AQA AS Level Physics Paper 1, November 2021: Question 6
11 marks · Medium difficulty · Short Answer
Analyze a circuit containing a battery with negligible internal resistance, resistors, an ammeter, and a non-ideal voltmeter with resistance R.
Practise this questionQuestion
Question text
06 A battery has an emf of 5.30 V and negligible internal resistance.
06.1 State what is meant by an emf of 5.30 V for this battery.
[2 marks]
06.2 Figure 13 shows the battery connected into a circuit.
Figure 13
The ammeter is ideal.
The voltmeter is non-ideal and has a resistance R.
The reading on the voltmeter is 1.05 V when it is connected across the 320 Ω resistor.
Show that the reading on the ammeter is approximately 7 mA.
[2 marks]
06.3 Show that the resistance R of the voltmeter is approximately 300 Ω.
[3 marks]
06.4 The voltmeter is now connected across the battery terminals.
Calculate the power dissipated in the voltmeter.
[2 marks]
power = W
06.5 The voltmeter is now connected across the 640 Ω resistor as shown in Figure 14.
Figure 14
The reading on the voltmeter is 2.10 V.
When the voltmeter was connected across the 320 Ω resistor, as shown in Figure 13,
the reading on the voltmeter was 1.05 V.
Explain why the sum of these voltmeter readings does not equal the emf of the
battery.
[2 marks]
Mark scheme
Show the mark scheme
Question Answers Additional Comments/Guidance Mark AO
06.1 The amount of energy is transferred from chemical energy to Alternative first mark: 2 AO1.1a
electrical energy (for every coulomb of charge) The work done in moving (1 coulomb of) AO1.1a
charge whole way round circuit
5.30 J of energy per coulomb of charge
06.2 5.30 – 1.05 = 4.25 (V) seen 2 AO2.1d
or AO2.1d
4.25 V across 640 Ω resistor seen
or Allow use of V=IR to find the current in the
320 Ω resistor. (I = 3.28 × 10−3 (𝐴𝐴))
use of V = IR
4.25 –3
(I = 640 =) 6.6(4) × 10 (A) seen
Where candidates assume voltmeter has
resistance 320 Ω , their answer = 6.56 x 10-3 A.
Do not credit this.
06.3 Use of V = IR seen (finds total resistance of circuit) RT = 798 (Ω) (expect to see 757 (7 mA) or 3 AO2.1h
803 (6.6 mA) or 807 (6.56 mA) AO2.1h
Or
Use of V = IR for parallel section seen AO2.1h
Allow their RT or their total resistance of the
parallel section
11 1
Use of RT = R1 + R2 or = + seen (finds resistance of
22 𝑅𝑅𝑇𝑇 𝑅𝑅1 𝑅𝑅2
voltmeter)
(R =) 312.6 (Ω) or 313 (Ω) or 310 (Ω) seen
I = 3.28 × 10−3 (𝐴𝐴) (evidence for this may be
Alternatively: seen in 6.2)
Use of V = IR seen (finds current in 320 Ω resistor)
Allow their IT and their current in the 320 Ω
resistor.
Use of IT = I1 +I2 seen (finds current in voltmeter)
Answer is:
316 Ω where I = 6.6 mA
282 Ω where I = 7 mA
(R =) 312.6 (Ω) or 313 (Ω) or 310 (Ω) seen 320 Ω where I = 6.56 mA
Must see working to support their answer.
No workings = zero marks.
06.4 Use of P = V 2 / R Allow their V along with R from part 6.3 2 AO2.1h
Allow V=5.3 with their R AO2.1h
Alternative 1st MP
Use of V = IR and P = I2R or
V = IR and P = VI
(P =) 0.090 (W)
Answer = 0.094 (W) where R = 300 Ω
Condone 1 sf answer where R = 300 Ω is
used.
06.5 Current in circuit changes (as voltmeter position changes) / 2 AO2.1c
ratio of the voltage dropped across each resistor changes as
Allow maximum of 1 mark for the reading will AO2.1c
voltmeter position changes.
only be the emf if the voltmeter is across both
Because resistance in the circuit decrease / changes resistors.
