Edexcel A-Level Chemistry AS Paper 2, June 2024: Question 3
17 marks · Medium difficulty · Open Response
Deduce formulae, mechanism, stereoisomerism, and hydration reactions for the isomeric alkenes but-1-ene, but-2-ene, and methylpropene.
Practise this questionQuestion
Question text
3 But‑1‑ene, but‑2‑ene and methylpropene are three isomeric alkenes.
Name Structural formula
but‑1‑ene CH3CH2CH CH2
but‑2‑ene CH3CH CHCH3
methylpropene (CH3)2C CH2
(a) Give the molecular formula and empirical formula of but‑1‑ene.
(1)
Molecular formula
Empirical formula
(b) The major product of the reaction between methylpropene and
hydrogen bromide is 2‑bromo‑2‑methylpropane.
(i) What is the name and type of the mechanism of this reaction?
(1)
A electrophilic addition
B nucleophilic addition
C electrophilic substitution
D nucleophilic substitution
(ii) Draw the mechanism for the formation of 2‑bromo‑2‑methylpropane.
Include curly arrows, and any relevant charges, dipoles and lone pairs.
(4)
*P76894A0832*
(iii) A minor organic product is also formed in this reaction.
Justify why this minor product is formed in smaller amounts.
Include the structure of the minor organic product.
(3)
(iv) State what a curly arrow represents in your diagram of the mechanism
in (b)(ii).
(1)
(c) But‑2‑ene exists as two stereoisomers. 9
(i) Give the displayed formula and name of each of these isomers.*P76894A0932*
(2)
Isomer 1 Isomer 2
Name … Name …
(ii) Explain how the presence of the double bond in but‑2‑ene results in these
two isomers.
(2)
(d) One of the three alkenes can be hydrated to form a tertiary alcohol.
Name Structural formula
but‑1‑ene CH3CH2CH CH2
but‑2‑ene CH3CH CHCH3
methylpropene (CH3)2C CH2
(i) Which is the skeletal structure of this alcohol?
(1)
A B
HO *P76894A01032*HO
C D
HO
HO
(ii) Explain why tertiary alcohols resist oxidation, but primary or secondary
alcohols are readily oxidised.
(2)
(Total for Question 3 = 17 marks)
Mark scheme
Show the mark scheme
Question
Answer Additional Guidance Mark
Number
3(a) An answer that makes reference to the following points: (1)
• molecular formula, C4H8 Do not award CH2 for the molecular formula
and
empirical formula, CH2 Allow a calculation involved C4H8
eg C4H8 ÷ 4 = CH2 as long as CH2 given
Question
Answer Mark
Number
3(b)(i) The only correct answer is A (electrophilic addition) (1)
B is not correct because the reaction involves electrophilic not nucleophilic attack
C is not correct because the reaction is an addition not a substitution
D is not correct because the reaction is an addition reaction resulting from electrophilic attack
Question
Answer Additional Guidance Mark
Number
3(b)(ii) An answer that makes reference to the following points: (4)
All marking points scores 4 marks
7 or 8 marking points scores 3 marks
5 or 6 marking points scores 2 marks
3 or 4 marking points scores 1 mark
+
• correct structure for 2-methylpropene :Br ‒
‒
• dipole on HBr molecule
• curly arrow from H‒Br bond to Br
• curly arrow from double bond to H atom of HBr / to
the space between the double bond and the H atom
of HBr
• correct carbocation intermediate to form 2-bromo-2- Allow TE on an incorrect starting alkene structure
methyl propane with + charge on correct carbon
• charge on bromide ion
• lone pair on bromide ion
• curly arrow from Br to correct carbon / to the space
Allow to the positive carbon of a carbocation even if
between the Br and correct carbon
incorrect
This can be awarded if no lone pair is present on Br, but
must be from the lone pair if a lone pair is present
• structure of product correct from either starting
material or carbocation or 2-bromo-2-methylpropane
Question
Answer Additional Guidance Mark
Number
3(b)(iii) An answer that makes reference to the following points: (3)
• structure of 1-bromo-2-methylpropane (1)
Allow skeletal / condensed / hybrid structures as long as
Either structure is clear
• because it is formed via / the intermediate is a Allow a description of a primary carbocation and/or a
primary carbocation (not tertiary) tertiary carbocation
Or
• the carbocation has only one alkyl group attached Ignore discussions of Markovnikov’s rule without
and is not stabilised by the inductive effect of three explanation in terms of inductive effect or stability of
methyl groups (as in the major product) (1) carbocations
• the minor carbocation is less stable than the major Allow a tertiary carbocation is more likely to form than a
carbocation (1) primary one
Allow a comparison of stability of secondary
