad rather than reinvested locally.
  • Social conflict and militant sabotage (e.g. Niger Delta Avengers).

🧠 Marking Criteria Breakdown

  • Level 3 (7–9 marks): Detailed, accurate case study knowledge (AO1), detailed explanation of positive and negative effects (AO2), and a justified, well-balanced evaluation/judgment (AO3).
  • Cap Rules:
    • Max Top Level 2 (6 marks) if no named country or TNC is used.
    • Max Top Level 2 (6 marks) if an HIC is used.
    • Max Level 2 (6 marks) if there are no evaluative comments or conclusion.

✅ Model Answer (Level 3 • 9/9 Marks)

"Transnational corporations (TNCs) bring substantial economic development to host NEEs, but often at a steep environmental and social cost, as demonstrated by Shell in the Niger Delta, Nigeria.

On one hand, Shell generates vital economic growth. The company directly employs thousands of Nigerians and awards over 90% of its servicing contracts to local companies, generating positive multiplier effects across the economy. Furthermore, oil export taxes and royalties provide billions of dollars to the Nigerian government, funding major road schemes, hospitals, and national infrastructure. Shell has also invested in community projects, such as building medical clinics and funding school scholarships in the Delta.

Conversely, the environmental degradation caused by Shell has severely harmed host communities. Decades of oil leaks and pipeline bursts, such as the catastrophic Bodo oil spills, have polluted drinking water and devastated mangrove ecosystems, destroying the traditional livelihoods of local farmers and fishermen. In addition, routine gas flaring produces air pollution and acid rain, leading to respiratory illnesses. Much of the generated profit is also repatriated back to corporate shareholders abroad rather than remaining within local communities, fuelling civil tension and militancy.

In conclusion, while Shell has been an indispensable catalyst for Nigeria's macro-economic growth and government revenue, at a local scale within the Niger Delta the impacts have been overwhelmingly negative due to environmental degradation and livelihood loss. The relationship will only be truly beneficial when the government strictly regulates corporate environmental standards."

Topics

3.2 Challenges in the human environment · 3.4 Geographical skills · 3.2.2 Section B: The changing economic world · 3.4.2 Graphical skills · 3.4.3 Numerical skills · 3.4.4 Statistical skills

Question and mark scheme from the AQA GCSE Geography examination, Paper 2, June 2025. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.