AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy Physics Paper 1 (Higher), 2024: Question 4

11 marks · Standard Demand difficulty · Extended Answer

Describe energy store changes and calculate the drone’s height and maximum possible speed after the motor is switched off using gravitational potential energy and kinetic energy equations.

Practise this question

Question

The question page shows Question 04 about a battery-powered drone controlled remotely, with a small black-and-white drawing of a person about to launch the drone labelled Figure 5. Part 04.1 asks for two changes to the drone’s energy stores as it moves at constant speed and gains height, stating that its thermal store increases, for 2 marks. Part 04.2 states the drone reached a height of 840 m, the motor was switched off, then switched back on after it had fallen; the change in gravitational potential energy during the fall is 3920 J, the mass is 2.5 kg, and gravitational field strength is 9.8 N/kg, and asks for the height above the ground when the motor was switched back on, for 4 marks. Part 04.3 states the kinetic energy when the motor was switched off was 150 J and asks for the maximum possible speed when the motor was switched back on, using the Physics Equations Sheet and giving the answer in km/s, for 5 marks.
Question text

04 A drone is a miniature aircraft that has a remote control.

An inventor designed a battery powered drone.

The inventor tested what would happen if the battery runs out of charge during

a flight.

Figure 5 shows the inventor about to launch the drone.

Figure 5

04.1 After the drone was launched, it moved at a constant speed and gained height.

The thermal stores of energy of the drone increased.

Describe two other changes to the energy stores of the drone as it moved at a

constant speed and gained height.

[2 marks]

When the drone reached a height of 840 m the motor was switched off.

The motor was switched back on after a short time, when the drone had fallen to a

lower height above the ground.

The change in gravitational potential energy of the drone during the fall to this lower

height was 3920 J.

The mass of the drone is 2.5 kg.

gravitational field strength = 9.8 N/kg

04.2 Calculate the height above the ground of the drone when the motor was switched

back on.

Use the Physics Equations Sheet.

[4 marks]

Height above ground =17 m

04.3 When the motor was switched off, the kinetic energy of the drone was 150 J.

Calculate the maximum possible speed of the drone when the motor was switched

back on.

Use the Physics Equations Sheet.

Give your answer in km/s.

[5 marks]

Maximum possible speed of drone = km/s

Mark scheme

Show the mark scheme Mark scheme for AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy Physics Paper 1 (Higher), 2024: Question 4

Question 4

AO /

Question Answers Extra information Mark

Spec. Ref.

04.1 chemical store of energy 1 AO2

decreases 6.1.1.1

gravitational potential energy of 1

the drone increases

AO /

Spec. Ref.

04.2 3920 = 2.5 × 9.8 × Δh 1 AO2

6.1.1.2

3920 1

Δh =

2.5 × 9.8

Δh = 160 (m) 1

(840 − 160) = 680 (m) allow an answer consistent with 1

their calculated value of Δh

using the correct equation

OR

Initial Ep = 2.5 × 9.8 × 840 (1) allow initial Ep = 20580

Final 𝐸 (= 20580 − 3920) allow correct use of an

p

= 16660 (1) incorrectly calculated value of Ep

using the gravitational potential

energy equation

16660 allow a correct substitution and

h = (1) rearrangement using their

2.5 × 9.8

calculated value of Ep using the

gravitational potential energy

equation

= 680 (m) (1) allow an answer consistent with

their calculated value of Ep using

– the gravitational potential energy– –

equation

AO /

Spec. Ref. 13

04.3 max Ek = 3920 + 150 (= 4070 J) allow max Ek = 4070 J 1 AO2

6.1.1.2

4070 = 0.5 × 2.5 × v2 allow a substitution using their 1

value for kinetic energy

4070 allow a correct re-arrangement 1

v =√ using their value for kinetic

0.5×2.5

energy

2 4070

allow v =

0.5 × 2.5

v = 57.06… (m/s) allow v = 57 (m/s) 1

v = 0.057… (km/s) allow an answer consistent with 1

their calculated value for v using

the kinetic energy equation

Total Question 4 11

How to answer it

Drone Energy Changes and Calculations

What this question tests

You need to understand energy stores and transfers in a moving object, use gravitational potential energy and kinetic energy equations, and show clear multi-step calculations with correct units. The question also tests whether you can identify the energy store that decreases as the drone uses its battery.

Question 04.1

Part (a): Changes in the drone’s energy stores

Describe two other changes to the energy stores of the drone as it moved at a constant speed and gained height.

✅ Correct answers

  • Chemical store of energy decreases in the battery.
  • Gravitational potential energy of the drone increases.
Each correct change = 1 mark. The question already told you that thermal energy increases, so you needed two other changes.