carbocations as a TE on M2
Do not award the primary halogenoalkane is less stable
compared to the tertiary
If M2 and M3 are not scored allow (1) for the carbocation
is less stable
Question
Answer Additional Guidance Mark
Number
3(b)(iv) An answer that makes reference to the following point: (1)
• the movement of a pair / two electrons Accept the transfer of a pair / two electrons
Allow movement of a bond pair / lone pair of electrons
Question
Answer Additional Guidance Mark
Number
3(c)(i) An answer that makes reference to the following points: (2)
Isomer 1 Isomer 2
• structure of both isomers correct (1)
• names of both isomers correct (1)
Name: trans-but-2-ene / Name: cis-but-2-ene /
E-but-2-ene Z-but-2-ene
Allow name and structure of one isomer correct for (1)
M2 dependent on M1 or near miss
Allow CH3 for the displayed methyl group
Penalise connectivity of CH3 once only
Question
Answer Additional Guidance Mark
Number
3(c)(ii) An explanation that makes reference to the following points: (2)
• because the C=C double bond has restricted rotation (1) Allow no rotation around C=C
Allow limited rotation around C=C
Allow the double bond in place of C=C
Allow the double / C=C restricts rotation
• and there is a CH3 group / H group on either side of the Allow there are two different groups attached
double bond (1) to each carbon (of the C=C double bond)
Allow priority groups being on the same or
different sides
Question
Answer Mark
Number
3(d)(i) (1)
The only correct answer is B ( )
A is not correct because this is a secondary alcohol
C is not correct because this is a primary alcohol
D is not correct because this is a primary alcohol
Question
Answer Additional Guidance Mark
Number
3(d)(ii) An explanation that makes reference to the following points: The carbon with the -OH group attached to it need be (2)
mentioned in only one of the two marking points, the
(because oxidation requires a hydrogen to be attached to the second can score just for the numbers of hydrogens
carbon with the -OH group attached to it and)
• tertiay alcohols have no hydrogen on the carbon with Allow because a C-C bond would have to be broken
the -OH group attached to it / on the carbon to be Allow the carbon with the OH group attached is
oxidised (1) bonded to 3 alkyl groups / other carbons
Ignore tertiary alcohols are bonded to three alkyl /
methyl groups
• whereas primary and secondary alcohols do have a Allow reference to tertiary alcohols do not have a
hydrogen on the carbon with the -OH group attached to hydrogen but other alcohols do
it / on the carbon to be oxidised (1)
(Total for Question 3 = 17 marks)
How to answer it
Isomeric Alkenes, Electrophilic Addition & Stereoisomerism
Key concepts and syllabus areas assessed across 17 marks:
- Formulae: Deducing molecular and empirical formulae of alkenes.
- Reaction Mechanisms: Complete 4-mark mechanism for electrophilic addition of HBr to an unsymmetrical alkene (curly arrows, dipoles, charges, carbocation intermediate).
- Carbocation Stability: Explaining major vs minor products using relative carbocation stability (tertiary vs primary) and inductive electron donation.
- Stereoisomerism: Drawing displayed formulae and naming cis/trans (or E/Z) isomers of but-2-ene, and stating the two structural criteria required for geometric isomerism.
- Alcohols & Oxidation: Identifying tertiary alcohols from alkene hydration and explaining oxidation resistance in terms of bonded hydrogen atoms.
Part (a) — Formulae of But-1-ene
Deducing molecular and empirical formulae
1 Mark Total✅ Correct Answer [1 Mark]
- Molecular formula: C₄H₈
- Empirical formula: CH₂
❌ Common Errors
- Writing CH₂ for the molecular formula (confusing molecular with empirical).
- Writing a structural formula like CH₃CH₂CH=CH₂ instead of counting the total atoms for the molecular formula.
Part (b)(i) & (b)(ii) — Electrophilic Addition Mechanism
Mechanism type & detailed 4-mark curly arrow mechanism
1 + 4 Marks✅ Correct Answers
(b)(i) [1 Mark]: Option A (electrophilic addition)
(b)(ii) [4 Marks Marking Points (MP)]:
- 1. Correct structure of methylpropene: (CH₃)₂C=CH₂ .
- 2. Dipole shown correctly on H–Br: H(δ+)–Br(δ-) .
- 3. Curly arrow from C=C double bond to H atom of H–Br.
- 4. Curly arrow from H–Br covalent bond onto the Br atom.
- 5. Correct tertiary carbocation: (CH₃)₃C⁺ with positive charge on central carbon.
- 6. Bromide ion formed with negative charge: :Br⁻ .
- 7. Lone pair of electrons shown on :Br⁻ .
