AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy Physics Paper 1 (Higher), 2018: Question 6

16 marks · Standard Demand difficulty · Extended Answer

Sketch the I–V graph for a filament lamp, compare currents in a parallel circuit with two identical lamps, calculate the charge through the cell in 1 minute, and explain how ammeter and voltmeter readings change in a circuit containing an LDR when light intensity changes.

Practise this question

Question

The question page contains four linked parts about electricity, total 16 marks. Part 06.1 asks for a sketch of a current–potential difference graph for a filament lamp on blank axes labelled Current vertically and Potential difference horizontally. Part 06.2 shows a parallel circuit with a cell on the top branch and two identical filament lamps on separate parallel branches, with currents labelled I1 in the main top branch, I2 through the middle lamp branch, and I3 through the lower lamp branch; students must compare the currents. Part 06.3 asks students to calculate the charge flowing through the cell in 1 minute, given that each filament lamp has a power of 3 W and a resistance of 12 ohms, with space to show equations and give the unit. Part 06.4 shows a different circuit with a cell, an ammeter in series, a fixed resistor, and an LDR in series, with a voltmeter connected across the LDR and arrows pointing at the LDR to indicate changing light intensity; students must explain how the readings on both meters change when environmental conditions change.
Question text

06 A student built a circuit using filament lamps.

06.1 Sketch a current potential difference graph for a filament lamp on Figure 9

[2 marks]

Figure 9

Figure 10 shows the circuit with two identical filament lamps.

Figure 10

06.2 Compare the currents I1, I2 and I3

[2 marks]

06.3 Calculate the charge that flows through the cell in 1 minute.

Each filament lamp has a power of 3 W and a resistance of 12 Ω

Write any equations that you use.

Give the unit.

[6 marks]

Charge =

Unit =

06.4 The student builds a different circuit.

Figure 11 shows the circuit.

Figure 11

Explain how the readings on both meters change when the environmental conditions

change.

[6 marks]

Mark scheme

Show the mark scheme The mark scheme is a table for questions 06.1 to 06.4. For 06.1 it awards marks for a filament lamp I–V curve that passes through the origin, lies in the first and third quadrants, and has decreasing gradient. For 06.2 it credits comparisons such as I1 = I2 + I3, I2 = I3, and therefore I1 = 2I2 or 2I3. For 06.3 it shows using 3 = I squared times 12 to find I = 0.5 A for each lamp, then either Q = 0.5 × 60 = 30 for one branch and total charge 60 C through the cell, or total current 1.0 A followed by Q = 60 C; unit accepted is coulombs or C. For 06.4 it uses a level-of-response scheme and indicative points that increased light intensity decreases LDR resistance, decreases total circuit resistance, increases current and ammeter reading, and because potential difference is shared in series, the potential difference across the LDR decreases so the voltmeter reading decreases.

AO /

Question Answers Extra information Mark

Spec. Ref.

06.1 a curve in the first and third 1 AO1

quadrants only, passing through 6.2.1.4

origin

decreasing gradient 1

06.2 any two from: 2 AO2

• I1 = I2 + I3 6.2.2

• I2 = I3

• I1 = 2I2

• I1 = 2I3 allow 1 mark for each correct

description given in words

06.3 an answer of 60 scores 5

calculation marks

3 = I2 × 12 1 AO2

6.2.4.1

1 6.2.4.2

I = �� �

I = 0.5 (A) 1

Q = 0.5 × 60 = 30 allow Q = 1

their calculated I × 60

Qtotal = 60 allow an answer that is 1

consistent with their calculated

value of I

or

3 = I2 × 12 (1)

I = �� � (1)

I = 0.5 (A) (1)

Itotal = 1.0 (A) (1) allow Itotal = their I × 2

Q = 1.0 × 60 = 60 (1) allow an answer that is

consistent with their calculated

value of I

coulombs or C 1 AO1

AO / 13

Question Answers Mark

Spec. Ref.

06.4 Level 3: Relevant points (reasons / causes) are identified, given in 5–6 AO3

detail and logically linked to form a clear account.

Level 2: Relevant points (reasons / causes) are identified, and 3–4 AO2

there are attempts at logically linking. The resulting account is not

fully clear.

Level 1: Points are identified and stated simply, but their relevance 1–2 AO2

is not clear and there is no attempt at logical linking.

No relevant content 0

Indicative content 6.2.1.1

6.2.1.4

• resistance of LDR changes when light intensity changes

• when light intensity increase resistance of LDR decreases

• overall resistance of circuit decreases

• potential difference across total resistance remains

unchanged

• current in ammeter increases

• potential difference across fixed resistor increases

• potential difference across LDR decreases

• reading on the voltmeter decreases

• potential difference is shared between the components in

series

• the lower the resistance of the LDR the smaller the share of

the potential difference

• reading on the voltmeter decreases

Total 16

How to answer it

Standard Demand

Filament Lamps: Graphs, Currents and an LDR circuit

What this question tests

This question checks whether you can draw and interpret a filament lamp I-V graph, use current in a parallel circuit, carry out a power / current / charge calculation, and explain how an LDR circuit changes when light intensity changes.

Full marks depend on using the correct physics ideas, showing working clearly, and linking cause → effect → meter reading.

Question part (a): Sketch a current-potential difference graph for a filament lamp

06.1 — 2 marks

✅ Correct answer

  • A curve in the first and third quadrants only.
  • The graph must pass through the origin.
  • The line should have a decreasing gradient as potential difference increases.

