AQA GCSE Biology Biology Paper 2 (Higher), June 2023: Question 1

8 marks Β· Low Demand difficulty Β· Short Answer

Identify ecological definitions and bird classification from binomial names, and interpret seasonal bird population changes from a line graph.

Practise this question

Question

Question 01 consists of multiple subquestions. 01.1 asks for the term for all organisms in a habitat with four tick boxes: community, food chain, population, ecosystem. Figure 1 shows illustrations and binomial names of four birds: Brambling (Fringilla montifringilla), Bullfinch (Pyrrhula pyrrhula), Chaffinch (Fringilla coelebs), and Goldfinch (Carduelis carduelis). 01.2 and 01.3 ask multiple-choice questions on which birds are most closely related and what defines different species. Figure 2 shows a line graph plotting the number of birds on the y-axis against months from Jan to Dec on the x-axis for four bird species A, B, C, and D. 01.4 to 01.6 ask to describe the population change of species A, identify the species with the lowest disease resistance in June and July, and identify the migratory species with a reason.
Question text

01 Many different species can live together in the same habitat.

01.1 What name is given to all of the organisms living in the same habitat?

[1 mark]

Tick ( ) one box.

A community

A food chain

A population

An ecosystem 4

Figure 1 shows four species of bird from the same habitat in the UK.

Figure 1

Brambling (Fringilla montifringilla) Bullfinch (Pyrrhula pyrrhula)

Chaffinch (Fringilla coelebs) Goldfinch (Carduelis carduelis)

01.2 Which species of bird in Figure 1 do scientists think are most closely related?

[1 mark]

Tick ( ) one box.

Brambling and chaffinch

Brambling and goldfinch

Bullfinch and chaffinch

Bullfinch and goldfinch

01.3 Scientists think the brambling and the bullfinch belong to different species.

What evidence is used by scientists to classify the brambling and the bullfinch as

different species?

[1 mark]

Tick ( ) one box.

The brambling and the bullfinch are different sizes.

The brambling and the bullfinch cannot breed together to give fertile

offspring.

The brambling and the bullfinch live in different parts of the habitat.

The brambling eats mainly seeds and the bullfinch eats mainly insects.6

Four other species of bird (A, B, C and D) live in a habitat in the UK.

Figure 2 shows how the numbers of each species of bird varied during one year.

Figure 2

Use information from Figure 2 to answer Questions 01.4 to 01.6

01.4 Describe what happens to the number of birds of species A during the year.

[3 marks]

01.5 In June and July, a disease affected the populations of some of the species.

Which species had the lowest resistance to the disease?

[1 mark]

Tick ( ) one box.

A B C D

01.6 One species migrates between the UK and other countries.

Which species migrates between the UK and other countries?

Give a reason for your answer.

[1 mark]

Species

Reason

Mark scheme

Show the mark scheme Mark scheme for Question 1: 01.1 awards 1 mark for 'a community'. 01.2 awards 1 mark for 'brambling and chaffinch'. 01.3 awards 1 mark for 'the brambling and the bullfinch cannot breed together to give fertile offspring'. 01.4 awards up to 3 marks for describing species A: constant from Jan to Mar/mid-Apr (1 mark), increases from mid-Apr to May (1 mark), and decreases from May/Jun to Dec (1 mark). 01.5 awards 1 mark for 'B'. 01.6 awards 1 mark for 'D' because it is present only from May to September/October. Total marks: 8.

Question 1

AO /

Question Answers Extra information Mark

Spec Ref.

01.1 a community 1 AO1

4.7.1.1

AO /

Spec Ref.

01.2 brambling and chaffinch 1 AO2

4.6.4

AO /

Spec Ref.

01.3 the brambling and the bullfinch 1 AO1

cannot breed together to give 4.6.2.2

fertile offspring

AO /

Spec Ref.

01.4 allow answers in terms of month AO3

numbers 4.7.1.1

ignore seasons

constant (from Jan) to Mar / ignore straight 1

(mid-)Apr

increases (from mid-)Apr to / 1

and May

decreases from May / Jun to

Dec

if no other marks awarded allow

for 1 mark constant, then

increase then decrease

AO /

Spec Ref.

01.5 B 1 AO3

4.7.1.1

4.7.1.4

AO /

Spec Ref.