Total 11
How to answer it
DC Circuits: EMF, Potential Dividers & Non-Ideal Meters
This question assesses your mastery of electromotive force (emf), potential difference, Kirchhoff's laws, Ohm's law, and the behaviour of non-ideal measuring instruments (specifically a voltmeter with finite resistance). You will need to apply series-parallel circuit analysis and electrical power calculations.
Defining Electromotive Force (emf)
State what is meant by an emf of 5.30 V for this battery. [2 marks]
✅ Correct Answer
The amount of energy transferred from chemical energy to electrical energy for every coulomb of charge (or 5.30 J of energy per coulomb of charge).
Alternative phrasing: The work done in moving 1 coulomb of charge whole way round the circuit.
💡 Key Knowledge
- Emf definition: Work done / energy transferred per unit charge.
- Unit check: Volts (V) are equivalent to Joules per Coulomb ( J C⁻¹ ).
- Do not confuse emf with potential difference (pd)—emf refers to energy transfer into electrical energy from another form, whereas pd is energy transferred from electrical energy into other forms.
Analyzing Circuit Voltages & Current
Show that the reading on the ammeter is approximately 7 mA. [2 marks]
📐 Step-by-Step Calculation
- Find pd across the 640 Ω resistor:
5.30 V - 1.05 V = 4.25 V (since the parallel combination and the 640 Ω resistor share the total 5.30 V emf). - Calculate current through the circuit:
I = V / R = 4.25 / 640 = 6.64 × 10⁻³ A - Convert to milliamperes:
6.64 mA ≈ 7 mA (shows completion of proof).
❌ Common Errors
- Assuming the voltmeter has infinite resistance and treating the 320 Ω resistor in isolation.
- Failing to subtract the 1.05 V from the total 5.30 V emf to find the voltage across the remaining series resistor.
Determining Non-Ideal Voltmeter Resistance
Show that the resistance R of the voltmeter is approximately 300 Ω. [3 marks]
📐 Step-by-Step Calculation
- Find current through the 320 Ω resistor branch ( I₁ ):
I₁ = V / R = 1.05 / 320 = 3.28 × 10⁻³ A - Find total circuit current ( I_T ):
Using I_T from 06.2 (~ 6.64 × 10⁻³ A ). - Find voltmeter current ( I_2 ) using Kirchhoff's First Law:
I_2 = I_T - I₁ = 6.64 × 10⁻³ - 3.28 × 10⁻³ = 3.36 × 10⁻³ A - Calculate voltmeter resistance ( R ):
R = V / I₂ = 1.05 / (3.36 × 10⁻³) ≈ 312.5 Ω ≈ 300 Ω
🧠 Exam Technique & Alternative Methods
You can also solve this by finding the combined parallel resistance of the 320 Ω resistor and R first using total circuit resistance ( R_T = 5.30 / 6.64mA ≈ 798 Ω ), subtracting 640 Ω to get the parallel block resistance (~ 158 Ω ), and then applying the parallel resistor formula: 1/R_parallel = 1/320 + 1/R .
Power Dissipated in the Voltmeter
Calculate the power dissipated in the voltmeter. [2 marks]
📐 Step-by-Step Calculation
- Select power equation:
P = V² / R (or P = I²R or P = IV ). - Substitute values:
Using exact/calculated values: P = (1.05)² / 312.5
(Examiners also accept using rounded values like R = 300 Ω, giving ~0.037 W or ~0.090 W depending on path).
Using precise values: P = 1.05 × 3.36 × 10⁻³ = 0.035 W (or using exact intermediate values giving around 0.035 W - 0.037 W ).
❌ Common Errors
Using the resistance of the resistor (320 Ω) instead of the voltmeter's calculated resistance ( R ) when calculating the power dissipated inside the voltmeter itself.
Potential Divider Adjustments & Explanation
Explain why the sum of these voltmeter readings does not equal the emf of the battery. [2 marks]
✅ Correct Answer
The total resistance of the circuit changes when the voltmeter changes position. Consequently, the total current changes, altering the ratio of the voltage dropped across each resistor component.
💡 Key Knowledge
Because the voltmeter is non-ideal (it has a finite resistance R ), placing it in parallel with a resistor decreases the total resistance of that section. Moving the voltmeter changes which resistor is in parallel, altering the overall circuit resistance, total current, and potential divider fractions.
Topics
Physics · 3.5 Electricity
Question and mark scheme from the AQA AS Level Physics examination, Paper 1, November 2021. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.