💡 Key knowledge

  • A filament lamp is non-ohmic, so current is not directly proportional to potential difference.
  • As current increases, the filament gets hotter.
  • Higher temperature means higher resistance, so the current rises less quickly.

🧠 Exam technique

  • For 2 marks, one mark is usually for the correct shape / quadrant and one for the decreasing gradient.
  • Make sure your curve is smooth, not a straight line.
  • Use the axes correctly: current on the vertical axis, potential difference on the horizontal axis.

❌ Common errors

  • Drawing a straight line like an ohmic conductor.
  • Putting the curve in the wrong quadrants.
  • Forgetting that it must go through the origin.
  • Making the gradient increase instead of decrease.
Examiner tip: Top answers showed the correct shape and clearly indicated that the graph becomes flatter as potential difference increases.

Question part (b): Compare the currents I₁, I₂ and I₃

06.2 — 2 marks

✅ Correct answer

  • I₂ = I₃
  • I₁ = I₂ + I₃
  • So I₁ = 2I₂ and I₁ = 2I₃

💡 Key knowledge

  • The lamps are identical.
  • They are connected in parallel, so each branch gets the same potential difference.
  • Identical components in parallel carry the same current.
  • The current from the cell splits between the branches.

🧠 Exam technique

  • Use a clear comparison sentence or equations.
  • Marks are for the relationship, not just saying “same” or “double” with no explanation.
  • If writing in words, say that the total current is the sum of the branch currents.

❌ Common errors

  • Saying all three currents are equal.
  • Forgetting that I₁ is the total current in the main loop.
  • Mixing up series and parallel rules.
Examiner insight: The mark scheme allowed either equations or correct descriptions in words. To gain both marks, link the identical lamps to equal branch currents, then state that the supply current is the sum of the two branches.

Question part (c): Calculate the charge that flows through the cell in 1 minute

06.3 — 6 marks

📐 Calculations: step-by-step

  1. Use power = current² × resistance
    P = I²R
  2. Substitute values for one lamp:
    3 = I² × 12
  3. Rearrange:
    I² = 3 ÷ 12 = 0.25
  4. Take the square root:
    I = √0.25 = 0.5 A
  5. There are two identical lamps in parallel, so total current is:
    I_total = 0.5 + 0.5 = 1.0 A
  6. Use charge = current × time
    Q = I × t
  7. Convert time: 1 minute = 60 s
    Q = 1.0 × 60 = 60 C

✅ Correct answer

  • Charge = 60 C
  • Unit = coulombs or C

💡 Key knowledge

  • P = I²R is useful when power and resistance are given.
  • Q = I × t tells you charge from current and time.
  • In a parallel circuit, the total current is the sum of the branch currents.
  • Always use seconds for time in charge calculations.

🧠 Exam technique

  • Write the equations first to secure method marks.
  • Show the substitution clearly.
  • Include the unit in your final answer.
  • Round sensibly: 0.5 A and 1.0 A are both acceptable, but keep consistency.

❌ Common errors

  • Using P = IV without finding the current or voltage correctly.
  • Forgetting that there are two lamps, so the cell current is doubled.
  • Using 1 minute as 1 second.
  • Giving the answer in amps instead of coulombs.
  • Missing the final unit mark.
How the marks are awarded: The scheme gives method marks for using the correct equation and rearrangement, then marks for finding the current in one lamp, total current, charge, and correct unit. A fully consistent answer based on the student’s current also scores.

Question part (d): Explain how the meter readings change when environmental conditions change

06.4 — 6 marks

✅ Correct answer

When the environmental conditions change so that light intensity increases, the resistance of the LDR decreases. This makes the total resistance of the circuit decrease, so the current in the ammeter increases.

The potential difference is shared between components in series. Because the LDR now has a lower resistance, it takes a smaller share of the potential difference, so the voltmeter reading decreases.

💡 Key knowledge

  • An LDR has lower resistance when light intensity increases.
  • In a series circuit, increasing one component’s resistance affects the whole circuit.
  • Current increases when total resistance decreases, assuming the battery voltage stays the same.
  • Potential difference is shared between series components.

🧠 Exam technique

  • For 5–6 marks, write a linked explanation: change in light → change in LDR resistance → change in total resistance → change in current → change in voltmeter reading.
  • Use the meter names correctly: ammeter increases, voltmeter decreases.
  • Top-level answers explained why the voltmeter changes, not just what happens.

❌ Common errors

  • Saying only “the readings change” with no explanation.
  • Mixing up the meters: ammeter measures current, voltmeter measures potential difference.
  • Saying the voltmeter increases when the LDR resistance falls.
  • Forgetting to mention that the supply potential difference stays the same.

📐 Best answer structure for 06.4

  1. State the change: light intensity increases.
  2. Explain the LDR: its resistance decreases.
  3. Link to circuit: total resistance decreases.
  4. State current change: ammeter reading increases.
  5. Explain voltage division: less pd across the LDR / voltmeter.
  6. Final meter reading: voltmeter reading decreases.
Examiner commentary: Level 3 answers were clear, logically linked, and used the correct physics language. Students lost marks when they described changes without explaining the chain of cause and effect, especially the idea that the LDR’s resistance changes the share of potential difference in a series circuit.

Quick recap: the key answers

✅ 06.1

Curve in first and third quadrants, through the origin, decreasing gradient.

✅ 06.2

I₂ = I₃ and I₁ = I₂ + I₃

✅ 06.3

60 C and unit C

✅ 06.4

Ammeter reading increases; voltmeter reading decreases when light intensity increases.

Topics

Physics · P2: Electricity

Question and mark scheme from the AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy examination, Physics Paper 1 (Higher), 2018. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.