- 8. Curly arrow from lone pair on :Br⁻ to the positive central carbon atom (C⁺).
- 9. Correct final product structure: 2-bromo-2-methylpropane.
🧠 Exam Technique & Diagram Details
Step 1: Draw (CH₃)₂C=CH₂ . Below it, draw H–Br with δ+ above H and δ- above Br.
Arrows: Start an arrow from the centre of the double bond pointing directly at the H(δ+) . Start a second arrow from the middle of the H–Br single bond onto the Br atom.
Step 2: Draw the carbocation intermediate (CH₃)₂C⁺–CH₃ . The positive charge must be explicitly on the central carbon atom.
Step 3: Draw :Br⁻ nearby with two visible dots for the lone pair. Draw a curly arrow originating precisely on the lone pair and ending on the C⁺ atom.
Part (b)(iii) & (b)(iv) — Minor Product & Curly Arrows
Carbocation stability justification and definition of a curly arrow
3 + 1 Marks✅ Correct Answers
(b)(iii) Minor Product Justification [3 Marks]:
- Structure [1 Mark]: 1-bromo-2-methylpropane, (CH₃)₂CHCH₂Br .
- Carbocation Identity [1 Mark]: Formed via a primary carbocation intermediate (or: the carbocation has only one alkyl group attached / fewer electron-releasing methyl groups).
- Stability Comparison [1 Mark]: The primary carbocation is less stable than the tertiary carbocation (which forms the major product).
(b)(iv) Curly Arrow Definition [1 Mark]:
Represents the movement of a pair of electrons (or two electrons).
❌ Common Errors & Examiner Warnings
- Comparing products instead of intermediates: Stating "1-bromo-2-methylpropane is less stable" scores 0 marks. You must state that the carbocation intermediate is less stable!
- Quoting Markovnikov's Rule without theory: Simply citing the rule ("hydrogen adds to the carbon with more hydrogens") is not accepted; you must explain it in terms of carbocation stability or inductive effects.
- Vague curly arrow definitions: Writing "movement of electrons" or "movement of a bond" loses the mark. It must specify a pair or two electrons.
Part (c) — Stereoisomerism in But-2-ene
Displayed structures, E/Z nomenclature, and cause of stereoisomerism
2 + 2 Marks✅ Correct Answers
(c)(i) Structures & Names [2 Marks]:
All bonds must be shown displayed: H–C–H bonds on methyl groups, C–H bonds on the double-bond carbons, and the central C=C. The two –CH₃ groups are on opposite sides.
Fully displayed formula with both –CH₃ groups on the same side of the C=C double bond.
(c)(ii) Explanation [2 Marks]:
- Point 1 [1 Mark]: Restricted rotation around the C=C double bond (due to the presence of the π bond).
- Point 2 [1 Mark]: Each carbon of the C=C bond is attached to two different groups (a –CH₃ group and a –H atom).
💡 Displayed Formula Trap
- A displayed formula requires every single bond to be drawn out. Drawing " CH₃ " in a displayed structure loses the mark unless drawn as:
H
|
H–C–
|
H - Ensure carbon connectivity is correct: bonds from the C=C must clearly attach to the C of the methyl group, not an H atom.
Part (d) — Alkenes to Alcohols & Oxidation
Tertiary alcohol structure & resistance to oxidation
1 + 2 Marks✅ Correct Answers
(d)(i) Skeletal Structure [1 Mark]:
Option B (2-methylpropan-2-ol: a tertiary alcohol where the –OH group is attached to a central carbon with 3 methyl branches).
(d)(ii) Why Tertiary Alcohols Resist Oxidation [2 Marks]:
- Mark 1: Tertiary alcohols have no hydrogen atom attached to the carbon that bears the –OH group (the C–OH carbon).
- Mark 2: Primary and secondary alcohols have at least one hydrogen atom attached to the carbon with the –OH group (primary has 2, secondary has 1).
❌ Common Errors
- Imprecise language: Saying "tertiary alcohols have no hydrogens" is incorrect and gains 0 marks—they have 9 hydrogens! You must specify: no hydrogen atom attached to the carbon carrying the –OH group.
- Focusing on the –OH: Stating "the OH has no hydrogen" is chemically meaningless. The focus must strictly be on the adjacent C atom.
- Alternative accepted reasoning: To oxidise a tertiary alcohol, a strong C–C bond would need to be broken, which requires too much energy under standard conditions.
Topics
Organic Chemistry · Physical Chemistry · Topic 5: Formulae, Equations and Amounts of Substance · Topic 6: Organic Chemistry I
Question and mark scheme from the Edexcel A-Level Chemistry examination, AS Paper 2, June 2024. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.