AQA AS Level Biology Paper 2, June 2025: Question 7
9 marks · Medium difficulty · Short Answer
Answer questions on the structure of Vibrio cholerae, protein toxin binding, the mechanism of diarrhoea via osmosis, and calculate cholera mortality from graphical data.
Practise this questionQuestion
Question text
07.1 Figure 11 shows the structure of the bacterium Vibrio cholerae.
Figure 11
Name three structures shown in Figure 11 that are not found in all bacteria.
[2 marks]
07.2 V. cholerae produces a toxin that only binds to the cell-surface membrane of epithelial
cells lining the ileum. The toxin is a protein.
Explain why the toxin can only bind to the cell-surface membrane of epithelial cells in
the ileum.
[2 marks]
07.3 The toxin causes chloride ion channels in the cell-surface membrane to open.
Chloride ions diffuse into the ileum. This causes diarrhoea (watery faeces).
Use your knowledge of water potential to explain how an increase of chloride ions in
the ileum results in diarrhoea.
[2 marks]
V. cholerae causes the disease cholera.
The Fatality Percentage (FP) is the percentage of people diagnosed with cholera who
die from it.
Figure 12 shows:
• the number of reported cases of cholera in a population for the years
2020 and 2021
• the FP for cholera for the years 2020 and 2021.
Figure 12
07.4 Using Figure 12 and the information provided, calculate the difference in the number
of deaths from cholera in 2020 and 2021.
[2 marks]
Difference in the number of deaths
07.5 The calculated numbers of deaths from cholera, in 2020 and 2021, are lower than the
*26true number of deaths.*
Using the information suggest one reason why.
[1 mark]
Mark scheme
Show the mark scheme
Question Marking Guidance Mark Comments
Flagellum/flagella
Plasmid(s)
Capsule;;
07.1 Accept in any order. (2 x
AO1)
3 correct = 2 marks
2 correct = 1 mark
1 or 0 correct = 0 marks
1. Has (specific) tertiary structure/shape; 1. Ignore 3D shape
1. Accept in context of
receptor or toxin
2. Structures are complementary; 2. Accept in correct
context of receptor
and/or toxin in relation
07.2 (2 x
to MP1.
AO2)
Reject only once
reference to active
site/enzyme/
substrate/induced
fit/antibody
1. (The chloride ions) lower the water potential (in 1. Accept correct
the ileum) description of lower
water potential eg
OR more negative
Accept Ψ for water
(Loss of chloride ions) increases the water potential but not
potential in the cells; wp/WP
2. Water moves out of the (epithelial) cells by 2. Accept small
osmosis intestine for ileum
07.3 OR (2 x
AO2)
Water moves into the ileum by osmosis
OR
Water does not enter the cells by osmosis
OR
Water does not move out of the ileum by
osmosis;
Correct answer for 2 marks = 108;;
Incorrect answer but shows 1260 or 1152 = 1 mark
OR
07.4 Incorrect answer but four correct readings 350 000, (2 x
0.36, 90 000, 1.28 = 1 mark AO2)
OR
Incorrect reading(s) from the graph but correct
method (number of cases × FP) ÷ 100 = 1 mark;
(Uses) reported cases only/not all cases reported
07.5 OR (1 x
AO2)
Misdiagnosis/not diagnosed (as cholera);
How to answer it
Vibrio cholerae: Structure, Pathogenicity & Data Analysis
This multi-step question integrates prokaryotic cell biology, membrane biochemistry, transport mechanisms, and mathematical graphical analysis:
- Prokaryotic Ultrastructure: Distinguishing universal bacterial cell components from variable specialist structures.
- Protein Specificity: Explaining molecular recognition through complementary tertiary structures without confusing enzymatic with non-enzymatic terminology.
- Osmosis & Water Potential: Formulating precise cause-and-effect explanations of ion movement and osmotic shifts across epithelial tissues.
- Dual-Axis Graph Calculation: Extracting values accurately across dual y-axes with different scales to calculate percentages and differences.
- Epidemiological Data Evaluation: Identifying systematic sources of error and under-reporting in health statistics.
Variable Prokaryotic Cell Structures
Identifying structures not present in all bacterial species
✅ Correct Answer
Any three from the structures labelled in Figure 11:
- Flagellum (or flagella)
- Plasmid (or plasmids)
- Capsule (slime layer)
• All 3 correct = 2 marks
• 2 correct = 1 mark
• 0 or 1 correct = 0 marks
💡 Key Knowledge
Universal to all bacteria:
- 70S Ribosomes
- Cell-surface membrane
- Cell wall (murein/peptidoglycan)
- Circular DNA molecule (nucleoid)
- Cytoplasm
Plasmids, capsules, and flagella are facultative (optional) adaptations.
🧠 Exam Technique
Always inspect the provided diagram carefully. The question asks for structures "shown in Figure 11". Do not name features absent from the diagram (e.g. pili or endospores), as examiners will reject items outside the provided figure.
❌ Common Errors
- Listing cell wall or circular DNA (all bacterial species possess these).