💡 Key knowledge

  • A battery stores energy chemically.
  • When the drone is rising, its height increases, so its gravitational potential energy increases.
  • Because it moved at constant speed, its kinetic energy stayed the same.

🧠 Exam technique

  • Use the exact energy-store names from GCSE Physics.
  • If the question says “other changes”, do not repeat thermal energy.
  • “Battery runs out” links directly to chemical store decreases.

❌ Common errors

  • Saying kinetic energy increases even though the speed is constant.
  • Writing only “energy increases” without naming the store.
  • Confusing gravitational potential energy with “height” but not stating the energy store.
Question 04.2

Part (b): Finding the height when the motor was switched back on

The drone fell and lost 3920 J of gravitational potential energy. Find the new height above the ground.

📐 Calculations: step-by-step

  1. Use the equation: ΔE_p = m × g × Δh
  2. Substitute the values: 3920 = 2.5 × 9.8 × Δh
  3. Rearrange: Δh = 3920 ÷ (2.5 × 9.8)
  4. Calculate the height fallen: Δh = 160 m
  5. Find the new height: 840 − 160 = 680 m
Final answer: 680 m

✅ Correct answer

Height above ground = 680 m

This full-mark answer can be shown either by finding the change in height first, or by finding the final gravitational potential energy and then converting it back to height.

🧠 Exam technique

  • Always use ΔE_p = mgh for a change in height.
  • Keep units consistent: mass in kg, g in N/kg, height in m, energy in J.
  • Show substitution clearly to secure method marks.
  • If you get an answer from an alternative correct method, it can still score full marks if it is consistent.

❌ Common errors

  • Using 840 m as the height in the equation instead of the height lost.
  • Forgetting to subtract from 840 m at the end.
  • Rearranging incorrectly and dividing by only one number instead of 2.5 × 9.8 .
  • Leaving the answer as 160 m — that is the distance fallen, not the final height.

💡 Why the mark scheme gives full marks here

The examiner awards marks for: 1) writing the correct equation, 2) substituting the correct values, 3) finding the change in height, and 4) getting the final height of 680 m.

Question 04.3

Part (c): Maximum possible speed when the motor was switched back on

Use the kinetic energy and the gained gravitational potential energy to find the speed in km/s.

📐 Calculations: step-by-step

  1. The drone had 150 J of kinetic energy when the motor was switched off.
  2. It also lost 3920 J of gravitational potential energy during the fall.
  3. So the maximum kinetic energy when the motor was switched back on is:
    4070 J = 3920 + 150
  4. Use the kinetic energy equation:
    E_k = 0.5 × m × v²
  5. Substitute the values:
    4070 = 0.5 × 2.5 × v²
  6. Rearrange:
    v = √(4070 ÷ (0.5 × 2.5))
  7. Calculate:
    v ≈ 57.1 m/s
  8. Convert to km/s:
    57.1 m/s = 0.0571 km/s
Final answer: 0.057 km/s (accept 0.0571 km/s)

✅ Correct answer

Maximum possible speed = 0.057 km/s

Equivalent values accepted: 57 m/s or 57.1 m/s before conversion.

🧠 Exam technique

  • In “maximum possible speed” questions, assume the energy transfer is ideal unless told otherwise.
  • Use the correct equation: E_k = 0.5mv² .
  • Make sure you include the extra 150 J from the kinetic energy already present.
  • Convert your final answer to the unit asked: km/s, not m/s.

❌ Common errors

  • Using 3920 J only and forgetting the original 150 J.
  • Getting v² but forgetting to square root.
  • Leaving the answer in m/s when the question asks for km/s.
  • Using the wrong formula, such as E_p = mgh .

💡 Examiner insight

Students often lost marks by not combining the energy values correctly. The top-level responses were the ones that: added 3920 J and 150 J, used the kinetic energy equation correctly, and then converted m/s to km/s.

Quick recall

Useful equations and facts from this question

💡 Key knowledge

  • E_p = mgh
  • E_k = 0.5mv²
  • Energy in joules: J
  • Mass in kilograms: kg
  • g = 9.8 N/kg

🧠 How to get full marks

  • State the equation first.
  • Substitute numbers carefully.
  • Show rearrangement.
  • Finish with the answer and the correct unit.

❌ Calculation traps

  • Forgetting the ×0.5 in kinetic energy.
  • Using 840 m instead of the drop in height.
  • Mixing up change in GPE with final GPE.
  • Not converting to km/s at the end.

Topics

Physics · P1: Energy

Question and mark scheme from the AQA GCSE Combined Science: Trilogy examination, Physics Paper 1 (Higher), 2024. QuestionVault is an independent revision resource; questions remain the copyright of the awarding body.