AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy Physics Paper 1 (Higher), 2018: Question 5

12 marks · Standard Demand difficulty · Extended Answer

Explain how cavity wall insulation reduces unwanted energy transfer, determine the house temperature after 30 minutes from a table, describe energy store changes in a gas boiler, and calculate the boiler power from energy transferred in a given time.

Practise this question

Question

The question page contains four linked physics parts about heating a house. Figure 7 is a labelled diagram of a cavity wall with outer brick, inner block, and insulation in the gap, shown being injected by a worker; part 05.1 asks how the wall reduces unwanted energy transfers for 3 marks. Part 05.2 describes an investigation where heating is switched off and inside temperature is measured every 20 minutes for 2 hours; Table 4 lists times 0, 20, 40, 60, 80, 100 and 120 minutes with temperatures 25.0, 20.8, 17.4, 14.5, 12.1, 10.0 and 8.4 degrees Celsius, and asks for the temperature after 30 minutes for 2 marks. Figure 8 shows a gas boiler with labelled arrows for fuel in, cold water in, hot water out, and hot exhaust gas out; part 05.3 asks for changes in energy stores for 3 marks, and part 05.4 states that the boiler transfers 15 MJ in 10 minutes and asks for the power, including an equation, for 4 marks.
Question text

05 Figure 7 shows cavity wall insulation being installed in the wall of a house.

Figure 7

05.1 Explain how the wall reduces unwanted energy transfers.

[3 marks]

05.2 The cavity insulation was tested.

• The heating inside the house was switched off.

• The temperature inside the house was measured every 20 minutes for

2 hours.

Table 4 shows the results.

Table 4

Time in minutes Temperature in °C

0 25.0

20 20.8

40 17.4

60 14.5

80 12.1

100 10.0

120 8.4

Determine the temperature inside the house after 30 minutes.

[2 marks]

Temperature = °C

05.3 Figure 8 shows the gas boiler used to heat the house.

Figure 8

Describe how different energy stores are changed by the boiler.

[3 marks]

05.4 To heat the house, the boiler transfers 15 MJ of energy in 10 minutes.

Calculate the power of the boiler.

Write any equation that you use.

[4 marks]

Power = W

Mark scheme

Show the mark scheme The mark scheme is a table listing answers, extra information, marks and AO/specification references for questions 05.1 to 05.4. For 05.1 it credits stating the wall has two or three layers or is thick, that the insulation, brick or block has low thermal conductivity, and that less energy is transferred by conduction; for 05.2 it shows interpolation between 20.8 and 17.4 degrees Celsius to give 19.1 degrees Celsius, with 18.5 to 19.1 accepted. For 05.3 it credits that the chemical energy store of the fuel decreases while the thermal energy store of the water and of the air or atmosphere increases. For 05.4 it shows E = 15,000,000 joules, t = 600 seconds, uses P = E divided by t, and gives 25,000 watts; the total is 12 marks.

AO /

Question Answers Extra information Mark

Spec. Ref.

05.1 the wall has two / three layers allow the wall is thick 1 AO1

6.1.2.1

cavity wall insulation / brick / 1

block has a low thermal

conductivity

so less energy is transferred by allow rate of energy transfer is 1

conduction lower

ignore any reference to

convection and / or radiation

05.2 an answer in the range 18.5‒ AO3

19.1 scores 2 marks 6.1.2.1

(20.8 - 17.4)

T = 17.4 + � � 1

or

(20.8 - 17.4)

T = 20.8 + � �

T = 19.1 (°C) 1

05.3 chemical energy store of the fuel 1 AO1

decreases 6.1.2.1

thermal energy store of the allow kinetic energy store of the 1

water increases water particles increases

thermal energy store of the air / allow kinetic energy store of the 1

atmosphere increases air particles increases

05.4 an answer of 25 000 scores 4 AO2

marks 6.1.1.4

E = 15 000 000 (J) 1

t = 600 (s) 1

allow a correct substitution of 1

15 000 000

p = incorrectly / not converted

600 values of E and / or t

allow a correct calculation using 1

P = 25 000 (W) incorrectly / not converted

values of E and / or t

Total 12

How to answer it

Heat Transfer, Temperature Change and Boiler Power

What this question tests

Core skills and knowledge

  • Explain how cavity wall insulation reduces heat loss by conduction.
  • Read a results table and estimate a value using interpolation.
  • Describe changes in energy stores in a boiler system.
  • Use the power equation power = energy transferred ÷ time with correct unit conversions.

Question overview

Overall difficulty: Low Demand

This is a straightforward GCSE question set. Most marks come from recalling key phrases, reading values from a table, and doing one simple calculation with unit conversion.

Part (a) / 05.1 — How the wall reduces unwanted energy transfers [3 marks]

✅ Correct answer

The wall has two or three layers. The cavity wall insulation, brick, and block have a low thermal conductivity, so less energy is transferred by conduction.