- Writing "nucleus" or "mitochondria" (prokaryotes lack membrane-bound organelles altogether).
Protein Toxin Specificity
Explaining targeted binding of cholera toxin to epithelial cell membranes
✅ Correct Answer
- The toxin has a specific tertiary structure (or specific 3D shape). 1 Mark
- Its shape is complementary to the binding site/receptor present only on the cell-surface membrane of epithelial cells in the ileum. 1 Mark
❌ Common Examiner Traps (Automatic Loss of Mark)
Reject references to:
- "Active site"
- "Enzyme" / "Substrate"
- "Induced fit model"
- "Antibody / Antigen"
Examiner Note: A toxin binding a membrane receptor is not an enzymatic catalytic event. Using enzyme vocabulary here demonstrates poor conceptual understanding.
💡 Key Knowledge
Proteins achieve binding specificity via unique sequences of amino acids folding into precise tertiary structures held together by hydrogen bonds, ionic bonds, and disulfide bridges. Receptors are typically transmembrane glycoproteins or glycolipids found exclusively on specific target cell lineages.
🧠 Exam Technique
Never write just "shape" or "they fit together like a lock and key". Use the precise A-Level terminology: specific tertiary structure and complementary shape.
Mechanism of Diarrhoea & Water Potential
Connecting ion secretion to osmotic movement into the lumen
✅ Correct Answer
- The accumulation of chloride ions (Cl⁻) lowers the water potential of the lumen / ileum (making it more negative)
OR loss of Cl⁻ increases the water potential inside epithelial cells. 1 Mark - Water moves out of the epithelial cells and into the lumen / ileum down a water potential gradient by osmosis. 1 Mark
💡 Key Knowledge: Osmotic Flow in Cholera
Pure water has a water potential (Ψ) of 0 kPa. Adding solutes (like Cl⁻) always lowers Ψ (making it more negative). Water constantly moves from a region of higher (less negative) Ψ to a region of lower (more negative) Ψ across a partially permeable membrane via osmosis.
🧠 Exam Technique
- You may write the symbol Ψ instead of "water potential", but never use abbreviations like "wp" or "WP" (these are strictly not accepted by AQA examiners).
- Always state the name of the process: osmosis. Saying "water diffuses" or "water moves down a concentration gradient" without specifying osmosis often forfeits MP2.
❌ Common Errors
- Stating that chloride ions "increase water potential" (solutes always lower water potential).
- Forgetting to state direction: water leaves the cells/blood and enters the ileum/lumen.
- Confusing water concentration with water potential. Stick to water potential terminology.
Dual-Axis Graph Calculation: Total Deaths
Calculating the difference in cholera fatalities between 2020 and 2021
📐 Step-by-Step Calculation
Step 1: Read the axes scales carefully
- Left Y-Axis (Reported Cases - Grey Bar): 50 000 per 5 small grid squares → 1 small square = 10 000 cases.
- Right Y-Axis (Fatality Percentage / FP - White Bar): 0.2% per 5 small grid squares → 1 small square = 0.04%.
Step 2: Calculate deaths in 2020
- Reported cases = 350 000
- Fatality Percentage (FP) = 9 small squares = 0.36%
- Number of deaths (2020) = 350 000 × (0.36 ÷ 100) = 1 260
Step 3: Calculate deaths in 2021
- Reported cases = 9 small squares = 90 000
- Fatality Percentage (FP) = 32 small squares = 1.28%
- Number of deaths (2021) = 90 000 × (1.28 ÷ 100) = 1 152
Step 4: Find the difference
- Difference = 1 260 − 1 152 = 108
Partial credit: If final answer is incorrect, 1 mark is awarded for either showing 1 260 or 1 152, or giving all 4 correct graph readings (350 000, 0.36, 90 000, 1.28), or showing correct formula with misread values.
🧠 Exam Technique
Always write down each intermediate number ( 1260 and 1152 ) in the working space. If you make an arithmetic slip on the final subtraction, you still secure 1 mark for the working.
❌ Common Errors
- Forgetting to divide the percentage by 100 (multiplying directly by 0.36 instead of 0.0036).
- Misreading the right-hand axis (e.g. assuming each square is 0.02 or 0.1 rather than 0.04).
Evaluating Epidemiological Data
Explaining why calculated cholera deaths underestimate the true death toll
✅ Correct Answer
Any one valid reason:
- The data only records reported cases / not all cases are reported. 1 Mark
- Misdiagnosis of cholera / cholera was not diagnosed (e.g. recorded as general gastroenteritis or dehydration). 1 Mark
- People die before reaching medical help / without being diagnosed in clinical facilities. 1 Mark
🧠 Exam Technique: "Using the information..."
Look at the wording of Figure 12: "Number of reported cases". Whenever the word "reported" appears in health statistics, it is a deliberate prompt indicating that non-reporting or under-reporting is a key limitation.
Topics
Biology · Practical skills · 3.1 Biological molecules · 3.2 Cells · Data analysis
Question and mark scheme from the AQA AS Level Biology examination, Paper 2, June 2025. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.