OCR A-Level Geography Geographical debates (03), June 2025: Question 6

12 marks · Hard difficulty · Extended Response

Examine how the formation of landforms within one landscape system (coastal, glaciated, or dryland) can be modified by climate change.

Practise this question

Question

Question 6: Examine how the formation of landforms within one landscape system you have studied can be modified by climate change (coastal, glaciated or dryland). Marked out of 12.
Question text

6 Examine how the formation of landforms within one landscape system you have studied can be

modified by climate change (coastal, glaciated or dryland). [12]

Mark scheme

Show the mark scheme OCR A-Level Geography mark scheme for question 6 (12 marks: AO1 6 marks, AO2 6 marks). Level descriptors range from Level 1 (1–3 marks) to Level 4 (10–12 marks). Indicative content outlines AO1 knowledge for coastal, glaciated, and dryland landscape systems alongside climate change impacts, and AO2 analysis points detailing how rising or falling temperatures, extreme events, and altered weathering/erosion modify specific landforms.

6 Examine how the formation of landforms within ONE 12 Indicative content

landscape system you have studied can be modified by AO1 AO1 – 6 marks

x6 Knowledge and understanding of formation of

climate change (coastal, glaciated or dryland). AO2

x6 landforms in ONE landscape system and climate

Level 4 (10-12 marks) change could potentially include:

Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding of • Climate change – majority of students likely to

formation of landforms in ONE landscape system and climate change focus on warming climate, credit discussions on

(AO1). influences of colder climate.

• Both negative + positive modifications relevant.

Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and • Increase in surface, atmospheric, and oceanic

understanding to provide clear, developed and convincing analysis temperatures leading to:

that is fully accurate of how formation of landforms in ONE landscape o Unpredictable rainfall patterns affecting

system can be modified by climate change (AO2). rates of weathering, erosion and deposition.

o Slower / more rapid formation depending on

This will be shown by including well-developed ideas about how landform / landscape chosen.

formation of landforms in ONE landscape system and climate change. • Coastal or Glaciated (inc tundra) or Dryland

landscapes.

There are clear and explicit attempts to make appropriate synoptic For each landscape system, formation of

links between content from different parts of the course of study. landforms across a variety of scales occurs e.g.

o Coastal: bays, cliffs, beaches, stacks

Level 3 (7-9 marks) o Glaciated: corries, troughs, moraines, striations

Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of formation o Dryland: wadis, canyons, dunes, ventifacts

of landforms in ONE landscape system and climate change (AO1). AO2 – 6 marks

Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse

Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and understanding how formation of landforms in ONE landscape system

to provide clear and developed analysis that shows accuracy of how can be modified by climate change could potentially

formation of landforms in ONE landscape system can be modified by include:

climate change (AO2). • Coastal landscapes

o ↑ temperatures → ↑ rates of evapotranspiration

This will be shown by including well-developed ideas either formation → ↑ intensity + frequency of storms, ↑ erosion

of landforms in ONE landscape system or climate change and e.g. wave pounding and abrasion → ↑

developed ideas for the other focus. erosional landforms developing e.g. shore

platforms; cliff retreat

There are clear attempts to make synoptic links between the content o As sea levels rise so erosion rates ↑ → ↑

from different parts of the course of study, but these are not always erosion of depositional landforms e.g.

appropriate. beaches; mud flats + salt marshes

o ↑ temperatures → ↑ chemical weathering as

Level 2 (4-6 marks) rates of chemical weathering accelerates. Sea

Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding ofMark Schemeformation water becoming more acidicJune 2025affecting[Type here]

of landforms in ONE landscape system and climate change16 (AO1). carbonate rocks in particular.

o ↓ freeze thaw weathering in some locations as

Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and global temperatures rise → slower

understanding to provide sound analysis that shows some accuracy of development e.g. cliff faces + scree slopes

how formation of landforms in ONE landscape system can be modified o ↑ temperatures →negative impacts on coral

by climate change (AO2). reefs (bleaching episodes)

o Climate change → changes in hydrological

This will be shown by including developed ideas about either cycle → sea level (eustatic) + isostatic

formation of landforms in ONE landscape system or climate change adjustments → landforms of submergence or

and simple ideas for the other focus. emergence

• Glaciated landscapes

There are some attempts to make synoptic links between content from o ↑ temperatures, ↑ ablation, ↓ development

different parts of the course of study, but these are not always relevant. erosional landforms e.g. corries, and ↑

development depositional landforms e.g.