💡 Key knowledge

  • Thermal conductivity tells us how easily energy passes through a material.
  • Materials with low thermal conductivity are good insulators.
  • A cavity wall has layers and a gap filled with insulation, which slows heat transfer.

🧠 Exam technique

  • To get full marks, link the structure of the wall to conduction.
  • Use the wording “less energy is transferred” or “rate of energy transfer is lower”.
  • Marks are awarded for separate points: structure, property, and effect.

❌ Common errors

  • Only saying “it keeps the house warm” is too vague.
  • Talking only about convection or radiation is not needed here.
  • “Insulation stops heat loss completely” is wrong — it reduces it.
How the marks are awarded: one mark for the wall having layers / being thick, one mark for low thermal conductivity, one mark for less energy transferred by conduction.

Part (b) / 05.2 — Estimate the temperature after 30 minutes [2 marks]

📐 Calculations: step-by-step

  1. At 20 minutes, the temperature is 20.8 °C.
  2. At 40 minutes, the temperature is 17.4 °C.
  3. 30 minutes is halfway between 20 and 40 minutes, so take the midpoint.
  4. Calculate the drop: 20.8 - 17.4 = 3.4 °C
  5. Half of 3.4 is 1.7 °C
  6. Subtract from 20.8: 20.8 - 1.7 = 19.1 °C

Answer: 19.1 °C

✅ Correct answer

Temperature = 19.1 °C

🧠 Exam technique

  • This is interpolation — finding a value between two results.
  • Use the two nearest values from the table.
  • Even if your method is shown, the final answer must be sensible.
  • The mark scheme allows answers in the range 18.5–19.1 °C for full marks.

❌ Common errors

  • Using the average of all temperatures is not correct.
  • Choosing 0 and 120 minutes would make the estimate less accurate.
  • Forgetting that 30 minutes is halfway between 20 and 40 minutes.
Examiner insight: students scored well when they clearly used the values at 20 and 40 minutes and showed a midpoint calculation. Top responses were neat and easy to follow.

Part (c) / 05.3 — Energy stores in the boiler [3 marks]

✅ Correct answer

  • The chemical energy store of the fuel decreases.
  • The thermal energy store of the water increases.
  • The thermal energy store of the air / atmosphere increases.

💡 Key knowledge

  • Fuel is burned, so chemical energy is transferred out of the fuel.
  • Energy is transferred to the water, heating it up.
  • Some energy is also wasted to the surroundings and the air.

🧠 Exam technique

  • Use the phrase energy store — this is important in GCSE Physics.
  • You do not need long explanations; three clear store changes are enough.
  • Marks are usually awarded for each correct store change.

❌ Common errors

  • Saying “heat rises” without naming an energy store is too vague.
  • Mixing up thermal energy store with temperature.
  • Leaving out the air/surroundings loss often loses a mark.
Examiner note: some students only mentioned the water heating up. Top answers also recognised that the surroundings gain thermal energy because no boiler is 100% efficient.

Part (d) / 05.4 — Calculate the power of the boiler [4 marks]

📐 Calculations: step-by-step

  1. Write the equation: power = energy transferred ÷ time
  2. Convert the energy:
    15 MJ = 15 000 000 J
  3. Convert the time:
    10 minutes = 600 s
  4. Substitute:
    power = 15 000 000 ÷ 600
  5. Calculate:
    power = 25 000 W

Answer: 25 000 W

✅ Correct answer

Power = 25 000 W

🧠 Exam technique

  • Always use joules and seconds for power calculations.
  • Write the equation before substituting numbers.
  • Show unit conversions clearly — they are part of the method marks.
  • Answer should be in W, not kW, unless you convert it correctly.

❌ Common errors

  • Using 10 instead of 600 seconds loses accuracy and often marks.
  • Writing 15 000 000 ÷ 10 is a common trap.
  • Forgetting the unit, or giving 25 kW without a correct conversion.
How the marks are awarded: 1 mark for converting 15 MJ to 15 000 000 J, 1 mark for converting 10 minutes to 600 s, 1 mark for substituting into the equation, 1 mark for the correct answer of 25 000 W. The mark scheme also allows full marks if a student gives 25 000 W even with some earlier value slips, as long as the method is correct.

Quick revision summary

💡 Key facts to remember

  • Insulation reduces heat transfer by conduction.
  • Estimate values from graphs/tables by interpolation.
  • Boilers transfer energy from chemical to thermal stores.
  • power = energy ÷ time
  • Use J and s in power calculations.

❌ Biggest traps

  • Talking about insulation in general terms without conduction.
  • Not showing how the 30-minute value is found.
  • Forgetting that some energy is transferred to the surroundings.
  • Not converting minutes to seconds in the power calculation.

Topics

Physics · P1: Energy

Question and mark scheme from the AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy examination, Physics Paper 1 (Higher), 2018. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.