01.6 D (because) present only May to allow D (because) present only 1 AO3 7

Sep May to Oct 4.7.1.1

4.7.1.4

allow D (because) not present

Oct to Apr / May

allow D (because) present only

in summer

allow D (because) not present

in winter

allow D (because) not present

for all the year

allow D (because) only present

for some of the year

Total Question 1 8

How to answer it

Ecology: Levels of Organisation, Classification & Population Graphs

πŸ“‹ What This Question Tests

This question assesses fundamental recall and graph-interpretation skills from Topic 4.7 (Ecology) and Topic 4.6 (Inheritance, Variation and Evolution):

  • Ecological terminology: Distinguishing between populations, communities, and ecosystems.
  • Binomial classification: Identifying related species using scientific genus names.
  • Species definition: Defining a species through the production of fertile offspring.
  • Graph interpretation: Describing population trends chronologically and extracting real-world biological phenomena (disease impact and migration).
Part 01.1 β€’ 1 Mark

Organisms in the Same Habitat

Identifying levels of ecological organisation

βœ… Correct Answer

A community

πŸ’‘ Key Knowledge

  • Population: All organisms of one single species living in a habitat.
  • Community: All the populations of different species living together in a habitat.
  • Ecosystem: The interaction of a community of living organisms (biotic) with non-living (abiotic) elements.

❌ Common Errors

Confusing community with population (only one species) or ecosystem (which must include abiotic factors like light, water, and temperature).

Part 01.2 β€’ 1 Mark

Relatedness from Scientific Names

Using the Linnaean binomial naming system

βœ… Correct Answer

Brambling and chaffinch

πŸ’‘ Key Knowledge

Every organism has a two-part Latin name (binomial):

  • First word = Genus: Shared by closely related species.
  • Second word = Species: Unique identifier within that genus.
  • Brambling is Fringilla montifringilla and Chaffinch is Fringilla coelebs. Sharing the genus Fringilla proves they are most closely related.

🧠 Exam Technique

Never rely on physical appearances in photosβ€”birds can look similar due to convergent evolution. Always scan the Latin names and match the first word.

Part 01.3 β€’ 1 Mark

Biological Definition of a Species

Criteria for classifying distinct species

βœ… Correct Answer

The brambling and the bullfinch cannot breed together to give fertile offspring.

πŸ’‘ Key Knowledge

A species is strictly defined as a group of organisms capable of interbreeding to produce fertile offspring.

If two organisms cannot interbreed, or their hybrid offspring are infertile (like a mule), they are separate species.

❌ Common Errors

Selecting differences in size, diet, or habitat location. Different species frequently share habitats and eat the same food, while members of the same species can vary greatly in size (e.g., dog breeds).

Part 01.4 β€’ 3 Marks

Describing Population Changes Over Time

Describing the trend for Species A from Figure 2

βœ… Correct Answer (Award 1 mark per point)

  1. Constant / stays the same from January to March / mid-April [1]
  2. Increases from (mid-)April to May / June [1]
  3. Decreases from May / June to December [1]
Compensatory mark rule: If no dates/months are provided, writing "constant, then increases, then decreases" scores a maximum of 1 mark.

🧠 Exam Technique: Describing Line Graphs

  • Split the graph into distinct stages: Identify each turning point along the x-axis.
  • Quote timeframes: Always pair the trend word (constant, increases, decreases) with the specific months.
  • Avoid vague vocabulary: Do not write "the line is straight" (examiners ignore this). Use constant or unchanged.

❌ Common Errors

  • Attempting to explain why (e.g., "birds hatched in spring") when the question command word is purely Describe.
  • Using seasons ("in spring it goes up") instead of the named months given on the axis. The mark scheme explicitly notes: ignore seasons.
Part 01.5 β€’ 1 Mark

Disease Resistance in Populations

Linking a sudden summer decline to low immunity

βœ… Correct Answer

B

πŸ’‘ Key Knowledge

Lowest resistance means individuals have little or no defence against the pathogen, causing the highest death rate.

On Figure 2, during June and July, curve B plunges steeply downwards almost to the baseline, indicating widespread mortality compared to the other species.

❌ Common Errors

Picking A or C because they also decline slightly, or picking D which doesn't decline until August/September.

Part 01.6 β€’ 1 Mark

Identifying Migration from Population Data

Recognising seasonal absence from a UK habitat

βœ… Correct Answer

Species: D

Reason: Any valid statement indicating seasonal presence/absence, e.g.:

  • Present only from May to September (or May to October)
  • Not present / absent from October to April (or October to May)
  • Only present in the summer / not present in winter
  • Not present for the whole year / only present for some of the year

🧠 Exam Technique

Both the correct species letter (D) AND an acceptable reason must be given to secure this 1 mark. A blank or incorrect reason will forfeit the mark even if D is chosen.

πŸ’‘ Key Knowledge

Migration is the seasonal movement of animals from one region to another. Curve D drops to zero and stays at zero for over half the year, which is a classic signature of a migratory summer visitor (such as swallows or swifts).

Topics

Biology Β· B6: Inheritance, Variation and Evolution Β· B7: Ecology

Question and mark scheme from the AQA GCSE Biology examination, Biology Paper 2 (Higher), June 2023. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.