Level 1 (1-3 marks) moraines, drumlins

Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of formation of o ↑ temperatures = ↑ freeze thaw and frost

landforms in ONE landscape system and climate change (AO1). shattering as temperatures rise to around

freezing → ↑ load for glaciers + meltwater → ↑

Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and understanding to erosion but also deposition e.g.

provide simple analysis that shows limited accuracy of how formation fluvioglacial/glaciofluvial.

of landforms in ONE landscape system can be modified by climate o ↑ temperatures → impacts on periglacial

change (AO2). locations e.g. thawing of permafrost; reduction

in intensity of frost heave but ↑ in freeze-thaw

This will be shown by including simple ideas about formation of cycles → active scree formation

landforms in ONE landscape system and climate change. • Dryland landscapes

There are limited attempts to make synoptic links between content o ↑ temperatures → ↑ rates of evapotranspiration

from different parts of the course of study. → ↑ frequency of droughts → ↑ impact wind

erosion e.g. ↑ impact on deflation and desert

0 marks pavements

No response or no response worthy of credit. o Water shortages → ↓ water erosion → slower

development of canyons

o ↑ temperatures, ↑ rates of evapotranspiration,

↑ frequency of droughts → ↓ impact of river

erosion e.g. development of wadis

NB If the response does not have one of the landscape

systems identified in the Spec. (coastal, glaciated,

dryland), MAX top L1. Credit is for AO1, climate change.

NB Responses must make clear the link between

How to answer it

Modifying Landform Formation via Climate Change

OCR A-Level Geography Paper 1: Physical Systems • Section A • 12 Marks

What This Question Tests

This 12-mark extended response assesses your ability to connect systems concepts, geomorphic processes, and climatic drivers in one specific setting:

  • AO1 (6 marks): Knowledge and understanding of the processes shaping landforms within one chosen system (Coastal, Glaciated, or Dryland) and how climatic shifts alter energy inputs and mass flows.
  • AO2 (6 marks): Application and analysis of how climate change accelerates, decelerates, halts, or reverses specific landform-building processes (erosion, weathering, mass movement, and deposition).
  • Synoptic Thinking: Connecting ideas across scales (e.g. atmospheric warming → eustatic sea-level change → micro-scale hydraulic action on cliff profiles).

Question Analysis & Mark Breakdown

Question 6: Examine how the formation of landforms within ONE landscape system you have studied can be modified by climate change (coastal, glaciated or dryland). [12]

🧠 Deconstructing the Command Word: "Examine"

“Examine” requires you to unpack the mechanisms at play and weigh up relationships. Do not just describe a landform; you must trace the chain of causation:

Climate Driver → System Energy / Process Change → Modification of Landform

Consider both accelerated formation (e.g. faster cliff retreat) and disrupted/dismantled formation (e.g. drowning of spits or degradation of permafrost landforms).

📐 Level Descriptor Thresholds (12 Marks)

  • Level 4 (10–12 marks): Comprehensive AO1 & AO2. Well-developed ideas covering both landform processes and climate change. Clear, explicit synoptic links. Fully focused on one system.
  • Level 3 (7–9 marks): Thorough AO1 & AO2. Well-developed in one area, developed in the other. Attempts synoptic links.
  • Level 2 (4–6 marks): Reasonable AO1 & AO2. Generalised explanations with simple links.
  • Level 1 (1–3 marks): Basic, fragmented ideas. Penalty note: Discussing more than one landscape or an invalid system caps your response in Level 1!

Option A: Coastal Landscape System (Exemplar Study)

Focusing on erosional, depositional, and relict/emergent landforms

💡 Key Knowledge (AO1)

  • Thermal Expansion & Ice Melt: Global mean atmospheric warming causes eustatic sea level rise (+3.7 mm/yr currently) and higher sea-surface temperatures (SSTs).
  • Wave Energy & Storminess: Warmer oceans intensify tropical and mid-latitude depressions, increasing the frequency of high-energy destructive waves.
  • Sub-aerial Changes: Warmer, wetter winters increase saturation, pore-water pressure, and slumping; warmer marine conditions accelerate chemical solution of carbonate cliffs.

