Edexcel A-Level Chemistry AS Paper 1, June 2016: Question 4
7 marks · Medium difficulty · Short Open Response
Identify four colourless solutions (hydrochloric acid, magnesium sulfate, potassium chloride, sodium carbonate) using various chemical and physical tests including flame tests, barium chloride, silver nitrate, and carbonate reactions.
Practise this questionQuestion
Question text
4 The labels on four colourless solutions had fallen off in storage. It was known that the
solutions were:
hydrochloric acid magnesium sulfate
potassium chloride sodium carbonate
In order to identify each solution, a number of tests were carried out.
(a) Solutions can be sprayed into a flame to produce a flame colour identical to that
seen in the more conventional method with a solid on a nichrome wire.
Which solution would produce a lilac flame?
(1)
A hydrochloric acid
B magnesium sulfate
C potassium chloride
D sodium carbonate
(b) Which of the following diagrams best illustrates the electronic transitions that
take place during a flame test?
(1)
Excited State Excited State
Energy Released Energy Released
Ground State Ground State
A B
Excited State Excited State
Energy Released Energy Released Energy Released
Ground State Ground State
C D
(c) Which solution produces a white precipitate with acidified barium chloride solution?
(1)
A hydrochloric acid
B magnesium sulfate
8 C potassium chloride
D sodium carbonate*P49837A0820*
(d) Two of the solutions produce the same result on the addition of dilute nitric acid
followed by silver nitrate solution.
State the observation with this test and the two solutions that give this result.
(2)
Observation …
Solutions …
(e) The hydrochloric acid and the sodium carbonate solution react together. State an
observation you would make and write the ionic equation for the reaction. State
symbols are not required.
(2)
Observation …
Ionic equation
(Total for Question 4 = 7 marks)
Mark scheme
Show the mark scheme
How to answer it
Identifying Unknown Solutions via Analytical Tests
What this question tests
This question assesses your core practical knowledge of qualitative inorganic analysis. You are tested on flame test colours, the underlying quantum transitions in flame tests, characteristic ionic precipitation tests (sulfates with acidified barium chloride, halides with acidified silver nitrate), and observations/ionic equations for acid-carbonate reactions.
Part (a) — Flame Tests
Identifying the solution that produces a lilac flame
✅ Correct Answer
C (potassium chloride)
💡 Key Knowledge
- Potassium ions ( K⁺ ) produce a lilac flame.
- Sodium ions ( Na⁺ ) produce a yellow/orange flame.
- Barium ions ( Ba²⁺ ) produce a pale green flame.
Part (b) — Electronic Transitions in Flame Tests
Understanding energy levels and light emission
✅ Correct Answer
B
💡 Key Knowledge
- Heat energy causes electrons to be promoted from the ground state to an excited state (absorption).
- When electrons fall back down from an excited state to the ground state, energy is released as electromagnetic radiation (light).
- Diagram B correctly shows an arrow starting at the upper excited state and pointing downwards to the lower ground state, with the label Energy Released .
Part (c) — Sulfate Identification
Precipitation reactions with acidified barium chloride
✅ Correct Answer
B (magnesium sulfate)
💡 Key Knowledge
- To test for sulfate ions ( SO₄²⁻ ), add acidified barium chloride solution ( BaCl₂ ).
- A positive result is the formation of a white precipitate of barium sulfate ( BaSO₄ ).
- Magnesium sulfate is the only solution provided containing sulfate ions.
Part (d) — Halide Identification
Nitric acid and silver nitrate test
✅ Correct Answer
Observation: White precipitate (or white solid)
Solutions: Hydrochloric acid and potassium chloride (Accept HCl and KCl , or A and C)
🧠 Exam Technique
Both solutions contain chloride ions ( Cl⁻ ). When reacted with acidified silver nitrate ( AgNO₃ ), they form silver chloride, which is a white precipitate.
❌ Common Errors
Students often lose marks by writing "off-white" or describing a cloudy solution instead of explicitly stating white precipitate. Make sure to use standard terminology.
Part (e) — Acid-Carbonate Reaction
Observations and ionic equations
✅ Correct Answer
Observation: Fizzing / bubbles / effervescence
Ionic equation: 2H⁺ + CO₃²⁻ → CO₂ + H₂O
💡 Key Knowledge
Acids react with carbonates to produce a salt, water, and carbon dioxide gas. The visible sign of carbon dioxide gas being evolved is effervescence (fizzing).
❌ Common Errors
Do not write "solid dissolves" or refer to hydrogen gas ( H₂ ). The gas evolved is carbon dioxide from the carbonate ion.
Topics
Inorganic Chemistry · Core Practicals · Topic 4: Inorganic Chemistry and the Periodic Table · Core Practical 7: Identify unknown organic liquids and inorganic solids
Question and mark scheme from the Edexcel A-Level Chemistry examination, AS Paper 1, June 2016. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.