✅ Process-Modification Links (AO2)

  • Wave-Cut Platforms & Cliffs: Higher water levels allow deeper water closer to shore, reducing wave energy dissipation via friction. Wave breaking occurs directly against cliff bases → increased hydraulic pounding & abrasion → faster notch formation and accelerated cliff retreat.
  • Spits & Barrier Beaches: Rising sea levels outpace sediment supply. Higher storm surges breach bars and overtop spits, converting stable depositional features into transient or submerged banks through roll-over mechanisms.
  • Emergent / Submergent Modifications: Historic climate changes formed relict features (raised beaches, rias, fjords). Present-day warming drowns existing shorelines, modifying them into estuaries.
Examiner Tip for High Marks: Show nuance! Climate change does not just mean "more erosion." Point out that rising temperatures reduce freeze-thaw weathering on temperate cliff faces, potentially slowing down scree accumulation, while hotter seas induce coral bleaching, starving biogenic reefs and atolls of calcium carbonate.

Alternative Options: Glaciated & Dryland Systems

If you choose Glaciated or Dryland, apply the same cause-and-effect rigour

Option B: Glaciated Landscapes

  • Ablation > Accumulation: Negative mass balance accelerates retreat. High-elevation cirque glaciers melt, arresting the development of corries and arêtes as active plucking ceases.
  • Meltwater & Deposition: Huge initial surge in fluvioglacial discharge increases bedload transport, rapidly building kames, eskers, and outwash plains (sandurs).
  • Periglacial Thaw: Permafrost degradation deepens the active layer, modifying patterned ground and accelerating solifluction lobes.

Option C: Dryland Landscapes

  • Shifting Aridity: Rising evapotranspiration rates reduce already scarce surface moisture, starving ephemeral channels (wadis) of intermittent fluvial cutting.
  • Wind Regimes & Aeolian Landforms: Vegetation loss exposes loose regolith, accelerating deflation (forming expansive desert pavements / reg) and increasing sediment transport to build dynamic barchan dunes.
  • Episodic Storms: Higher convective instability causes rare, extreme flash floods, carving canyon walls via deep hydraulic scouring before long dry spells return.

Structuring a Level 4 Response

How to secure 10–12 marks through evaluative structure

🧠 Recommended 3-Paragraph Structure

  1. Paragraph 1: Erosional Landforms
    Examine how altered energy inputs (e.g. storm frequency/magnitude, higher water planes) modify erosional rates, notch formation, and shore platform morphology.
  2. Paragraph 2: Depositional & Sediment Budget Dynamics
    Examine how modified sediment supply (littoral drift changes, river inputs) disrupts the equilibrium of beaches, spits, or sand dunes.
  3. Paragraph 3: Weathering Shifts & Spatial/Temporal Variations
    Contrast changes in mechanical vs chemical weathering (e.g. decline in frost-shattering vs acceleration of carbonation). Distinguish immediate episodic modifications (single storm surge) from gradual macro-modifications (millennial sea-level transgression).

❌ Common Errors That Lose Marks

  • Mixing Landscape Systems: Discussing both coasts and glaciers in the same essay. The question explicitly says ONE landscape system.
  • The "Runaway Global Warming" Essay: Writing pages on the greenhouse effect, greenhouse gas emissions, or polar bear habitats without directly linking back to landform morphometry.
  • Static Landform Descriptions: Simply describing how a stack forms (crack → cave → arch → stack) without ever explaining how climate change modifies that timeline.
  • Ignoring Negative Feedback: Forgetting that accelerated cliff erosion provides more sediment to the beach, which can act as a natural buffer and subsequently decelerate erosion rate.

Topics

1.1.1 Option A – Coastal Landscapes · 1.1.2 Option B – Glaciated Landscapes · 1.1.3 Option C – Dryland Landscapes · 3.a. Emergent coastal landscapes form as sea level falls. · 3.b. Submergent coastal landscapes form as sea level rises. · 3.a. Glacio-fluvial landforms exist as a result of climate change at the end of glacial periods. · 3.b. Periglacial landforms exist as a result of climate change before and/or after glacial periods. · 3.a. Fluvial landforms can exist in dryland landscapes as a result of earlier pluvial periods. · 3.b. Periglacial landforms can exist as a result of earlier colder periods.

Question and mark scheme from the OCR A-Level Geography examination, Geographical debates (03), June 2025. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.